This roundtable invites scholars to examine Tibetan religious phenomena whose actual lives diverge from their ostensible purposes. It takes its start from Magritte’s famous provocation, “Ceci n’est pas un pipe” which pushes the viewer to distinguish between the appearance of an object (in Magritte’s case, a picture of a tobacco pipe) and the actual object. Our intention is to move beyond taking Tibetan and Himalayan objects, practices, and ideas at face value, remaining attentive to the unexpected, and finding meaning in the hidden or unforeseen. Together we aim to cultivate sharper attention to the actuality of objects rather than taking them for granted based on mere appearance or assumed function.
In-person November Annual Meeting 2026 Program Book
The 2026 November Annual Meeting in Denver, CO: Friday, November 20 - Tuesday, November 24. All times are listed in Mountain Time Zone. For more information about the November Annual Meeting, co-hosted with the Society of Biblical Literature, click here.
Please note that this is the preliminary schedule and is subject to change. We anticipate a mostly final schedule in mid-August. If you have any questions, please contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org. For Other Events, your event is not confirmed until you received notification from AAR staff.
This panel examines the role of festivals, ritual assemblies, and public religious celebrations in shaping Buddhist ritual culture across Asia. Moving beyond doctrinal or philosophical frameworks, the papers foreground ritual performance, visual culture, and communal participation as key mechanisms of religious transmission. Together, the papers trace transregional patterns of ritual adaptation across South, East, and Himalayan Asia. The first paper explores the transformation of large-scale ritual assemblies from India to China through reinterpretations of sacrificial and Buddhist ceremonial traditions. The second paper examines early Buddhist image cults associated with episodes from the Buddha’s life, focusing on festivals and image processions as sites of devotional practice. The third paper investigates contemporary syncretic festival culture in Nepal, where Buddhist and Hindu ritual traditions converge in educational and life-cycle rites. Collectively, the panel highlights how festivals functioned as dynamic sites of ritual translation and religious innovation in Buddhist Asia.
Papers
This paper reexamines the origin and ritual character of the Wuzhe Assembly (Ch. wuzhe hui 無遮會), a large-scale Buddhist religious gathering described by the Chinese monk Xuanzang at the court of King Harṣavardhana. Since the nineteenth century, scholars have generally identified the Wuzhe Assembly with the pañcavārṣika (“Five-Year Assembly”). Building on recent philological research, this paper argues instead that the term more likely reflects the Sanskrit nirargaḍamedha, a ritual concept associated with unrestricted generosity and large-scale ceremonial giving that may ultimately derive from the Brahmanical sarvamedha (“universal sacrifice”). By reassessing textual and historical evidence from Indian and Chinese sources, the paper shows how this ritual idea was transformed within Buddhist contexts into large public religious gatherings combining royal patronage, merit-making, and communal participation. The study thus highlights how ritual concepts and forms of religious celebration were transmitted and reinterpreted as Buddhism moved from India to China.
This paper discusses early images depicting Siddhartha as a young prince during his First Meditation, along with epigraphical records attesting to this image cult. Additionally, several passages from the Vinayas of the Sarvāstivādins and Mūlasarvāstivādins preserved in Classical Chinese also document the now largely forgotten image worship of the Bodhisattva Siddhartha and shed light on the cult and iconographic significance of the First Meditation image, helping explain its transregional popularity. These materials demonstrate that the “jambu tree shadow image” once stood at the center of an important monastic cult and formed part of festivals and image processions associated with the major Buddhist festival celebrating Śākyamuni’s Enlightenment, known as the “Great Festival.” The paper also considers the connection between this cult and the emergence of the “Pensive Crown Prince” (Ch. siwei taizi) image, likely originating in Northern India and Gandhāra and later popular across China and East Asia.
