You are here

Online Program Book

PLEASE NOTE: We are working on making updates and edits to finalize the program. If you are searching for something and cannot find it, please reach out to annualmeeting@aarweb.org.

The AAR's inaugural Online June Sessions of the Annual Meetings were held on June 25, 26, and 27, 2024. For program questions, please reach out to annualmeeting@aarweb.org.

This is the preliminary program for the 2024 in-person Annual Meeting, hosted with the Society for Biblical Literature in San Diego, CA - November 23-26. Pre-conference workshops and many committee meetings will be held November 22. If you have questions about the program, contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org. All times are listed in local/Pacific Time.

M23-104

Saturday, 11:30 AM - 1:30 PM

Grand Hyatt-Torrey Hills AB (Third Level - Seaport Tower)

Launched in 2023, Theologia seeks to promote and celebrate women working in the field of Christian theology through an annual networking event and to encourage these scholars by cultivating spaces for fellowship, mentoring, and academic engagement among women in Christian theology. 

If you are a woman and consider yourself a Christian and theologian (even if en route), please join us the Saturday of AAR/SBL as we gather for lunch, fellowship, and a short program featuring reflections from Katherine Sonderegger, Distinguished Professor of Systematic Theology, Virginia Theological Seminary.

We welcome women who are members of the American Academy of Religion, members of the Evangelical Theological Society, women pastor theologians, and beyond.

Advance registration is required to attend. To cover the cost of the event, attendees will also be asked to contribute $20. Financial help is available. 

Please register here: https://www.westernsem.edu/theologia/

We can only guarantee spots for the first 65 who register, given our room capacity.

This lunch is co-sponsored by Baker Academic, Baylor University Press, Wipf and Stock Publishers, Zondervan Academic, Western Theological Seminary, and the John Templeton Foundation. 

For further information, contact Kristen Deede Johnson (Kristen.johnson@westernsem.edu) or Christa McKirland (christa.mckirland@carey.ac.nz).

P23-105

Saturday, 11:30 AM - 1:30 PM

Grand Hyatt-Coronado D (Fourth Level)

This mealtime gathering, for those who identify as BIPOC faculty, is a place for fellowship, connection, and mutual support. Hear about Wabash Center grants specifically allocated for BIPOC peer mentoring. The mealtime conversation will explore self-care and wellness as a fundamental component of the teaching life. Being healthy, getting healthy, staying health, is an essential aspect needed to successfully navigate the classroom, your institution, and academic career. Gather with a network that cares about life-affirming teaching and faculty formation. Please register directly on our website or at this link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeb3oDM9TAdiHFE3dbkT8N6mTWr_pOU...

M23-200

Saturday, 12:00 PM - 1:00 PM

Marriott Marquis-Rancho Sante Fe Rooms (North Tower - Lobby Level)

Welcome to the Christian Scholarship Foundation reception! We are delighted to have you join us for this special luncheon to reconnect with each other.

A23-200

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Cobalt 520 (Fifth Level)

.

  • On Rupture and Contempt: Pentecostal Receptions of the Second World Black and African Festival of Arts and Culture

    Abstract

    This paper analyzes Nigerian Pentecostal receptions of the Second World Black and African Festival of Arts and Culture (FESTAC ‘77) and engages existing narratives of “rupture” used to characterize Nigerian Pentecostalism. In doing so, this paper seeks to offer an alternative account of Pentecostal relationships to the imagined “past” associated with Orisa traditions—focusing on “contempt” rather than “rupture”—that can account for both violent rejection of Orisa among Pentecostals as well as the presence of Orisa in Pentecostal religiosity. What may seem a rupture or break with the past, can alternatively be seen as Pentecostals inhabiting a contemptuous posture towards specific objects (groups, traditions, people, etc.). While Pentecostals consistently narrate the rise of Christianity as a break from a “dark” non-Christian past, Pentecostals in Nigeria and the diaspora draw from Orisa cosmologies and traditions while sustaining a theologically generative posture of contempt towards those same traditions.

  • Muslim Women on the Air and in the Workplace: Insights from Ethnographic Work at a Tanzanian Radio Station

    Abstract

    The study explores Tanzanian women's engagement with Islam through an ethnography of Radio Nuur, a non-denominational Islamic station in Tanga, Tanzania. Based on participant observation and interviews, the research investigates the discourse types and ideologies broadcasted, emphasizing women's participation and perspectives. Contrary to other stations, Radio Nuur actively involves women, both as staff and callers, potentially increasing their "voice" in the workplace and community. I examine how radio discourse shapes Tanzanian Muslims' sense of belonging to local and global religious communities and influences their interpretations of gender roles amidst diverse religious discourses. By studying media's role in constructing community identities and negotiating various ideological influences, the research sheds light on gendered communication dynamics within Tanzania and beyond, impacting understandings of Islam's local and global dimensions.

  • “The Inheritors of the Prophets”: Islamic Historical Memory along the Swahili Coast

    Abstract

    This paper engages Islamic frameworks of historical memory along the Swahili coast. It argues that Swahili ideas of inheritance (*urithi*) formulate a dynamic and generative way in which Muslim scholars and biographers articulate and live with Islamic pasts and religious memory along the coast. Building on anthropological approaches to history and memory as well as work concerning Islamic historiography, I explore *urithi*’s significance as a Swahili-Islamic ordering of the past based in a spiritual tradition that posits knowledge as a meaningful historical inheritance and Islamic scholars as “inheritors of the Prophets” and thus bearers of religious memory. These arguments are based on analysis of two biographical texts covering the lives of pioneering reformist Swahili-Muslim scholars, Sheikh Al-Amin b. Ali Mazrui (d. 1947) and Sheikh Abdulla Saleh Al-Farsy (d. 1982). My analysis is further informed by insights gathered from various interviews with the authors of these biographies.

  • On the Portuguese Influence on the Early Development of African Catholicism: The Case of Annobon

    Abstract

    In my book Afro-Atlantic Catholics: America's First Black Christians (2022), which will be discussed at a roundtable in the 2024 AAR conference, I present a new theory on the development of Black Christianity in the Americas. The goal of this paper is to complement this panel discussion with a presenation that debates the Portuguese influence on the early development of African Catholicism. It does so with a focus on the little-known African Atlantic island of Annobón. 

A23-201

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Cobalt 502A (Fifth Level)

This session aims to explore the significant contributions of the anthropological perspective to Jain Studies, highlighting the work of both emerging and senior scholars who have conducted extensive fieldwork in India. Ethnographic methods and anthropological concepts have played a constitutive role in shaping the field of Jain Studies. Participants will reflect on how these approaches have influenced their own scholarship and fieldwork with Jain communities, fostering understanding of Jain society and practice. In light of the recent passing of anthropologist Lawrence A. (Alan) Babb, this panel also serves as a tribute to the influence of his scholarship and enduring legacy in the field. Through engaging overlaps and intersections of anthropology and Jain Studies around positionality in the field, ritual culture and practice, social organization, and theory, this conversation aims to stimulate critical dialogue and inspire fresh insights into the changing dynamics of Jain culture and society and its academic study.

