This authors-meet-critics session introduces a book co-authored by three scholars representing religious studies, environmental humanities, and the history of science. Responding to calls to reconsider human-nonhuman relations in a time of global polycrisis, the book offers a novel framework for imagining connections between animated matter and political action through case studies focused on animated films, ritual practices, and robotics. Rather than studying animism as a specific cultural tradition distinct from non-animistic cultures and their supposedly disenchanted worldviews, the authors argue that practices of animation are universal, even as they stress that specific methods of animation differ according to time and place. The authors investigate how humans make persons through rituals, use the technique of compositing to construct worlds in illustrated films, and evoke feelings to forge intimacy with robots. Additionally, they show how humans deanimate entities that have become unruly, dysfunctional, or unwanted.
In-person November Annual Meeting 2026 Program Book
The 2026 November Annual Meeting in Denver, CO: Friday, November 20 - Tuesday, November 24. All times are listed in Mountain Time Zone. For more information about the November Annual Meeting, co-hosted with the Society of Biblical Literature, click here.
Please note that this is the preliminary schedule and is subject to change. We anticipate a mostly final schedule in mid-August. If you have any questions, please contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org. For Other Events, your event is not confirmed until you received notification from AAR staff.
What happens to human futures when they are organized around the possibility of contact with beings who are, by definition, unknowable? This panel brings together three scholars working at the intersection of religion, science, and culture to examine how extraterrestrial life and intelligence–scientifically speculated, culturally contested, and personally experienced–function as sites where alternative futures are imagined, struggled over, and made livable. Each paper examines communities operating at the margins of both institutional science and mainstream religion that are nonetheless engaged in urgent, consequential work to open new horizons: epistemically, cosmologically, and therapeutically. Together, the papers illuminate how UFO subcultures, alien abduction communities, and the scientific practices of SETI researchers function as laboratories for the anthropology of the future–spaces where competing imaginations contest the shape of what is possible, who has the authority to say so, and what forms of life will be viable.
Papers
This paper examines how SETI practitioners use game theory, historical analogy, and policy protocols to predict and control the fundamentally unknowable event of contact with extraterrestrial intelligence. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork and analysis of scientific literature, I argue these methods constitute scientific divination that transforms radical uncertainty into managed risk while simultaneously generating new forms of enchantment. Game-theoretical models depend on non-empirical axioms that conjure particular futures into calculable existence. Historical analogies mobilize sanitized colonial narratives as predictive tools, reading futures in the past. Post-detection protocols impose bureaucratic order onto speculative scenarios, promising control without eliminating surprise. Rather than opposing enchantment, these rational methods produce meta-empirical otherness—potential alien presences that structure present action despite their unknowability and speculative nature. SETI's predictive practices are existential technologies for navigating decisions with species-ending consequences, revealing how prediction operates and enchantment intensifies precisely where empirical grounding fails and rationalization appears most complete.
This paper will provide an overview of the lineage of thought, treatment, and community building that anomalous experiencers have engaged with to make meaning of what has happened to them. Drawing from archival research and ethnographic fieldwork, this paper reframes the lives of experiencers, and often their most traumatic moments, not as cultural curiosities but as sites of lived meaning and care within the context of psychiatric history and religious experience.
How do meaning-making strategies surrounding the “UFO phenomenon” intersect with “religion”? This paper explores the call-and-response between mainstream institutional UFO denial and grassroots subcultural knowledge production. The UFO phenomenon and associated notions of non-human intelligence destabilize hegemonic Western paradigms. Those in the UFO community navigate this fraught terrain through four distinguishable truth-seeking orientations: 1) speculative-political, 2) investigative-scientific, 3) communicative-spiritual, and 4) reconstructive-experiential. Symbolic boundaries and appeals to authority, experience, and science position UFO knowledge relative to mainstream institutions. Communicative-spiritual knowledge production, the third mode, is oriented vis-à-vis the spiritual-but-not-religious milieu as well as religious orthodoxies. In the U.S., UFO communities bypass both cautious Catholic openness and fundamentalist Christian demonization of UFOs to improvisationally bricolage Christian, Hindu, Buddhist, esoteric, and New Age elements into UFO-based spiritualities. The paper will conclude with two subcultural case studies of attempts at communication with non-human intelligences and the hierarchies of knowledge thereby reproduced or subverted.
