‘Another Gospel’ or ‘A remaining tension’? Methodist Arminianism in Great Britain from the Free Grace Controversy to the Anglican-Methodist Covenant, 1740-2004
From its origins in the eighteenth-century Evangelical Revival, Methodism in the tradition of the Wesleys has defined itself as confidently and robustly Arminian. This has been a marker of Methodist identity, and it has influenced evangelistic and pastoral practice. After a century of vigorous debate with the proponents of Reformed theology, Calvinist/Arminian polemics diminished from the latter part of the nineteenth century, while from the mid-twentieth century Methodism’s evangelical Arminianism was gradually re-cast into an emphasis on breadth, tolerance, and inclusivity. This paper will track the trajectory of Arminianism in British Methodism from the Wesleys to the present-day, looking particularly at post-Wesley developments, including the reframing or replacement of Arminianism over the past century and the presence or absence of this doctrinal emphasis in ecumenical dialogues.