  • Lawrence A. (Alan) Babb and the Study of the Jains

    Abstract

    The study of the Jains was transformed in the 1980s and 1990s when anthropologists and fieldwork oriented scholars in other fields turned their attention to contemporary Jain communities. Lawrence A. (Alan) Babb was a key person in this turn in Jain Studies, beginning with his fieldwork on Jain ritual transactions in Ahmedabad in 1986 and Jaipur in 1990-91, leading to his 1996 Absent Lord. For many of these scholars, fieldwork with Jains was their starting point in the study of South Asia. Babb, however, brought two decades of previous scholarship to his study of the Jains, having previously engaged in fieldwork on Hindu rituals in Chhattisgarh, Singapore and Delhi. This paper looks at this earlier scholarship, arguing the advantages for a fuller understanding of Babb’s scholarship on the Jains, and Jain studies as a whole, of situating Absent Lord and Babb’s subsequent scholarship on the Jains within this longer arc.

  • Jainism and the Spirit of Capitalism? Foreign and Vernacular Practices of Comparison

    Abstract

    This paper revisits the works of Max Weber, particularly The Protestant Ethic and The Spirit of Capitalism alongside his Religions of India, to ask what is at stake in comparing the Jains to other groups. As Alan Babb has argued, Weber never actually asserts that the Jains are the Protestants of India; nevertheless, the comparison persists. Based on fieldwork conducted from 2018-2023, attention is then drawn to vernacular practices of comparison between Jains and other foreign groups by Jains and non-Jains alike: comparisons that often involve a theological dimension, but rest on sociological assumptions about both Jains and the nature of commerce itself. These comparisons reveal the continuing salience of the caste category baniya, glossed by the Subaltern Studies scholar David Hardiman as “usurer,” for understanding contemporary Jain communities, as well as the economic system that they are the “spirit” of.

  • Emergence of Spiritual Tourism: Exploring Contemporary Trends in Religious Practice Among Jains in Jaipur

    Abstract

    This paper aims to explore the intersection of religious sites, tourism, and Jains in Jaipur to demonstrate the emerging trend of spiritual tourism within contemporary Jainism. While both religion and tourism have independently flourished in Jaipur and have been extensively studied across various contexts and methodologies, their symbiotic relationship remains relatively underexplored. Drawing from my fieldwork in Jaipur and building on the works of anthropologist Lawrence Babb, this paper proposes to discuss “spiritual tourism,” a third ideology. This ideology motivates an increasing number of Jains to engage in religious practices and its growing significance in the social, devotional, and economic lives of the Jains in Jaipur. Through this investigation, the paper also seeks to underpin the impact of such phenomenon on the individual and collective identities of religious groups within the broader framework of South Asian traditions.

  • Rethinking Theorization(s) of Jain Ritual from the Domestic Dying Space

    Abstract

    Because of the Durkheimian idea of ritual space set apart, the domestic has been largely excluded or described in limited terms as a space of ritual possibility. This raises questions about gendered participation in ritual innovation. Formative schematic theorizations of Jain ritual emphasize practices such as puja that are sited in the temple. Sallekhanā, the voluntary Jain fast until death, is a continuation of renunciation of food and effacement of the embodied self that begins in a plethora of small quotidian acts within the domestic space, making the seemingly dramatic withdrawal from life a conceptual continuity with everyday ritualization. Ritual dispersal in everyday life entails vulnerability which is differently embodied and distributed across age and gender within family and household. This paper proposes that gendered norms of ritualization and ritual pedagogy in the domestic sphere, exemplified in the practice of sallekhanā, demand a rethinking of the boundaries of Jain ritual.

  • Gotras, Grandfathers, and Grand-gurus: The Transformation from Monastic to Biological Lineages

    Abstract

    While theoretically casteless, Jain participation in and development of caste identities, especially as vaiśyas, has been well-documented. Alan Babb’s 2004 Alchemies of Violence, for example, studied the development of Marwari Jain trader caste identity, typically in contradistinction to Brahman and Kshatriya caste identity. This study examines the development of four relatively new gotras that trace their origin from Śvetāmbar yatis, a special category of monks that follow an alternative interpretation of Jain monastic conduct. Some yatis, or former-yatis according to some, were known to take wives and father children. These children inherited their monastic parentage’s property, maintained the social networks of their predecessors, and continued their ritual practices. The existence of these gotras creates tension among yati monks and the broader Jain community by forcing them to consider the caste status of someone who walks back their renunciation and to deal with the social implications of their renewed worldly life.

A23-202

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-6D (Upper Level West)

Art Theology is a method of making art to make new knowledge and understanding of theological ideas that discursive reasoning alone cannot provide.  This interactive and collaborative workshop will engage participants in making theology.  Participants will be invited to gather their own experience, knowledge, and wisdom through various materials (pastels, paints, colored pencils, markers, crayons, fabrics, and colored paper will all be supplied). We will make theology on the question: What is divine love in the margins? and/or What is non-violence?  We will then discuss the emerging ideas of art historians and cognitive scientists, which explain how Art Theology arrives at different knowledge than discursive reasoning. Art Theology is an interdisciplinary method that centers on indigenous wisdom like the Matauranga Maori of Aotearoa, New Zealand, which has always included a variety of ways of accessing knowledge, including making art.

  • Art Theology, Seeing what we Overlooked and Making New Knowledge

    Abstract

    Art Theology is a method that engages in making art in order to make new knowledge and understanding about theological ideas that discursive reasoning alone cannot provide.  Art Theology includes seeing art (with intention), but it is even more importantly about making art.  Art Theology is an interdisciplinary method grounded in the scholarship of art historians, Susanna Berger and Eyelet Evens-Ezra who have demonstrated that we have not fully understood theologians and philosophers before the 18th century because we overlooked their visual thinking.  The method is also grounded in the emerging cognitive science of The Extended Mind Theory.  Art Theology centers indigenous wisdom like matauranga Maori of Aotearoa New Zealand, that has never overlooked making in knowing.  This paper provides the research behind the workshop offered by the Arts, Literature, and Religion Unit: Art Theology, Non-Violence, and Wisdom from the Margins.

  • Workshop application: “Art Theology, Non-Violence, and Wisdom from Margins”

    Abstract

    I have explored practices of improvisation not only as spiritual practices, but as enacted and embodied theology. For example, art and improvisation can be understood through theologies of co-creating with God, of responding to God, and of understanding creation as both human and divine. I focused on musical and dance improvisation and would welcome this opportunity to delve into the visual arts as theology. My current work centers practices of deep listening in community-engaged scholarship. This work continues to attend to dynamics of improvisation in order to pay attention to “wisdom from the margins” through listening and responding, co-creating, and engaging in practices that center belonging, compassion, and attunement over extractive methods of gathering information. This work takes time, space, and slowing down, all practices offered through Art Theology that could also serve to guide academic and ethnographic work in kinder and more attuned ways.

