Islamic Embodiments of Menstruation

This paper situates menstruation within the discussion of reproductive freedom in Islam, analyzing how the everyday phenomenology of menstruation disrupts traditional ‘ulama-led knowledge-making related to women’s bodies. The paper asks: how do ordinary Muslim women draw on nuances of their menstruating bodies to create Islamic knowledge related to menstrual purity (tahārah)? Drawing on the pietistic emphasis on menstruation (hayd) in the Islamic tradition at large, basing analysis on contemporary ethnographic accounts of menstrual effluent disposal in Pakistan, and using frameworks of embodied phenomenology, this paper inverts the doctrine-making direction of menstruation laws in Islamic fiqh by showing how the bodily nature of menstruation dictates a context of its Islamic interpretation. The paper shows how challenges of effluent disposal raise questions of agency for women, answered by the discursive closeness of menstruation with vernacular concepts of purity and pollution, re-imagined as the ‘Islamic’ norms of menstruation by women in Pakistan.