What happens to human futures when they are organized around the possibility of contact with beings who are, by definition, unknowable? This panel brings together three scholars working at the intersection of religion, science, and culture to examine how extraterrestrial life and intelligence–scientifically speculated, culturally contested, and personally experienced–function as sites where alternative futures are imagined, struggled over, and made livable. Each paper examines communities operating at the margins of both institutional science and mainstream religion that are nonetheless engaged in urgent, consequential work to open new horizons: epistemically, cosmologically, and therapeutically. Together, the papers illuminate how UFO subcultures, alien abduction communities, and the scientific practices of SETI researchers function as laboratories for the anthropology of the future–spaces where competing imaginations contest the shape of what is possible, who has the authority to say so, and what forms of life will be viable.
Papers
This paper examines how SETI practitioners use game theory, historical analogy, and policy protocols to predict and control the fundamentally unknowable event of contact with extraterrestrial intelligence. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork and analysis of scientific literature, I argue these methods constitute scientific divination that transforms radical uncertainty into managed risk while simultaneously generating new forms of enchantment. Game-theoretical models depend on non-empirical axioms that conjure particular futures into calculable existence. Historical analogies mobilize sanitized colonial narratives as predictive tools, reading futures in the past. Post-detection protocols impose bureaucratic order onto speculative scenarios, promising control without eliminating surprise. Rather than opposing enchantment, these rational methods produce meta-empirical otherness—potential alien presences that structure present action despite their unknowability and speculative nature. SETI's predictive practices are existential technologies for navigating decisions with species-ending consequences, revealing how prediction operates and enchantment intensifies precisely where empirical grounding fails and rationalization appears most complete.
This paper will provide an overview of the lineage of thought, treatment, and community building that anomalous experiencers have engaged with to make meaning of what has happened to them. Drawing from archival research and ethnographic fieldwork, this paper reframes the lives of experiencers, and often their most traumatic moments, not as cultural curiosities but as sites of lived meaning and care within the context of psychiatric history and religious experience.
How do meaning-making strategies surrounding the “UFO phenomenon” intersect with “religion”? This paper explores the call-and-response between mainstream institutional UFO denial and grassroots subcultural knowledge production. The UFO phenomenon and associated notions of non-human intelligence destabilize hegemonic Western paradigms. Those in the UFO community navigate this fraught terrain through four distinguishable truth-seeking orientations: 1) speculative-political, 2) investigative-scientific, 3) communicative-spiritual, and 4) reconstructive-experiential. Symbolic boundaries and appeals to authority, experience, and science position UFO knowledge relative to mainstream institutions. Communicative-spiritual knowledge production, the third mode, is oriented vis-à-vis the spiritual-but-not-religious milieu as well as religious orthodoxies. In the U.S., UFO communities bypass both cautious Catholic openness and fundamentalist Christian demonization of UFOs to improvisationally bricolage Christian, Hindu, Buddhist, esoteric, and New Age elements into UFO-based spiritualities. The paper will conclude with two subcultural case studies of attempts at communication with non-human intelligences and the hierarchies of knowledge thereby reproduced or subverted.
Many people who play games understand their actions as political. This session examines the role of games and sport in creating space for political expression, forging a humanistic outlook, and informing theological understandings.
Papers
My paper pexplores the humanizing ethic of sport that counters the weighing imposition of authoritarian governments. I suggest that viewing sports through the philosophy of humanism provides a window into speaking about and addressing difficult topics like religion and politics in sporting spaces. Humanism is a lifestance that envisions and practices living well without organized religion, typically amongst individuals in a loose collective of nonbelievers. I argue that humanism can act as an interpretive framework through which sport becomes a site of ethical resistance. I draw upon humanist insights from religion and sport theorists like Eric Bain-Selbo, the theory of Olympism in conversation with early modern humanist philosophers like Albert Camus, values conveyed from prominent atheist professional athletes, and compare between the story of Springboks role in addressing the aftermath of the South Africa apartheid and the targeted effort amongst American female professional athletes against unjust governmental structures.