  • Submission for Workshop: “Art Theology, Non-Violence, and Wisdom from Margins"

A23-203

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Cobalt 500 (Fifth Level)

This session explores the ways APIA communities in the United States have navigated the various state institutions and theological discourses that enact, perpetuate, and enforce the organizing logics of American secularism. It will open with a historical analysis of the theological presuppositions built into the nation's secularist legal regimes as they applied to Chinese laborers, followed by a contemporary exploration of processes by which Hindu ritual practices at a New Jersey temple have been reshaped to address secular assumptions of American life. A final paper then returns to the late-nineteenth century to scrutinize how the translation practices of Japanese Pure Land Buddhists influenced the community's legibility as "religion" within the American context.

 

  • Beyond Dichotomies: The Secular and Religious Interplay at the Swaminarayan Hindu Temple Inauguration in the USA

    Abstract

    This paper examines the interplay between the secular and religious dimensions of the "Festival of Inspirations" at the Swaminarayan Hindu temple, Akshardham, in NJ, USA. As the largest Hindu temple in the Western hemisphere, Akshardham epitomizes Hindu art, architecture, culture, spirituality, and modern secular facets. Utilizing textual, media, and ethnographic research, this paper illustrates not only the mutual influence of the religious and secular but also the fluid and inseparable nature of these categories, and argues for the theoretical integration of these two categories. It contends that reshaping religious practices to address secular concerns and adapt to changing facets of modernity brings about everyday experiences among practitioners that are simultaneously immanent and transcendent, personal and political. Its data-driven arguments also raise crucial questions within the broader discourse on secularism and secularization, and address them from within the perspective of treating the secular and the religious as fundamentally inseparable theoretical categories.

  • Translating Amida: Transpacific Japanese Pure Land Buddhism and Religio-Linguistic Translation

    Abstract

    When Japanese Pure Land Buddhists came to the United States and Hawaii in the late-nineteenth century, they often translated their religion and traditions into the English language so they could be comprehensible to state institutions and cultural observers. Linguistic translations proved necessary for both simple material reasons, such as filling out legal forms and interacting with American society, and also complex ideological reasons, such as rendering religious expressions, practices, and structures in terms consistent with American definitions of religion. This essay argues Pure Land Buddhist translations between Japanese and English were a function of competing transpacific imperial political projects asserting distinct legal definitions of religion and modernity. An analysis of Japanese and English-language Pure Land Buddhist documents and texts from around the turn of the century demonstrates that language and linguistic translation are significant mechanisms of secular governance and societal power to shape foreign communities into legible subjects.

  • Asian American in BIPOC: Confronting the Model Minority Myth and Reclaiming Asian American Mental Health in Wake Up Saṅgha

    Abstract

    On the basis of two years of ethnographic fieldwork at Wake Sangha California (2020- 2022), this paper examines a new form of digital Buddhist community that burgeoned during the COVID-19 pandemic. These Buddhist therapeutic communities of care teach contemplative practices in a secular context of mental health care. What I term “Buddhist therapeutics” emerges from the process of collective authenticity in which experiences of racism, abuse, trauma, and systemic inequity—often illegible elsewhere in the public sphere—are reframed and “authenticated” as expressions of individual and communal suffering. In these self-described “secular Buddhist” spaces, contemplation is rendered amenable to a body of standardized biomedical, psychological, and social expectations regarding mental health. Treating these as productions, rather than expressions, of secular mental health, participants in Wake Up Sangha frame the Dharma in ways that confront social inequity.

A23-239

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-25A (Upper Level East)

The late Bishop Carlton Pearson was an extraordinary religious figure by almost any measure.This roundtable will consider how Bishop Pearson as a sonic and visual performative figure transgressed racial boundaries; how Pearson’s embrace of universal salvation might be situated within the Black radical tradition, and perform a type of Black radical constructive theology and liberative praxis more readily associated with Black, Womanist and Queer theologies; how Pearson’s Pentecostal consideration of Black suffering sparked the largest and most widespread theological rebuke of his ministry via the Joint College of African American Pentecostal Bishops suggesting Pentecostalism’s reliance on Black suffering for forms of order, theological normativity, and respectability; and finally, how Pearson mastered media performances of piety, even in death.

A23-204

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-26B (Upper Level East)

The papers in this session engage Bonhoeffer's thought in relation to politics and various political theology discourses, including secularism and Christian nationalism; queer theory; global and racial capitalism; whiteness, fascism, anti-racism, and anti-Semitism; and retributive justice and violence.

 

  • “We Are Otherworldly or We Are Secularists:” Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Josh Hawley, and the Politics of the Kingdom of God

    Abstract

    Focusing on competing understandings of the kingdom of God, this paper contrasts the political theologies of German pastor/theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer and American senator Josh Hawley. The paper traces the connections between Bonhoeffer and Hawley’s visions of the kingdom of God and their political choices. While Bonhoeffer’s interpretation of God’s kingdom informed his costly repudiation of Christian nationalism in his context, Hawley’s interpretation bolstered his unwavering support for Christian nationalism in his context.    

  • The Theological Art of Failure Reading Bonhoeffer’s Late Writings with Jack Halberstam

    Abstract

    Despite their very different contexts and styles, there are some striking resonances between Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s late theology and Jack Halberstam’s The Queer Art of Failure (2011). On the one hand, Bonhoeffer proposes a “view from below”, claiming that “suffering is a more useful key, a more fruitful principle than happiness for exploring the meaning of the world in contemplation and action.” On the other hand, Halberstam develops queer theory as “knowledge from below”, which can assist with countering “the logics of success that have emerged from the triumphs of global capitalism.” In this paper, I bring Bonhoeffer’s reflections on suffering and weakness into conversation with Halberstam’s insights into failure. Specifically, I explore how Halberstam’s work might help to supplement and radicalise some of Bonhoeffer’s reflections in his late theology.

  • Does Divine Retribution Generate Human Violence?—Bonhoeffer, Guilt, and Resistance

    Abstract

    In contemporary soteriological discourse, several voices have raised the concern that atonement theologies that assume divine justice has a retributive element end up justifying violence.  Though this may be the case in some instances, Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s theology and ethics present a more complicated picture.  While Bonhoeffer presumed retributive justice was operative in God’s saving work in Christ, this never resulted in an outright justification of his work in the resistance. 

  • Judeo-Christianity (and Palestine); or, Late Modernity's Whiteness Project

    Abstract

    This talk addresses the religio-racial transformation of “the whiteness project” through the machinery of antiracism and anti-antisemitism. It turns to the mid-twentieth martyr-theologian and ethicist Dietrich Bonhoeffer, glimpsing this machinery in his late writings to imagine a postfascist Western future. That future entailed subjecting Jewishness to whitening, thereby figuring Jews no longer as targets (traditional supersession) but now agents (a new supersessionism) of Christian (post)colonial empire. This is Bonhoeffer’s unwitting renewal of “the religion of whiteness” (W. E. B. Du Bois), where in its distinction from and yet relation to “white people” whiteness is a locution for planet-wide racial capitalism. Imagined now as racially “plastic,” Jews are hailed into the West’s civilizational project while Jewishness becomes a site for Western post-Holocaust self-renewal. With the term “Judeo-Christianity,” I sketch how this maneuver works in Bonhoeffer’s Ethics to illuminate the religio-racial terms of the present, including the current crisis in Palestine.