Mañju Pañcamī (Śrī Pañcamī) is a major cultural and religious festival of the Kathmandu Valley that commemorates the arrival of Mañjuśrī from China’s sacred Mount Wutai. Celebrated on the fifth day of the waxing moon in Māgha (January–February), the festival venerates Mañjuśrī—revered as the prince of Buddhist Dharma as well as Sarasvatī, the Hindu goddess of learning. This study examines the festival’s syncretic character, in which Buddhist and Hindu traditions converge in shared devotion to wisdom and speech. It also explores associated practices, including ritual bathing at Taudaha Lake for scholarship and prosperity, and the widespread belief that this auspicious day permits life‑cycle ceremonies without astrological consultation. A central rite initiates children into education by guiding them to write “Namo Vāgīśvarāya.” As a nationally observed festival, Mañju Pañcamī integrates religious veneration with educational and social rites of passage, reflecting the Kathmandu Valley’s long-standing cultural harmony.
This panel examines the role of festivals, ritual assemblies, and public religious celebrations in shaping Buddhist ritual culture across Asia. Moving beyond doctrinal or philosophical frameworks, the papers foreground ritual performance, visual culture, and communal participation as key mechanisms of religious transmission. Together, the papers trace transregional patterns of ritual adaptation across South, East, and Himalayan Asia. The first paper explores the transformation of large-scale ritual assemblies from India to China through reinterpretations of sacrificial and Buddhist ceremonial traditions. The second paper examines early Buddhist image cults associated with episodes from the Buddha’s life, focusing on festivals and image processions as sites of devotional practice. The third paper investigates contemporary syncretic festival culture in Nepal, where Buddhist and Hindu ritual traditions converge in educational and life-cycle rites. Collectively, the panel highlights how festivals functioned as dynamic sites of ritual translation and religious innovation in Buddhist Asia.
Papers
This paper reexamines the origin and ritual character of the Wuzhe Assembly (Ch. wuzhe hui 無遮會), a large-scale Buddhist religious gathering described by the Chinese monk Xuanzang at the court of King Harṣavardhana. Since the nineteenth century, scholars have generally identified the Wuzhe Assembly with the pañcavārṣika (“Five-Year Assembly”). Building on recent philological research, this paper argues instead that the term more likely reflects the Sanskrit nirargaḍamedha, a ritual concept associated with unrestricted generosity and large-scale ceremonial giving that may ultimately derive from the Brahmanical sarvamedha (“universal sacrifice”). By reassessing textual and historical evidence from Indian and Chinese sources, the paper shows how this ritual idea was transformed within Buddhist contexts into large public religious gatherings combining royal patronage, merit-making, and communal participation. The study thus highlights how ritual concepts and forms of religious celebration were transmitted and reinterpreted as Buddhism moved from India to China.
This paper discusses early images depicting Siddhartha as a young prince during his First Meditation, along with epigraphical records attesting to this image cult. Additionally, several passages from the Vinayas of the Sarvāstivādins and Mūlasarvāstivādins preserved in Classical Chinese also document the now largely forgotten image worship of the Bodhisattva Siddhartha and shed light on the cult and iconographic significance of the First Meditation image, helping explain its transregional popularity. These materials demonstrate that the “jambu tree shadow image” once stood at the center of an important monastic cult and formed part of festivals and image processions associated with the major Buddhist festival celebrating Śākyamuni’s Enlightenment, known as the “Great Festival.” The paper also considers the connection between this cult and the emergence of the “Pensive Crown Prince” (Ch. siwei taizi) image, likely originating in Northern India and Gandhāra and later popular across China and East Asia.
Mañju Pañcamī (Śrī Pañcamī) is a major cultural and religious festival of the Kathmandu Valley that commemorates the arrival of Mañjuśrī from China’s sacred Mount Wutai. Celebrated on the fifth day of the waxing moon in Māgha (January–February), the festival venerates Mañjuśrī—revered as the prince of Buddhist Dharma as well as Sarasvatī, the Hindu goddess of learning. This study examines the festival’s syncretic character, in which Buddhist and Hindu traditions converge in shared devotion to wisdom and speech. It also explores associated practices, including ritual bathing at Taudaha Lake for scholarship and prosperity, and the widespread belief that this auspicious day permits life‑cycle ceremonies without astrological consultation. A central rite initiates children into education by guiding them to write “Namo Vāgīśvarāya.” As a nationally observed festival, Mañju Pañcamī integrates religious veneration with educational and social rites of passage, reflecting the Kathmandu Valley’s long-standing cultural harmony.
