Critiquing AI from a Religious History of the Printing Press

This paper examines parallels between early American critiques of the printing press with contemporary critiques and problems with particular uses of AI. By the eighteenth-century, members of Native American communities, the Jewish diaspora, and German migrant groups were becoming wary of the ways the Anglo-American Protestants treated the technology and its productions as producing speech that would be treated as timeless, permanent, and having universal scope. At the heart of their concerns, however, was the way the technology was promoted by booksellers, printers, missionaries, etc... to do exactly that, but in a manner that only really benefitted Anglo-American Protestants. This paper compares these critiques to some AI use-cases in contemporary discourse, and the ways that eighteenth-century critiques of print technology very much parallel our own concerns about the rampant marketing of the technology and the goals of those most invested in its proliferation across all parts of society.