A23-205

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-24A (Upper Level East)

Yunnan Province, located in southwest China, has long been a hub in transregional Buddhist networks. However, it has received less scholarly attention than Silk Road sites and maritime routes. This panel’s four papers demonstrate Yunnan’s significance as a place for encounters between different forms of Buddhism and Buddhists of different backgrounds, with a focus on political themes in the late imperial period (1368–1911). Each paper uses a specific case study— Xitan Temple, the Yongle Buddhist Canon, an _abhiṣeka_ ritual text, and the _Săpº kammavācā_—to foreground a different encounter zone that connects Yunnan to Tibet, the Ming (1368–1644) court, middle-period South and Southeast Asia, or Theravada Southeast Asia. The papers draw on diverse sources in various scripts to reveal different facets of Buddhist encounters in Yunnan. The panel shows the benefits of treating Yunnan as a whole, rather than separately addressing Sinitic, Tibetan, or Pali forms of Buddhism.

  • Xitan Temple on Mt. Jizu: Shared sacred space for Naxi, Tibetan, and Chinese Buddhists

    Abstract

    This study looks into how Xitan Temple 悉檀寺, located on Chicken-foot Mountain (Ch. Jizu shan 雞足山; Tib. Ri bo bya rkang), facilitated material, human, and ritual encounters between Tibetan and Chinese Buddhism. Drawing upon the Sixth Zhwa dmar Chos kyi dbang phyug’s (1584-1630) pilgrimage account, Xu Xiake’s (1587-1646) 徐霞客 travel diary, temple inscriptions, and mountain gazetteers, this paper examines the ways in which Mu Zeng 木增 (Tib. bSod nams rab brtan, 1587-1646), a Naxi Chieftain who governed the Lijiang (Tib. ‘Jang Sa tham) area in northwestern Yunnan, played a critical role in Mt. Jizu’s transformation into a sacred site by patronizing both Tibetan and Chinese Buddhism. This will shed light on the power dynamics among different ethnic groups in Yunnan, and how this influenced decisions on the religious market.

  • The Yongle Northern Canon as Bestowed on Jizu Mountain in Yunnan Province

    Abstract

    The Ming Court probably bestowed seven sets of the Yongle Northern Canon to areas in Yunnan. In one case, the Wanli Emperor (r. 1573–1619) issued a decree to present the canon to Huayan Temple on Jizu shan in the fourteenth year of Wanli (1586). His mother, Empress Dowager Li (1545–1614), issued a decree the following year that imperial court would exempt 1284 _shi_ 石of grain-tax from the local people (almost equal to 65,736 kg of rice) to bring prosperity to the country and blessings to the local people. This paper examines the Ming court’s bestowal of the Yongle Northern Canon in Yunnan to analyze the relationship between the Imperial Court and the border province in the southwest and to explore why the court disproportionately favored temples on the sacred Buddhist mountain Jizu shan. One purpose was clear: to consolidate the border region and to protect the empire.

  • Becoming the Buddha-King: Abhiṣeka and Buddhist Kingship in the Dali kingdom (937-1254)

    Abstract

    This paper nuances the dominant view that the Buddhist kingship of the Dali kingdom drew upon the Sinitic teaching of the _Humane King_. It does so by calling attention to a group of unstudied Esoteric Buddhist ritual manuals for the consecration (Sk. _abhiṣeka_; Ch. _guanding_) of the Dali rulers and by showcasing the ideal of divine rulership embodied in the final part of the ritual. I argue this section is modeled after the enthronement part of the Hindu kingship ritual _pratiṣṭhā_, through which the king reigns as an incarnation of the Buddha. Such a merging of the king and Buddha in one person was never attained in the _Humane King_ model but constitutes a parallel with the Hindu-inspired _buddharāja_ (Buddha-king) ideal in contemporaneous Southeast Asian Buddhist kingdoms. In drawing the parallel, this paper advocates repositioning Dali in a cosmopolitan world consisting of the synchronous pursuit of an Indian-inflected divine kingship.

  • A Bilingual Pali-Dai Pātimokkha from Yunnan: Language, Exegesis, and Power at the Edge of the Theravada World

    Abstract

    Bilingual Pali-vernacular versions of the Vinaya, including the core Pātimokkha rules and their ritual framework, are some of the most widespread forms of monastic exegesis in the Theravada world. These bilingual compositions, or bitexts, typically follow an interphrasal format, in which Pali words or short phrases are followed by expanded glosses in a local vernacular. As part of a broader inquiry into how bitexts shaped Buddhist translation across mainland Southeast Asia, this paper focuses on a single Pali-Dai example of the Pātimokkha from early modern Sipsongpanna (today’s Xishuangbanna Autonomous Prefecture in Yunnan province, China). This paper compares this text—preserved in facsimile form as part of the massive _Zhongguo beiyejing quanji_ project—with other manuscripts in Laos, Cambodia, Myanmar, and Thailand to reveal how the translation choices made by Dai scholars—into Dai as well as into Chinese—made the Pātimokkha respond to local conceptions of scriptural authority and temporal power.

A23-206

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-30E (Upper Level East)

Intentionally breaking from the norms of intellectual argument, where one presents a thesis and defends it against critique from others, this roundtable provides an occasion for scholars to reflect and critique their work from multiple perspectives, some complimentary, some adversarial, some exploratory. Led by two moderators who begin by showcasing conflicting reflections on their own scholarship, each panelist will pick a category (gender, identity, state, violence, mind, pluralism, and disciplinary boundaries) and critically reflect on (at least) two modes of engaging with these categories in Buddhist Studies, by making rival arguments that are equally valid. This conversation aims to create a space of openness and vulnerability where difficult dialogues between emic Buddhist and religious studies categories can take place, in hopes that situating a multiplicity of epistemological categories in the mirrors of one another will provide a vantage from which both scholarly and Buddhist notions of truth can be revalued.

A23-207

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-11B (Upper Level West)

This panel explores cutting-edge scholarship using current cognitive theories applied research to the study of religion, religions, or religious-related phenomena. It is intentionally broad on scope, focusing on the most-recent and novel applications of CSR.

