Deconstructing the Dichotomy between the Esoteric and Buddhism in the West: the case study of Ananda Metteyya

Through the life of Allan Bennett/Ananda Metteyya (1872-1923), this paper argues that the transmission of Buddhism to the West cannot be understood without examining Western esotericism. To draw a line between Buddhism and the esoteric in a Western context is a false dichotomy. In his youth, Bennett turned towards Theosophy and the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, within which he became the teacher of Aleister Crowley (1875-1947). After a period in Sri Lanka, he gained higher ordination as a Buddhist monk in Myanmar, becoming Venerable Ananda Metteyya. As a monk, Metteyya insisted that there was nothing esoteric or mysterious in Buddhism. In his personal life, however, Metteyya retained constructive relationships with Theosophists and continued to practice the esoteric, yogic meditation he had learnt in Sri Lanka. A dialectical relationship, therefore, existed between the esoteric and Buddhism within Metteya's life and within the Buddhism that he communicated to the West.