Responding to C. Thi Nguyen’s recent work on the philosophy of games, I argue that both the history and form of the fantasy tabletop role-playing game Dungeons and Dragons have profound lessons for theological doctrine. I critique Nguyen’s brief treatment of D&D and argue that his own distinction between a ‘dish’ and a ‘recipe’ reveals the danger — navigated by players, religious studies scholars, and practitioners alike — of reducing games to rules, and theology to doctrine. This is a particularly salient danger for theological education, wherein students are familiarizing themselves not just with doctrines but what doctrine itself is and can do. Drawing from recent work on theological education and method, I argue that students must be brought to terms with the constitutive ambivalence of doctrine, and work to gain a more capacious understanding of doctrine’s varied uses, contexts, politics, and corresponding — but never containable — ways of life.
This paper illustrates the ways American Muslim teen girls in the U.S. heartland respond creatively, playfully, faithfully and politically to the precarity of their world through playing basketball. I map the various authorizing forces which impact girls’ ability to play basketball and how the girls play authorities against each other to achieve their goals. I show that they do this by playing up or downplaying basketball as a serious endeavor. Their desire to play is very serious, but they play to have fun. While some girls "fight to play" by finessing the meritorious and beneficial aspects of playing basketball to parents skeptical of their daughters “wasting time,” other girls "play to fight," using their platform as esteemed athletes for anti-war activism. I argue that through playing, Muslim teens recover a girlhood for themselves in a context bent on denying it to them while transforming the community around them.
Respondent
This session examines the concept of “the world” in the thought of Tupac Shakur as a space structured by the negation of Black life through sexual stigmatization, carceral surveillance, and Black male vulnerability. Through close readings of tracks such as “F*** the World” and “Blasphemy,” it argues that juridical power and media function as mechanisms that render Black men objects of suspicion and punishment.
Situating Shakur within broader traditions of Black critique, the paper engages the notion of “thingification” to show how Black male life is constructed as inherently culpable. It further argues that Shakur articulates a form of racial eschatology, drawing on dispensationalist discourse while reorienting it toward present conditions. In this account, hell is not deferred but lived. Against this “world,” Shakur gestures toward a counter-eschatological horizon of Black peace and release.
Papers
With the approaching 30th anniversary of the tragic passing of Tupac Amaru Shakur, an appraisal of how Shakur conceived the idea of “future” is warranted, particularly in light of his consistent articulation and expectation of his early death. This paper explores Shakur’s notion of death as liberative against the terrors of modernity and its commitments to the subjugation, early death, and disappearance of Black persons. Within this framework, I pay particular attention to how Shakur critiques the organized vision of the future articulated within dispensationalist eschatology, a framework through which Black futures are rendered unavailable under the terms of modernity. Rather than imagining the present as a site where Black flourishing is possible, Shakur calls for the end of the world and its dominating logics while visually and sonically depicting Black flourishing in a deferred future—a Black heaven. This paper reads these themes through the song “Blasphemy” from The Don Killuminati: The Seven Day Theory and the video for “I Ain’t Mad at Cha.”
Respondent
This session consists of four ethnographic studies of local, often marginalized forms of lived Hinduism practiced in North America. Focused on peculiar, sometimes hidden varieties of Hindu devotion and practice, these projects represent various engagements between devotees and their traditions as they have been reinterpreted and recreated for new contexts, times, and cultures. The panel’s emphasis on ethnography not only de-centers Indian Hinduism, but also shifts the focus away from scholarly and other conventions and towards devotee perspectives and experiences, as well as material realities. Addressing cases ranging from deity devotion and contemporary events to Hindu communities and even inter-religious mixing, these papers depart from traditional narratives. Collectively they invite renewed reflection upon Hinduism and diaspora, and call our attention to the frequently ignored creativity and originality employed under the broader heading of Hinduism as it expands into, engages with, and enculturates itself into ever new times and places.