  • Extreme Social Bonding During Queen Elizabeth’s Funeral

    Abstract

    Social scientists have long proposed that funerary rituals foster group cohesion. Our research rigorously tests and refines these long-standing qualitative claims by uncovering the causal mechanisms and quantifiable effects of this universal human behavior. We conducted two preregistered sequential studies following the national funeral of Queen Elizabeth II, exploring the psycho-social pathways to identity fusion and their impact on pro-group commitment among 1,869 British spectators. The initial study, involving 1,632 participants surveyed within two weeks of the funeral, validated predictions that intense sadness during the event correlated with heightened identity fusion and pro-group commitment. The subsequent longitudinal examination, involving 237 participants over 12 months, delved into the causal psycho-social pathways to identity fusion. As expected, the visceral quality of memories exerted a transformative effect on personal identity through processes of personal reflection, ultimately leading to identity fusion via perceived sharedness within the group.This research contributes to accumulating evidence that sharing emotionally intense dysphoric experiences with others, including viewing sacred rituals, leads to incredibly potent social bonding. 

  • Aligned bodies, united hearts: Embodied emotional dynamics of Islamic Congregational ritual

    Abstract

    Collective rituals involve coordinating intentions and synchronizing actions to align emotional states and social identities. However, the mechanics of achieving group-level synchrony is yet unclear. We report the results of a naturalistic study in the context of an Islamic congregational prayer that involves synchronous movement. We used wearable devices to capture data on body posture, autonomic responses, and spatial proximity to investigate how postural alignment and shared arousal intertwine during this ritual. The findings reveal a dual process at play: postural alignment appears to be more localized, with worshippers synchronizing their movements with their nearest neighbors, while physiological alignment operates on a broader scale, primarily driven by the central role of the religious leader. Our findings underscore the importance of interpersonal dynamics in collective gatherings and the role of physical co-presence in fostering connections among participants, with implications extending to our understanding of group dynamics across various social settings.

  • Embodied Cognition of Value

    Abstract

    In this paper, I argue that embodied cognition helps to undermine the Humean dualism of facts and values. I draw on two contributions to embodied cognition, the concept of affordances (originally developed by Gibson) and the enactive approach (originally developed by Varela, Thompson and Rosch). Gibson argued that the perceiving animal would typically be engaged in some goal-directed activity, and he speaks in this context of the animal’s perception of “affordances,” i.e., value-laden opportunities in their environment. The enactive approach treats cognition as a dynamic system that arises from the interactions between an animal and its environment. Together, these two concepts open the door to a realist account of values. Insofar as religious practices are regimens for training participants in the perception of affordances, we can underaind them as helping people move from novice to competent to expert at recognizing real good and bad in the world. 

  • From the Disaster of the Century to the Solidarity of the Century: Earthquakes Facilitate Social Bonding in Türkiye

    Abstract

    This study investigates predictors and consequences of identity fusion, a profound sense of unity with a group, towards Turkish citizens and Syrian refugees following the catastrophic earthquakes in Türkiye on February 6th, 2023. Surveys were administered in-person to 120 Turkish earthquake survivors in the most heavily impacted areas. Results revealed challenges in establishing relationships between emotional intensity, perceived sharedness, and identity fusion due to extreme emotional intensity during the earthquake. However, mean fusion levels significantly increased with perceived shared suffering, validating predictions. Identity fusion also predicted pro-group commitment, measured by volunteerism pledges of Turkish earthquake survivors. As expected, Turkish earthquake survivors exhibited higher pro-group commitment scores than their Syrian counterparts. The study contributes to understanding the complex dynamics of identity fusion in post-catastrophe contexts.

  • How Filipino (Tagalog) Case Markers Affect the Perception of Supernatural Agency

    Abstract

    This paper analyzes CSR theories of SA attribution, and tests them through an online survey from 40 native Filipino speakers who currently reside in the Philippines. Preliminary data suggest that when gods are involved as the subject, they are coded with non-human case markers. We also see differences depending on whether gods are framed in Tagalog or English terms: human case markers are used for English terms for gods (Lord, God, Jesus, etc.) while non-human markers are used for Tagalog terms (Diyos, Panginnon, Hesus, etc.). Such findings support certain of CSR’s theories but also problematize the more universalizing claims around cross-cultural supernatural agent attribution at the heart of certain foundational CSR theories.

  • “Are you still with us?”: The Embodiment of Robot-Induced After Death Experiences

    Abstract

    Between 30 and 60% of the population have experienced sense of presence in the form of a deceased loved one (Castelnovo et al., 2015; Elsaesser et al., 2021; Streit-Horn, 2011). These experiences (i.e., ghosts, grief or bereavement hallucinations) may generally be called after death experiences (ADEs). In this paper, I will argue that 4E cognition, or the notion that cognition is shaped by dynamic interactions between the brain, body, and physical/social environments, plays a key role in understanding the cognitive underpinnings and behavioral outcomes of ADEs as both universal experiences and those deemed religious or spiritual. Drawing from mixed-methods experimental research in cognitive neuroscience, I posit that sensorimotor manipulations of a bereaved individual may induce experiences of presence more readily than in non-bereaved. Based on clinical data and preliminary findings, I will explore how future research relying on 4E cognition principles may impact the study of religious or spiritual phenomenon.

     

A23-208

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-28D (Upper Level East)

On February 28, 2024, the Public Religion Research Institute’s survey revealed co-relations between Christian nationalists and support for former President Donald Trump. A homogenizing nationalism is alive and well in the American “melting pot” and is not restricted to certain regimes abroad. The phenomenon of nationalism paired with an interest in militarism empowered by religious adherence is hardly new, however. This roundtable session will reflect upon instances of nationalism—historical and contemporary—that are supported by religious faith and practice in religions of the world from North Africa, South Asia, and China. The presenters may only briefly reference Christianity in order to leave time for Christian reflection by the audience.

A23-209

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-25B (Upper Level East)

Panelists discuss with Perry Schmidt-Leukel his new book *The Celestial Web. Buddhism and Christianity. A Different Comparison* (Orbis 2024). Is his application of fractal analysis to religious diversity able to overcome post-structuralist critiques of interreligious comparisons? Which insights can be gained from his approach for the methodologies in Comparative Religion and Comparative Theology? How sound is Schmidt-Leukel’s claim that major typological differences between Buddhism and Christianity replicate within each of the two traditions? To what extent can his approach foster reciprocal illumination and interreligious learning? These questions are discussed by specialists in Comparative Religion, Comparative Theology, Buddhist-Christian Studies and Buddhist Studies / “Buddhist Theology”.

A23-210

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-6F (Upper Level West)

Confucian contemplation, particularly quiet-sitting meditation, has been historically overlooked in contemplative studies. This is despite its deep integration in Confucian traditions, where figures like Cheng Yi and Yang Shi viewed it as crucial for moral self-cultivation and active engagement with the world. Zhu Xi's evolving stance further illuminated its philosophical depth. The underrepresentation is partly due to the practice's societal integration, the absence of texts with detailed techniques, and the scholarly necessity to reinterpret and recontextualize these traditions after their decline in modern times.The papers session advocates for including the Ruist perspective in global research, noting its potential relevance to modern professionals akin to ancient Ru scholars. It includes papers exploring early Chinese ritual fasting, the philosophical dimensions of quiet-sitting in the lineage of pattern-principle learning, Zhu Xi's meditation interpreted through a Chinese Catholic lens, and the efficacy of Confucian practices in contemporary pedagogy of liberal arts.