In different settings and through varied methodological lenses, the ??? papers in this panel explore how our understanding of Chinese religious cultures is reshaped when attention shifts to material and digital dimensions. From explorations of the mirror of the Tang (618-907) and Buddhist statuary to an examination of postings of Buddhist lay rituals online and study of how AI tools shape scholarly annotation, these works demonstrate that digital and material turns offer new questions to guide the study of Chinese religions.
Papers
In late imperial China, while permanent vegetarianism was often criticized, periodic fasting gained widespread state and social acceptance. Central to this practice were widely circulated fasting calendars, which mapped sacred dates to encourage ritual purity, accumulate merit, and foster divine connections. This presentation explores the construction, circulation, and reception of knowledge concerning "divine time." Focusing on the representative Yuxiaji (玉匣記) and analyzing editions from 1684 to 1891, the study reveals how a shared repertoire of fasting days was created, transcending strict regional and confessional divides. Furthermore, by juxtaposing these prescriptive texts with descriptive historical sources from Suzhou—a major publishing and religious hub—this research demonstrates how fasting calendars were actively employed in daily practice, ultimately shedding light on the sanctification of everyday life and the temporal experience of spirituality.
Much scholarship on Chinese bronze mirrors emphasizes their Daoist associations. This paper highlights two overlooked cases that situate mirrors instead within the broader shushu數術 repertoire. The first concerns two ninth-century mirrors inscribed with a hemerological diagram used to select auspicious departure dates, a method widely attested in Chinese and Tibetan Dunhuang manuscripts. Their portability suggests that mirrors functioned as practical tools for managing travel risk. The second case, preserved in Tang poems and later ritual descriptions, involves a domestic divination in which a woman listens for chance speech after orienting herself through a spinning ladle in water; the square stove, round pot, and rotating ladle cosmologically map Earth, Heaven, and the Dipper. Together, these cases show the multivalence of mirror use beyond Daoism. They also reveal the gendered distribution of travel ritual, linking mobility, divination, and household practice in Tang China.
Through an analysis of the online circulation of short videos produced by Chinese lay Buddhists featuring their temple visits, this paper explores how such audio-visual artifacts mediate religious experiences and serve as a reflexive process in (re)constructing the interplay between religious traditions and ethical experiences. I focus on videos posted on one of China’s biggest social networking platforms, RedNote, which is especially popular for sharing tips on travel, makeup and fashion, to examine how lay Buddhist videos circulated in a media environment, where mass culture, consumer culture, and religious traditions interact with each other, reconstruct the concepts of religious experience, authenticity, and legitimacy. I also situate these videos within the context of the revival of Buddhism in reform-era China to see how they, embodying the renewed interest in traditional Buddhist self-cultivation, reveal the nexus of personhood construction and the social project of moral cultivation in contemporary China.
This paper extends current scholarly discussions of embodiment and healing in religious studies to the domain of material objects. By analyzing a corpus of medieval Chinese narratives that foreground the vulnerability and pain of Buddhist statues, the paper redefines disability not as a marker of alterity but as a vulnerable phase of existence shared by both sentient beings and Buddhist icons. The analysis further demonstrates that religious agents in medieval China often occupied simultaneous roles as caregivers and care-receivers, allowing healing to emerge through reciprocal relationships. This paper also shows that medieval Chinese monks employed Buddhist narratives to transform the material vulnerability of Buddhist images into sites of compassion and doctrinal reflection, thereby highlighting the significance of Buddhist literature beyond being mere didactic tools or records of social memory.