Papers
This paper studies the Brahma Kumari tradition in Canada and in global space. The focus is on the issue of globalized identity and female religious authority of the followers. I examine several aspects of the globalization of Brahma Kumari in Canada and its complex links with South Asian religions in India. It seems that the tradition is at crossroads, just as the devotees’ cultural identity is at crossroads – being simultaneously Western and at the same time South Asian. What happens when traditions and identities are at crossroads? Do globalized traditions produce globalized identities? Are there any other transformations that happen in this cultural mobility? By means of analysis of texts and data from interviews with Brahma Kumari followers, this paper seeks to reframe the Brahma Kumari tradition in a global context, a truly global movement, which has made home in Canada while maintaining links with the spiritual homeland in India.
This this paper will explore the presence, vitality, and active worship of two Hindu goddesses in the Tamil diaspora in the San Francisco Bay Area. While Lakshmi is very well known, representing wealth, health, and auspiciousness, the earth goddess Bhudevi is not as focused upon. Recent wildfires in California wrought havoc, raising questions connecting devotion and ecology. How does environmental catastrophe affect Hindu Americans’ worship of Bhudevi or Lakshmi? Are there caste distinctions or class differences to note, and how do these shape the perceptions of the Hindu diaspora? These questions will be investigated through the interlaced lenses of 1) economics and the varying notions of “value”; 2) the Hindu sacralization of the natural world and its relationship to environmental knowledge; and 3) transformative individual and community action about climate chaos. This research will be based on ethnographic fieldwork situated around two temples: Concord Siva-Murugan Temple and Livermore Siva-Vishnu Temple.
This paper addresses the creative expansions of the god Jagannath as he travels from his origins in the state of Odisha into the US Hindu diaspora. Despite the popularity of Jagannath’s Ratha Yatra festival, far less attention has been paid to his other travels and his continuous material re-creations. De-centering Puri and its more orthodox Hinduism, this paper confronts some lesser-known movements and dwellings of the god in the San Francisco Bay area. These more imaginative adaptations of the god address the concerns and very lives of the devotees who live there. As a result, the god has moved and transformed—including in his material forms—into American Hindu communities and the homes of everyday devotees. Relying on material culture studies and ethnography, this study delves into more marginal aspects of the god’s transformative reality that allow him to be present to devotees across time, place, and culture.
This paper presents testimonies from Thai-American restaurateurs whose businesses function not only as sites of commerce but also as spaces where distinctive modes of engagement with Hindu deities emerge. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork among Thai communities in the northeastern US, the study examines the growing presence of Hindu deities such as Ganesha and Krishna in restaurant interiors. These visual arrangements reflect recent religious developments in Thailand, where Hindu gods have gained prominence as patrons of entrepreneurial success, and reveal how Thai migrants carry these practices into North America. By examining how restaurant art and décor mediate encounters with Hindu imagery, the paper argues that Thai Buddhist restaurateurs emerge as unexpected stewards of Hindu devotion in North America. In doing so, the study highlights how migration, religious materiality, and interreligious borrowing invite us to reconsider familiar narratives about Asian American religion while helping decenter India in the study of global Hinduism.
Respondent
How might arts-based and imaginative practices function not simply as modes of representation, but as sites of theological reflection and ecclesial imagination? How might embodied experiences serve as loci for imagination of the future/s?
This session explores the methodological possibilities that emerge when ethnographic research engages creative and arts-based practices. Papers in this session examine how drawing, creative writing, and image-focused mixed-methods research function as methodological tools that both reveal and generate theological insight. By foregrounding methodological innovation, this conversation will highlight how ethnographic research can both document and generate new possibilities for understanding the future(s) of church.
Papers
How can social-scientific inquiry and systematic ecclesiology be brought into constructive dialogue? This paper explores the relationship between lived Ecclesial imagination and theological models of the Church by placing empirical research into conversation with classical ecclesiology. Drawing on mixed quantitative and qualitative methods—including a congregational survey and follow-up interviews in a Taiwanese church—the study identifies “the church as home” as a dominant lived Ecclesial image shaping belonging, care, worship, and communal identity. Engaging Avery Dulles’s Models of the Church as a theological framework, the paper argues that classical ecclesiology has tended to privilege institutional and corporate metaphors while under-theologizing domestic and relational dimensions of ecclesial life. The findings demonstrate how empirical research can function not merely as illustration but as a generative partner in ecclesiology, prompting the refinement of theological models by attending to operative ecclesial imaginaries within lived Christian communities.