  • Ritual Fasting and Inner Cultivation in Early China

    Abstract

    “Fasting” 齋 was central to early Chinese ritual practice, whether in preparation for sacrificing to the spirits or other occasions of ritual significance. In this paper, I propose to examine the practices that gather about this imperative to “fast” (often written with the allograph 齊). Ritual fasting involved not only the proscription of various activities (social engagement and other sources of pleasure and distraction) but also contemplative elements that have not drawn as much scholarly attention. Drawing primarily on the Liji 禮記, I will discuss the details and practical logic of ritual fasting as well as its relationship to contemporaneous practices of inner cultivation.

  • Quiet-Sitting Meditation: A Philosophical Practice in Cheng-Zhu Learning of Pattern-Principle

    Abstract

    Confucian philosophers within the lineage of pattern-principle learning perceived quiet-sitting meditation as a pivotal philosophical exercise in the broader pursuit of self-cultivation. Cheng Yi considered quiet-sitting among various contemplative practices that fostered reverence, a virtue crucial for discerning and engaging with the pattern-principles inherent in the world. Yang Shi underscored quiet-sitting as a foundational and primary step in self-cultivation, attributing significant philosophical importance to this practice. Zhu Xi aimed to amalgamate the perspectives of Cheng and Yang, elucidating his understanding of quiet-sitting through three stages of his philosophical journey: initially dismissing its significance, later valuing it as the fundamental practice of reverence, and eventually regarding it on par with other contemplative practices, reverting to Cheng Yi’s stance. As the practice and its broader implications were deeply intertwined with ongoing intellectual dialogues concerning virtuous human existence within the pattern-principle tradition, the act of Confucian quiet-sitting inherently embodies philosophical dimensions.

  • Rereading Zhu Xi’s Quiet-Sitting Practice through a Chinese Catholic Lens

    Abstract

    With a focus on the quiet-sitting meditation of major Neo-Confucian figure Zhu Xi (1130-1200), this paper aims to shed new light on Zhu’s contemplative practice by adopting a comparative theological method. More specifically, it follows the interpretations of Zhu’s quiet-sitting put forth by Chinese Jesuit theologian Hu Guozhen (1948-) in his work to “inculturate” Christian prayer for fellow Chinese Catholics. Whether simply through oversight or because his study of Zhu on this topic was motivated by different concerns than those of most scholars, Hu’s reading of Zhu Xi has not been noted in contemporary scholarship; however, this paper argues his novel approach can help us think in fresh ways about Zhu’s quiet-sitting practice—especially its flexible approach to cultivating “reverence” as opposed to pursuing mental tranquility through strict techniques, and its relation to other practices like reading.

  • Confucian Contemplation and Experiential Learning

    Abstract

    This talk will share some of the findings from research I conducted in two upper-level seminars that I recently taught at two different Midwestern liberal arts colleges in which I included Confucian contemplative practices as modes of experiential learning. These seminars surveyed and analyzed contemplative practices primarily from an array of Asian traditions, but I also included case studies of both religions and modern, secular, and hybridized traditions in the West. An aim of this IRB-approved research is to assess the pedagogical effectiveness of using contemplative pedagogy as a form of experiential learning. The two Confucian contemplative techniques that I included as components of contemplative pedagogy in these seminars were quiet-sitting meditation and self-examination/self-monitoring. I will report on aspects of what students accomplished both inside and outside the classroom relating to these Confucian practices, on the data I collected and analyzed from students, and on the preliminary findings concerning their effectiveness, as types of experiential learning, in enhancing student learning. 

     

A23-211

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Indigo C (Second Level)

This session examines women’s use of text, images, video, memes, and audio across various social media platforms and spanning four religious traditions in North America. By focusing on brujas on Instagram, Muslims on TikTok, evangelicals on Twitter, and Catholics on YouTube, the papers explore situated digital practices. How do women use media to contest dominant and hegemonic interpretations of religious texts and practices and put forth their own? How do they use humor, creativity, and referentiality to create digital content to assert authority and build community? What are some of the ways that the relationship between online and offline worlds are impacting religious experience? This papers’ session approaches these questions from a variety of perspectives to theorize some of the ways in which religious women’s use of diverse social network sites contribute to theorizing digital religion and digital archives and methods. 

  • "Why Is This Guy Preaching Again?": Rachel Held Evans and Feminist Counter-Messaging on Twitter

    Abstract

    In the 2010s, Twitter rose in popularity as a digital space for theological dialogue, debate, and grandstanding. For feminist Christians, Twitter activism was a vital form of activism with real-world consequences that was motivated by theological ideas about God’s ethical expectations. I argue that social media platforms were spaces in which evangelical women who were marginalized based on their gender and who grew up with an emphasis on evangelism could “inverse evangelize” conservative evangelicals with progressive theologies and progressive politics. By focusing on one well-known Twitter user, Rachel Held Evans, in her posts relating to two famous men, John Piper and Mark Driscoll, I examine the way that feminist women used Twitter posts to push against the logic of patriarchal theology. This paper shows how Evans, a woman who had less institutional power than either Piper or Driscoll, used Twitter to contradict their viewpoints in view of an evangelical and post-evangelical public.

  • “These are for girls only”: Experience, Authority, and the Practice of Naṣīḥa in Online Contexts

    Abstract

    When the “these are for girls only” meme went viral on TikTok in 2021, many Muslim women in North America used the meme to create content that comically addresses the commentary they receive about their Islamic practice and the boundaries they’ve established around it. This paper focuses on the concept of naṣīḥa, understood to be a discursive mode of communal regulation in accordance with constructed ideals, in digital contexts. It examines several TikTok videos in which Muslim women address their audience about who is or is not authorized to offer social commentary on their Islamic practice on the basis of shared experience. I explore these videos as sites of contestation surrounding authority, arguing that these women use their videos to counter hegemonic conceptions of who has the authority to determine proper practice. How might focusing on the concept of naṣīḥa, or social commentary, complicate scholarly understandings of top-down models of Islamic authority? This paper attempts to address this question.

  • “Taking Spirit To Market”: Brujapreneurs Make Digital Sacred Space on Instagram

    Abstract

    Over the last several years there has been a growing interest in popular culture on the modern-day witch. To contest the erasure of Afro-Indigenous spiritual perspectives, this paper looks at how digital sacredness the Instagram accounts of self-identified brujas of Afro-Caribbean descent. By creating digital sacred spaces that become the basis for their activism, the bruja’s social media presence acts against larger hegemonic structures, such as white supremacy, colonialism/imperialism, racism, and homophobia. By enabling the divine via social media the brujas are able to have a voice in the world that would seek to silence them. Their social platforms allow their voices to be easily amplified (read: go viral) in ways that did not exist before. Ultimately, this paper seeks to begin conversations on how digital media has transformed newer generations to engage with the cosmologies of Afro-Indigenous religiosity.