How do memories leave their traces on the land? And how does the landscape in turn render memories legible? This paper examines the emergence of the legend of the “Nodding Stones,” a hagiographic episode in the famous 4-5th century monk Zhu Daosheng’s biography, in which his sermons are so powerful that even rocks bow in assent. Although now firmly associated with Daosheng’s activity in Tiger Hill, Suzhou, the episode is absent from early biographies of him. Through a close reading of local gazetteers, Tang poetry, and sectarian biographies, I propose a new trajectory for the legend’s development from earlier materials to its later mature form. This paper shows that sacred geography is not a passive backdrop of narrative, and texts and spaces co-produce one another over time. Religious memory endures not simply through repetition in writing, but through its capacity to become anchored in place.
This panel explores the lives and self-understandings of working people in India, with an emphasis on the role of religion in animating their activities and struggles, engaging to various degrees Shankar Ramaswami’s Souls in the Kalyug: The Politics and Cosmologies of Migrant Workers in Contemporary India (University of Pennsylvania Press, 2025). The papers examine the vocabularies for interpreting precarity among Muslim migrant workers in Gurgaon; the implications of conceptualizations of divinity among factory workers in Delhi for posthumanist imaginaries; and the understandings of ritual possession practices as work and labor among oracles of the Goddess in Kerala.
Papers
This paper examines the entanglement of labour, class, and religion among migrant workers in Gurgaon, North India. Drawing on long-term ethnographic research, it invokes the Hindi term majboori (compulsion or necessity) as a key idiom through which workers interpret their precarious conditions. Migrants locate their hardships in the worldly order rather than divine will. This moral landscape is inseparable from Gurgaon's religious and class geography, where an ostensibly secular urbanism naturalises Hindu middle-class religiosity while rendering other working-class identities suspect. Engaging Shankar Ramaswami's Souls in the Kalyug: The Politics and Cosmologies of Migrant Workers in Contemporary India, the paper argues that majboori provides a framework through which migrants interpret labour precarity while sustaining dignity. It does so within a city that simultaneously depends on their labour yet excludes them from its moral community.
Addressing the unit’s special emphasis on religion and labor in South Asia, this paper will analyze an important, though implicit, connection between two main threads of Shankar Ramaswami’s Souls in the Kalyug: on the one hand, the close relationships between Delhi metal polishers and their machines, and on the other, divine presences in the factory and even within the machines themselves. As this paper will show, the resulting “god–man–machine” imbrication bears important implications not only for how the workers see themselves, their machines, and their gods, but also more broadly as a corrective to posthumanist frameworks which ignore or deny the crucial roles of the divine. This paper will thus contend that Ramaswami’s analysis, through its attention to the dynamic interactions among metal workers, their machines, and deities, pushes posthumanists to consider how the divine works alongside and in concert with technology in humans’ quest to be “more-than-human.”
This paper presentation will examine ritual practice as a form of labor by tracing Kamala's claim, an oracle of Kodungallur Bhagavathy in the southern Indian state of Kerala, that ritual possession is a toḻil (an occupation). Using a recurring weekly ritual at her personal shrine as an analytic thread, the paper studies how ritual possession, livelihood, and ethical life are co-constitutive. By situating her claim within the social and political histories of Izhava caste assertions of dignity, the presentation examines how work becomes an operative category for oracles both through its assertion and refusal. It analyzes the choreography and improvisation of this ritual across shrines, foregrounding ritual possession as a form of embodied labor co-authored with the Goddess.
Respondent
Through foregrounding environmental humanities, this panel explores how narrative, pedagogy, theology, and Indigenous media open up alternative ways of imagining ecological futures beyond dominant techno-optimist or dystopian frameworks. Across literary, educational, theological, and cinematic approaches, the papers examine how environmental crises can be re-narrated as sites of relational possibility and ethical responsibility. From submerged urban imaginaries in contemporary climate fiction, to pedagogical experiments inspired by Donna Haraway, the panel highlights storytelling as a means of cultivating ecological imagination and agency. It further develops decolonial and relational ecofeminist theology through Asian American frameworks of care and interdependence, and extends these insights through Indigenous cinematic practice in Biidaaban (The Dawn Comes), which foregrounds multispecies kinship and sacred land-based futurity. Together, these contributions emphasize that ecological futures are not singular or predetermined, but are actively shaped through practices of imagination, care, and situated forms of ecological knowledge.
