“Going Deeper”: The Search for Authenticity in Yogaland

Based on multi-sited ethnographic fieldwork, this paper explores American spiritual seekers who, having started doing yoga for any number of reasons, decide to “go deeper” into their practice. This is a context of not only postural practice, but also mantra, devotional singing, festival-going, astrology, and murti-puja, among others. Despite appearances to the contrary, such cultural borrowing or appropriation is rarely as hodgepodge as it initially seems. Rather, there is a guiding principle that shapes the contours of individual choice: authenticity. That is, spiritual seekers in the yoga world “go deeper” both by adopting “authentic” practices, and by choosing practices that feel personally “authentic.” But what does this mean? Authentic to what? And to whom? In this paper, I address how the effort of “going deeper”–both its associated practices, and the rhetoric around it–is navigated through a multi-faceted discourse about what counts as “authentic.”