  • Do Nuns Just Want to Have Fun? #MediaNuns and the Millennial American Catholic Sister

    Abstract

    This paper examines the Roman Catholic sisters known as the Daughters of Saint Paul and their use of social media as part of their mission to use the media to evangelize. Through using modern forms, the Daughters of St. Paul emerge as leaders in Catholic media use. While their content challenges some stereotypes about Catholic nuns, their efforts seem primarily to serve recruitment goals, and their young millennial sisters are leading the efforts in making the nun life appear attractive to prospective future sisters that exist among their following. Through analyzing the Daughters of St. Paul’s use of Instagram, TikTok, and Youtube, this paper explores themes related to technology and religious traditions, technology and communal formation, virtual belonging, and politics and technology. Ultimately, while the Daughters of St. Paul are committed to using “new media,” they do so while preserving traditional aesthetics and messaging for the Catholic Church in America.

  • Conjuring Interiority: Womanist Reflections on Ancestor Veneration, Social Media, and a Philosophy of Aesthetics

    Abstract

    Philosophical approaches to Black aesthetics have included how Black human beings make meaning and see value in their everyday lives. The theorization of this cultural and social production has been essential to a philosophy of aesthetics, as shown through the work of Lewis R. Gordon and Paul C. Taylor. These philosophers have provided historical trajectories of Western philosophy and Black expressive culture to define blackness and racialization’s impact on how people show up in this world. Therefore, this paper seeks to come alongside Gordon and Taylor and explore the role of ancestor veneration in the project of Black value and meaning-making within technology. By drawing from womanist reflections on aesthetic interiority, I will examine the diasporic tradition of Southern Hoodoo on social media as a site for understanding how ancestors assist in the inner cultivation, transformation, and construction of individuals and communities.

A23-212

Theme: Heterotopias

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-9 (Upper Level West)

Michel Foucault labeled counter-spaces that influence, contest, mirror, and invert as heterotopias. Paper one considers heterotopia through transformations of a plot of land in Colorado, unveiling environmental challenges, adaptations, and the interplay of sacred spaces facing climate-related shifts. The second, co-authored paper offers a dialogic analysis of two U.S. social institutions – early nineteenth century prisons and mid twentieth century sexual closets – at a key moment in their historical formations. In the dialectic between imagined and materialized, they each produce another heterotopia – queer and spectral in form – in which other worlds are imagined, queering the hetero of heterotopia. The third, multi-authored paper showcases innovative ethnographic research of a revival of Victorian era-style spiritualism underway in British public houses (‘pubs’), the latest collective space for contemporary spirit communication. The fourth paper examines the ambiguous utopia/heterotopia that is the Métis community of Ste Madeleine in Manitoba, destroyed by the settler government.

  • Brothels to Books: Heterotopia and Protestant Morality in a Boulder, Colorado Floodplain (1884-1921)

    Abstract

    This paper considers the idea of heterotopia through a small plot of land in Boulder, Colorado. Located in a floodplain, it transformed from a red light district in the 1880s to a site of ramshackle dwellings in the 1910s, then to a city park and public library. This transformation was aided by several catastrophic floods that destroyed brothels and saloons, and it was propelled by moralizing forces. Relying on newspapers, oral histories, city and national archives, and city government reports, this paper will engage in a critical conversation with heterotopia through a space on the outskirts of morality and traditional notions of religion. By examining the interplay between human-driven meaning-making and climate-related events, this microhistory narrates the efforts of social forces to define and control the floodplain but also unveils the environmental challenges, adaptations, and the interplay of sacred spaces in the face of climate-related shifts.

  • Prisons and Closets: U.S. American Protestant Materializations of the Secular

    Abstract

    This co-authored paper offers a dialogic analyses of two U.S. American social institutions--early nineteenth century prisons and mid twentieth century sexual closets--at a key moment in their respective historical formation. Building on Michel Foucault's theorization "heterotopias," we analyze these sites as spaces of containment for perverse masculinities, with attention to these material spaces of containment as sedimentations of religious and non-religious imaginations, practices, and institutions. We explore, in particular, how religious imaginaries shape and are shaped by material spaces regarded as “secular.” These secular heterotopias, we argue, were and are materialized through particular Protestant discourses. At the same time, in the dialectic between the imagined and the materialized, they each produce yet another heterotopia--queer and spectral in form-- in which other worlds are imagined, thus queering the hetero of heterotopia. 

  • Pub Psychic Nights as Heterotopia: Exploring Experiences of Marginal, Unlikely, and Transformative Spaces in Contemporary Spirit Communication

    Abstract

    In Britain, a revival of Victorian era-style spiritualism is arguably underway. Yet, instead of seances or mediumship demonstrations in domestic homes, theatres, or the Spiritualist Church (as during the ‘golden age of spiritualism’), public houses (‘pubs’) have emerged as the latest collective space for contemporary spirit communication. Drawing on innovative ethnographic research, and engaging with Foucault's concept of heterotopia, we argue that pub psychic nights destabilise social norms and empower marginalised participants, as well as encourage reflection and the potential for real-time social change, especially for working-class women. The broadly accessible and commonplace nature of the British pub helps to scaffold and promote the development of alternative beliefs and practices, beyond more traditional locations for spirituality. Despite critiques, in a context where religious institutional affiliation has dramatically declined, pub psychic nights function with transformative potential and offer new spaces that combine spirituality with social change.

  • Re-theorizing Heterotopia: Towards an Ambiguous Utopianism

    Abstract

    In this paper, I propose that a more theoretically promising understanding of the concept of ‘heterotopia’ is possible only if we attend to its utopian roots. To do this I examine the ambiguous utopia/heterotopia that is the Métis community of Ste Madeleine - a small settlement near where I grew up that was destroyed by the settler government. By re-theorizing ‘heterotopia’ conceptually from utopian studies, and particularly the work of Louis Marin, we arrive at a more theoretically useful concept for analyzing the actual places/spaces that Foucault gestures toward in his original articulation of the concept. 

A23-213

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Sapphire 402 (Fourth Level)

This session includes four papers spanning different time periods, cultures, and methodologies to explore new understandings within Orthodoxy. From hermeneutical reframings, to phenomenological interpretations, and theological insights to cultural heritage, this panel provides space for diverse topics to be brought into conversation around understandings of Orthodoxy and the types of thinking that can be applied to gain new insights around topics within Orthodox Christianity. 

  • Origen of Alexandria’s Appraisal of the Mosaic Law

    Abstract

    In this paper I will evaluate the reception of Mosaic Law (hereafter just Law) by Origen of Alexandria (c. 185 – c. 254 C.E.). Within in the polemics against “Christian heretics” and Judaism, Origen ascribed an important place to the Law preferring allegorical interpretation to the “heretical” and “Judaizing” approaches to the law, which included both rejection and literal interpretation.  Origen of Alexandria treated the Mosaic law on the one hand as relatively lower in value to Christian message while at the same time defending its divine origin and limited but continuing relevance. While a chronological evolution is apparent in Origen’s thought, I argue that there is a great deal of continuity in Origen’s view of the Law between the Alexandrian and Caesarean period.