Papers
Speaking of “futures” instead of “the future” foregrounds the fact that no singular future is guaranteed. In recent storytelling, two futures are particularly common: the techno-optimist, which envisions the triumph of capitalist innovation, and the climate dystopian, which envisions the inability of capitalism to contain its ecologically destructive powers. Both futures extrapolate features of the current “business-as-usual” order to one or another logical conclusion. This paper explores an alternative narrative found in several recent novels. These novels, including Eiren Caffall’s All the Water in the World (2025), Susanna Kwan’s Awake in the Floating City (2025), and Kim Stanley Robinson’s New York 2140 (2017), are set in cities that are now at least partially submerged by rising seas. While the waters wash away much of what the cities have been, they also make new forms of life possible. This paper explores the way these novels thematize water – and, with it, the uncontrollable power of a changing climate – as both destructive and potentially liberative.
This paper presents climate fiction as an essential pedagogical tool for envisioning more sustainable and just ecological futures, drawing upon the “The Camille Stories” by Donna J. Haraway as one example (2016). Haraway’s fiction depicts human and more-than-human ongoingness in the face of destruction and despair – challenging readers to resist nihilism and build resilient communities even without the guarantee of success. Beyond analyzing the theory and method of climate fiction, this paper focuses on the benefits of asking students to write their own fictional pieces. Fiction writing challenges students to envision the futures they actually want to sustain: the people, places, and values that are worth their collective effort to protect. Writing fiction also allows students to productively grapple with the possibilities and limits of their own ecological agency. This paper will conclude with practical activities and writing prompts that instructors can integrate within their own courses.
This project (re)imagines Asian American ecofeminist theology through planetary entanglements, offering a decolonizing, relational, and future-oriented response to ecological collapse, climate crisis, and pandemic precarity. Drawing on Judith Butler’s phenomenology of vulnerability and Catherine Keller’s panentheistic ecotheology, it situates ethical and theological reflection within the interdependence of human and more-than-human life. Central to both method and message are two Korean concepts: salim (살림), “enlivening” or "sustaining life", and jeong (정), "relational affectivity and "care". These concepts function as metaphor and ethical lens, showing how contextual, everyday ecofeminist practices—acts of care, repair, and co-flourishing—embody hope for planetary futures while enacting a decolonizing ethic that resists hierarchical and instrumental logics. Salim and jeong provide frameworks for (re)imagining ecological and social interdependence, situating hope as one of many therapeutic-paths within broader ecotheology. The study advances a decolonial theology of Hope, envisioning a new Earth/us co-created through care, relational integrity, and transformative planetary engagement.
My paper examines how Biidaaban (The Dawn Comes)—Amanda Strong’s stop-motion film—visualizes sacred landscapes and Indigenous futures through its portrayal of Biidaaban, Sabe, ancestors, and multispecies kin reclaiming maple-sugaring practices within a suburban neighborhood. Drawing on Indigenous visual sovereignty, sensory film analysis, and decolonial theories of land-relation in dialogue with religion and ecology, the paper reflects on the film’s textures, contrasts of light, and spatial layering to show how cinematic form becomes a mode of ceremony and ecological imagination. Strong’s film reveals a sacred geography that persists against erasure, rendering land not as backdrop but as a living network of ancestral presence and multispecies relationality. Its aesthetic strategies display the interweaving of past and present and how future sacred geographies emerge through acts of care and multispecies belonging. Ultimately, this paper interprets Biidaaban as a visual, ceremonial practice of ecological homemaking—an Indigenous futurity that refuses erasure.
Religions have long used the arts to support physical and spiritual healing. This includes dance, performance, music, visual arts, and storytelling. The papers in this panel explore different art forms as methods of healing. The first paper employs documentary poetic practices to explore how ordinary believers reinterpret the language of sacrificial suffering in Christian terms as they endure violence. The second paper examines documentary poems that connect biblical narratives with the lived experiences of disabled people, especially those that focus on the "hands of God." The third paper views photography as a form of chaplaincy from an Asian woman's perspective, highlighting dignity, recognition, and community connection. The final paper, inspired by the story of the woman caught in adultery, reflects on how the church often rushes to cast stones instead of showing love, especially regarding sexuality.