The 2015 report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada identified ongoing structures that continue to enforce oppression against Indigenous peoples across Canada and deform the relationships between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples. Scholars in the Americas describe these structures as coloniality and recognize their overt and subtle embeddedness within Western culture. As a part of a larger research project investigating coloniality in Canadian Anglican liturgy, this paper focuses on one ethnographic tool to reveal the subtle manifestations of coloniality: drawing. While the drawings were initially used as a starting point for interviews, they emerged as a source of data themselves, demonstrating the unconscious ways participants conceived of Anglican worship. This research analyzes selected drawings to demonstrate the ways in which they manifest domination, Eurocentric liturgical practices, and binary classifications, showing that coloniality remains a subtle and pervasive force in liturgical practice.
This paper explores ongoing research that examines the intersections of trauma, theology, and creative writing within the Downtown Eastside of Vancouver (DTES). Grounded in trauma theory, ethnographic, and practical theological methods, this paper recognizes the ways in which collective and individual trauma impacts theological imagination and faith practices and explores the role that spirituality can play in survival and meaning-making post trauma. At the same time, it takes seriously the potential of creative writing—not merely as a method, but as a practice of resistance and healing. This research aims to understand how theological meaning emerges in and through trauma, and how creative writing functions as a site of theological reflection. Its aim is to bring more voices into theological conversations about trauma, and in doing so, open a wider scope of how theology is constructed, the settings that shape it, and whose voices are recognized and amplified.
The 2025 film KPop Demon Hunters exposed many fans to elements of Korean religion which the film draws upon. This film is just one recent example of how popular culture, from or based on Korea, intersects with Korean religion. In response to this growing phenomenon, this session features three papers that address the representation of Korean religion within popular culture media. The first paper examines KPop Demon Hunters as a hybridized example of musical exorcisms in Korea, referencing elements of shamanism, Christianity, and Buddhism together with K-pop and appealing diverse audiences. The second paper argues that the “Jesus Birthday Cafe” (Jesus Saeng-ca), organized by Korea Campus Crusade for Christ, refashions Christian devotion through the affective and participatory grammar of K-pop fandom. The final paper approaches KPop Demon Hunters as a tool for education about Korean religion, taking advantage of the film’s broad popularity and its heavy reliance on Korean religious influences.
Papers
This paper addresses the Future/s theme by interpreting KPop Demon Hunters (KDH) as a meditation on Korea’s contested religious past that imagines a global future in which shared musical experiences exorcise literal and metaphorical demons by uniting religiously and culturally diverse audiences. KDH celebrates but does not merely represent Korean “shamanism,” creating a hybrid cosmology that cross-references elements from Christianity, Buddhism, and popular culture. Specifically, the film’s conceit of music as exorcism connects centuries-old kut (musical rituals to appease spirits) to pre-Pentecostal Protestant uses of hymn-singing and modern Pentecostal megachurch worship as techniques deployed first to demonize indigenous religions and then to exorcise spirits identified as demons. KDH is sufficiently non-specific about this religious history to attract diverse audiences, bringing together established fan bases for Hallyu (Korean wave) and exorcism media. Mobilizing ambiguous meanings of “idol,” KDH idealizes a global spiritual community fueled by fan devotion to popular cultural artists.