  • Joban Prayers: A Maximian Contemplation of the Cosmic Job – Christ

    Abstract

    St. Maximus the Confessor states that "the mystery of the Incarnation of the Logos is the key to all the arcane symbolism and typology in the Scriptures." This project explores to what extent Maximian Logos/Logoi theology aids an inclusivist interpretation of the Book of Job within the Judeo-Christian Traditions. Joban scholarship is typically siloed to discussions of theodicy; however, the Scriptural account of a pagan saint is prophetic in content and provides a pedagogy for the religious 'other'. Applied theological structures include Maximian Christology and Mystagogy which is aided by Pope Gregory the Great's threefold spiritual hermeneutic in Moralia in Job. The exploration concludes that Christology and Job provide theological grounds for an inclusivist interpretation of salvation and hopes for further explorations in Patristic writings on Job.

  • Contesting Ontological Eastern-ness: Florovsky’s Neo-Patristic Synthesis as a Postmodern and Postcolonial Response to Orientalism and Slavophilia

    Abstract

    This paper contends that Orientalism and right-wing Slavophilia are based in the same colonial epistemology aimed to disentangle, legitimize, and hierarchize the sociopolitical categories of “East” and “West.” With this as a backdrop, I will propose a reading of Florovsky’s neo-patristic synthesis as a postmodern and postcolonial response to both, attempting to reconstruct a foundation for self-actualized Orthodox Christian identity neither in subjugation nor in contrast to Protestantism and Roman Catholicism. I will explore how this differs from a Slavophilic reading of neo-patristic synthesis, which I call “neo-patristic reactionism,” focusing on method and historiography. Lastly, I will discuss its implications for contemporary Orthodox ecclesiology and ecumenical relations, including an appraisal of its flaws and limitations.

  • Wounding Presence of Prayer in Orthodox Iconography

    Abstract

    As objects of devotion and veneration, icons invite the beholder to an encounter with the one depicted. But the presence an icon promises is grounded on a metaphysics of presence and absence, which, refuses stability or mastery and ultimately entails an essential difference between the icon and whom it depicts. In this paper I explore how phenomenology illuminates this encounter with the icon’s metaphysics of presence and absence. Drawing on Jean-Louis Chretien’s analysis of prayer, which explores the experience of presence and absence in prayer as both wounding and blessing, I argue that the traditional metaphysical accounts of the icon are amplified by consideration of how presence and absence is an experiential reality revealed in the prayerful encounter of the one depicted, an encounter that carries with it the possibility of wounds that bless.

A23-214

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Convention Center-28B (Upper Level East)

If esoteric religious practices are, by definition, "hidden," then who exactly do they exclude, and what are the social consequences of such exclusions? This panel examines the relationship between esoteric practice and violent ideology in three diverse historical and cultural circumstances. From the Middle Ages to the twentieth century, these panelists explore the interconnections between esotericism and discourses of universalism and traditionalism. These panelists demonstrate some of the ways in which esoteric discourses of prisca theologica and secrecy can and have led to intolerant and violent cultural formations. 

  • Esoteric Universalism and Crusader Evangelism in the Work of Ramon Llull

    Abstract

    Ramon Llull is an extraordinary figure both as a Christian apologist and as a collater of the various streams of knowledge that converged in medieval Spain. Predating Marsilio Ficino's *prisca theologia* by a few hundred years, Llull sought to chart the hidden unity amongst the Abrahmic faiths despite their apparent diffusion. This esoteric universalism is a theme of Western esotericism that runs through the present, with both benign and not-so-benign historical outcomes. While pointing out what is noble and in accordance with Christian truth in his Jewish and Muslim interlocuters, Llull advocated for further crusades on the grounds of his "Art". Influenced by intellectual historian Tomoko Masuzawa, this paper is a contribution to the dialogue on Euro-Christian universalism and its aftereffects, for better or worse. 

  • Embracing Evola and Glorifying Guénon: Traditionalism, Nationalism, and Orthodoxy among the Digital Far Right

    Abstract

    Drawing on ethnographic research and digital data collection, this paper considers the entanglement between the esoteric philosophies of Rene Guénon, Julius Evola, and Aleksandr Dugin and far-right nationalist ideologues. Utilizing case studies of digital content produced by American converts to Russian Orthodoxy (and its political framings), I tease out how philosophically intolerant, anti-modern conceptions of the body and person—proliferated through memes, podcasts, and video streams—are intimately tied to understandings of traditionalism, racism, and the disciplinary structures of political authority in the 20th century European context. I show that the project of traditionalism espoused on far-right social media is not linked to primordial truths but rather to the 20th century philosophical conceptions of what counts as modern, right, wrong, true, false, salvific, or damning. In doing so, I contend that traditionalism provides the vocabulary to help alleviate far-right anxiety about rapid social change, economic crisis, and shifting political dynamics.

     

     

  • Navigating Extremism and Esotericism: Savitri Devi and the Spread of Religious Eco-Fascism

    Abstract

    The proposed paper explores the complex relationship between esotericism, violence, and the far-right through the work and life of Savitri Devi Mukherji (1905-1982), also known as Maximani Portas and 'Hitler's priestess.' This critical discourse analysis focuses on her uniquely problematic ideology of violence which combines modern aryanism and radical Hindu nationalism with Malthusian 'deep ecology' and contempt for Christianity and Judaism. In doing so, I aim to highlight and contextualize her formative effect on violent international neo-Nazism and white nationalist politics, continuous from the mid-1960s onward. Through recently published data gathered from the digital *Savitri Devi Archive,* I follow her lasting global impact in spreading this antisemitic revisionist history (Figueira 2002). In addition, I also situate her influence within various contemporary esoteric, New Age, and environmentalist movements, especially through her religious eco-fascism which included devout reverence for Hitler, deified as an avatar of the Hindu god Vishnu.

A23-215

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Aqua Salon AB (Third Level)

This roundtable explores maternal agency, choice, and children’s upbringing within or against religious frameworks. Although maternal agency (mothers’ ability to make autonomous decisions that shape their children’s lives) is a crucial aspect of parenting, it is significantly influenced by religious beliefs and practices on maternal agency. For many mothers, religion is a guiding force in shaping decisions regarding themselves and their children, from moral teachings to ritual participation and community engagement. For others, religion poses challenges, constrains their agency, and prompts questions about autonomy and freedom of choice. Contributors will share perspectives and empirical research on the dynamics of navigating the intersection of motherhood and religious norms within a framework centered on matricentric feminist approaches as they explore the experiences of mothers who grapple with the tensions between observing religious traditions and asserting autonomy in child-rearing in several religious contexts, past and present, including Antiquity, Christianity, Judaism, Buddhism, and Daoism.