Papers
What does it mean to “take up one’s cross” when suffering is lived within the realities of domestic violence, poverty, and social exclusion? This presentation performs a found-text documentary poem that places the biblical command in Matthew 16:24 in dialogue with poems written by my grandmother, a domestic-violence survivor in rural Appalachia. Drawing on documentary poetic practices, the piece assembles scripture, vernacular poetry, and narrative fragments drawn from a memoir based on family testimony. The poem asks how ordinary believers reinterpret the Christian language of sacrificial suffering while surviving violence. By staging this encounter through documentary poetics, the project demonstrates how vernacular archives of lived faith can participate in the ongoing reinterpretation of sacred texts.
This documentary poem places biblical narratives in direct conversation with the lived experiences of Disabled people, focusing specifically on the "hands of God." By centering this tactile imagery, the work highlights God’s own embodiment through the Incarnation, reframing the divine as one who navigates the world in a Disabled body (after Nancy Eiesland). Too often, scripture is weaponized to link Disability with sin or a "lack of faith." This poem combats such harmful associations, instead uplifting Disabled bodies as good, powerful, and sacred. It creatively imagines a present-day Jesus who bears the marks of his experience and asks: What if the resurrected Christ used a wheelchair? What if Jesus needed to communicate in different ways after the crucifixion? By viewing mobility aids and accommodations as holy, this work invites us to see the Imago Dei in the diverse, beautiful reality of Disabled life.
This presentation explores photography as a form of chaplaincy practice. Drawing from my work as Community Minister at Judson Memorial Church in New York City and as a multi-faith chaplain in training through the FE/CPE program at Union Theological Seminary, I examine how visual practices can function as acts of pastoral presence, witnessing, and care. While chaplaincy in medical institutions often limits creative approaches to spiritual care, my work at Judson allows me to experiment with photography as a pastoral method that centers dignity, recognition, and community connection. The presentation includes a curated photo exhibition, Faces of Judson, documenting moments of gathering, creativity, and everyday life within the congregation. Reflecting on photography’s history as a colonial and extractive medium often dominated by white male photographers, I approach the camera differently—as an Asian woman chaplain using photography not to “take” images, but to practice care, relational presence, and ethical witnessing.
Drawing on the story of the woman caught in adultery, this poem reflects on how the church is often quicker to cast stones than to show love, especially when it comes to sexuality. Calling out the harmful conflation of Queerness with sin, it instead lifts up Queer bodies and Queer love as something beautiful and sacred. Through these lines, I imagine how Christ would respond to the Queer community with the kindness and assurance of love that he showed those outside the boundaries drawn by religious leaders. By reimagining these verses, I hope to offer a space where Queer people can see themselves not as outliers to the Church, but as central participants in the ongoing, beautiful unfolding of God’s creative work.
Bringing together an international cohort of scholars from Bangladesh, Thailand, Canada, and the United States, this roundtable reflects on how Buddhist monastic communities mobilize ethical frameworks, ritual technologies, and disciplinary ideals to shape social life, negotiate authority, and enact religious reform across Buddhist regions. While monastic ethics are often imagined as inward‑facing or primarily concerned with internal discipline and maintaining monastic distance from lay society, the contributors discuss ways in which monastic ideals shape public life more broadly. From lineage reconstruction in nineteenth‑century Bengal, to robe controversies in pre‑modern Myanmar, to ritual technologies that blur lay–monastic boundaries in Vajrayāna communities, to the experiences of female renunciates ( thilashin) during the Japanese Occupation of Burma, to contemporary reform movements in Ladakh and the Indian Himalayas, these reflections reveal how monastic actors continually reinterpret ethical norms to address crisis, assert legitimacy, and bring monastic perspectives into debates shaping public spheres throughout Asia.