This paper argues that the “Jesus Birthday Cafe” (Jesus Saeng-ca), organized by Korea Campus Crusade for Christ, refashions Christian devotion through the affective and participatory grammar of K-pop fandom. Modeled on the K-pop “Idol Birthday Cafe,” the event transforms Christmas into an Instagrammable pop-up devotional space structured around Jesus photo cards, a photo zone, and limited-edition goods. These material forms make faith tangible, emotionally resonant, and culturally legible for a digital-native generation. Yet they also mediate encounter with the divine through commodified signs shaped by a white, Eurocentric, male image of Jesus. The paper contends that the Jesus Birthday Cafe does more than popularize Christianity; it reveals how evangelical belonging is increasingly produced through consumer aesthetics, affective participation, and visual mediation, while simultaneously reproducing colonial Christian visuality. In doing so, it exposes tensions among accessibility, devotion, commodification, and postcolonial critique in contemporary South Korean evangelical culture and practice today.
The US-made animated film KPop Demon Hunters, released on Netflix in 2025, has broken viewership records and won milestone awards. Its breakout popularity has meant greater attention by American and global audiences to Korean culture and religion. This presents a challenge, but also an opportunity to use the current popularity of that film, and the interest it generates, to teach wider audiences about Korean religious culture. This paper explains and argues that KPop Demon Hunters can and should be used as an effective teaching tool. I explain ways in which Korean religion and culture are used in the film. Then I describe examples of the pedagogical application of KPop Demon Hunters, including an account of my public lecture on the History Behind KPop Demon Hunters given at the Ann Arbor District Library and incorporation into other lessons and works on Korean religion by myself and other scholars.
Respondent
This paper session engages with the concepts of “moral injury” and recovery in light of AAR’s 2026 presidential theme of the future. The session places moral injury in global, transnational, and intersectional contexts, and shows how the forms of oppression and injury the concept can illuminate and clarify discursively also become sites for recovery, possibility, solidarity, and imagining a viable future together. With the rise of authoritarianism around the world, dystopian visions of the future are increasingly popular. Oppressive and unjust ethical, religious, legal, and moral frameworks in the West disguised as progress, fairness, and civility have resulted in amplified physical, semiotic, and psychic violence directed toward minority groups across the globe. Spiritual, communal, and cultural forms of response and response-ability to these moral, epistemic and hermeneutic conditions motivate the proceedings of the session and address the fate of our futurity in an age of precarity.
Papers
Black contemporary gospel music provides a womanist method for spiritual care and physical healing. However, little scholarship has examined the capacity for gospel music to heal Black women against the health-reducing factors necessitating their healing, especially the physically and spiritually deleterious effects of stress and, upon accumulation, moral injury. Black women within the United States face particular psychological-spiritual distress resulting from intersectional stress due to the multidimensional oppression imposed on them along race, gender, class, and age. Given that music interventions offer a scalable, cost-effective approach to alleviate physiological stress and psychological stress, this paper proposes the first-ever framework and evidence-base identifying the stress-reducing qualities of Black contemporary gospel music in order to guide the development of gospel music interventions specifically tailored to Black women’s lived experiences with intersectional stress and moral injury.
This paper engages Miranda Fricker's framework of epistemic injustice and Jonathan Shay's theory of moral injury to examine the intersections of epistemic injustice, moral injury, and moral repair in diasporic contexts.
This paper examines the moral injuries experienced by American Protestant missionaries during the Nanjing Massacre and the Nanking Safety Zone (1937–1938), arguing that their suffering reveals moral injury less as an individual pathology than as a sign of systemic failure. Drawing on diaries, letters, and reports by Minnie Vautrin, Miner Searle Bates, George Fitch, and Robert Wilson, the paper analyzes how humanitarian and spiritual labor under conditions of occupation, scarcity, and violence produced distinct forms of moral injury, including guilt over exclusion, indirect collusion, remorse over misjudgment, and anguish under impossible triage. In conversation with current debates over defining “moral injury disorder,” the paper argues that pathologizing moral injury risks shifting attention away from institutional betrayal and structural violence. The Nanjing case shows that spiritual caregivers themselves may be uniquely vulnerable, and that moral injury can function as an embodied political and theological critique.
The Annual November Meeting of the National Association of Baptist Professors of Religion is open to all AAR/SBL conference attendees. The session will feature a presidential address by Laura Rodgers Levens, BSK and a plenary address by Oluwatomisin Olayinka Oredein, Brite Divinity School. The two presentations will include QandA and be followed by a brief business session.