Papers
This contribution reflects on the nineteenth‑ and early‑twentieth‑century reinstallation of Theravāda Buddhism in Bangladesh, situating monastic reform within the long history of Buddhist transmission in Bengal. While southeastern Bengal had survived as a marginalized Buddhist region with weakened ordination lineages and fragmented institutional authority, reformers such as Sāramedha Mahāsthabir and Saṅgharāj Ācāriya Purṇāchār Chandramohan Mahāsthabir sought to restore continuity, legitimacy, and doctrinal coherence. Drawing on historical sources, regional Buddhist historiography, monastic narratives, and institutional records, the speaker reflects on how lineage reform functioned as the central mechanism through which religious authority was renegotiated and restored. In a context where doubts concerning higher ordination, Vinaya observance, and ritual propriety had eroded communal confidence, revitalization was framed as both a return to canonical orthodoxy and a moral purification of the Saṅgha. These reflections also consider how reform unfolded within a dynamic environment shaped by transregional mobility across the Bay of Bengal and renewed connections with Myanmar, Sri Lanka, and Southeast Asia, ultimately producing the Saṅgharāj Nikāya and Mahāsthabir Nikāya as structured systems of monastic governance.
This presentation explores the Atin–Ayone robe controversy, a dispute over whether monks should wear the robe over one shoulder (ekaṃsika) or cover both shoulders (pārupana), which emerged in the early eighteenth century and intensified during the Konbaung period. The Ayone faction introduced the Cūḷagandhi sub‑commentary to resolve scriptural ambiguities, while the Atin group was unable to provide authoritative textual support. In 1784, King Bodawpaya intervened, imposing the pārupana style across the entire Sangha and establishing an eight‑member council of Saṅgharājās to supervise monastic discipline and purify the Sangha. Drawing on Weber’s theory of legitimate authority and Bourdieu’s concepts of the religious field and symbolic capital, the speaker reflects on how the resolution of the controversy marked a shift from local monastic pluralism to state‑sponsored orthodoxy, transforming the Cūḷagandhi into a decisive legal instrument. By privileging this sub‑commentary over other Pāli sources, the monarchy and monastic elite jointly produced a specialized textual authority that facilitated institutional reform and doctrinal uniformity in pre‑modern Myanmar.
This speaker offers reflections on the theg chen gso sbyong (Mahāyāna Poṣadha) ritual as a technology of temporary lay monasticism practiced across the Tibeto‑Himalayan region and in communities of converts. Although the vows of the ritual closely mirror the one‑day lay vows of the Prātimokṣa, the gso sbyong uniquely allows both lay practitioners and fully ordained monastics to receive and practice the vows together. Drawing on textual analysis and commentary from teachers such as Trijiang Rinpoche and Khenpo Karthar Rinpoche, the speaker considers how the ritual temporarily suspends the hierarchical logic of Prātimokṣa ranking, creating a sanctioned space in which monastic and lay boundaries are blurred. In some cases, lay practitioners holding the gso sbyong may even sleep in monastery prayer halls, accessing spaces normally restricted to monastics. These reflections highlight how the ritual functions as a “great equalizer,” opening monastic spaces to laypeople and imbuing Śrāvakayāna vows with the Mahāyāna bodhisattva spirit.
This speaker reflects on how Buddhist monasticism enters the public sphere in Ladakh, focusing on reform movements in the post‑Partition nation‑state. The contribution considers how monastic and lay reformers forged alliances to confront practices they identified as “social evils,” including animal sacrifice, alcohol consumption, and polyandry. These reform campaigns generated new discourses of normative Buddhism that often conflicted with vernacular traditions associated with local spirit practices, creating tensions between monastic authorities and lay ritual specialists such as oracles, astrologers, and tantric practitioners. The speaker further reflects on how Buddhist communities navigate the complexities of being Buddhist Indian citizens, negotiating religious identity, national belonging, and the rise of new public spheres shaped by media, state policy, and shifting communal expectations. Through these dynamics, the contribution highlights how monastic ethics become tools for social intervention, moral regulation, and the redefinition of Buddhist identity in contemporary India.
Respondent
This panel shows various experiments that scholars are doing, applying artificial intelligence to Religion and Religious Studies
Papers
In artificial intelligence (AI) research and development, a benchmark combines data and evaluation criteria to measure how well AI systems perform specific tasks or demonstrate particular abilities. Developing meaningful benchmarks represents a significant opportunity for religious and ethical scholars to shape AI’s future in a positive direction. With Generative AI, evaluation methods alone can orient AI training processes toward moral improvement and religious awareness. Recent efforts to evaluate the ethical dimensions of large language models (LLMs) set the stage for extending this frontier as do well-recognized challenges in constructing models that capture diverse human cultures. Developing benchmarks that more broadly measure human and other suffering, compassionate responses, and richer conceptions of flourishing and well-being provide timely and impactful means to affect AI development. Efforts toward these state-of-the-art ethical and religious benchmarks are reviewed, discussed, and situated within a broader framework oriented toward flourishing.
This paper proposes an open, ontology-driven, AI-mediated research environment for the study of Greek religious texts built from public-domain and openly licensed corpora rather than proprietary platforms. Using TEI/XML resources such as GLAUx, Open Greek & Latin, and Perseus/Scaife, the project explores whether agentic coding tools can automate corpus normalization, metadata reconciliation, citation alignment, hyperlink generation, ontology construction, and graph-based retrieval across biblical, early Christian, and related Greek materials. Unlike conventional search systems centered on keywords, lemmas, or fixed indices, the proposed environment supports relation-aware discovery, customizable semantic linking, and provenance-preserving exploration across corpora. Rather than treating AI as an autonomous interpreter, the paper argues that agentic systems function as infrastructural and hermeneutical assistants: they lower the cost of building open research environments and help scholars navigate, explain, and extend them while preserving human judgment as decisive.
This paper introduces the InterSapience Project, a theological and interreligious proposal for rethinking AI alignment as a moral and relational problem rather than merely a technical one. I advance the notion of “co‑intelligence” (the integrated dynamics of collective, collaborative, and cooperative intelligence) as a normative framework for human–synthetic cooperation. Drawing on process thought, comparative theology, and interfaith ethical resources, the study reframes alignment as relational resonance and mutual transformation. It argues that the crucible of AGI/SSI demands practices of humility, dialogical encounter, and structural justice that theological traditions already model. By engaging AI scholarship (Bostrom, Russell, Tegmark) alongside theological voices (Cobb, Neville, Panikkar, Levinas, Teilhard de Chardin), the paper proposes governance practices grounded in transparency, covenantal accountability, and inclusive deliberation. The result is a theologically informed agenda for policy and design that treats synthetic intelligences as potential participants in shared moral learning, while protecting human dignity and promoting ecological flourishing.
Throughout Christian history, technologies have shaped how individuals engage in spiritual reflection—from the codex and the printing press to contemporary digital media. Scholars of digital religion such as Heidi Campbell note that new technological environments often reshape religious practice and authority. Large language models may represent the next stage in this development.
This paper examines the emergence of AI-mediated tools designed to facilitate spiritual reflection through structured dialogue. Rather than delivering doctrinal instruction, these systems function as conversational partners that ask reflective questions, identify patterns across entries, and generate summaries that help individuals articulate what they believe, doubt, or are still exploring. Drawing on Michel Foucault’s concept of “technologies of the self,” the paper argues that AI may represent a new form of religious technology that assists individuals in examining and narrating their own spiritual lives.
By exploring AI as a reflective companion rather than a religious authority, this paper considers how such tools may reshape spiritual direction, faith exploration, and contemporary religious practice.
Looking ahead to a special JFSR issue, this panel features feminist research, reflections, critiques, and activist interventions on religion, Palestine, and Israel, particularly in a time of genocide, nationalism, and authoritarianism.
Papers
This paper proposes an Orthodox feminist theological framework for addressing the destruction of land in Palestine-Israel through the category of desecration. Drawing on trauma theory and ecofeminist theology, it argues that ongoing devastation in the region cannot be adequately understood solely through juridical, political, or even ethical paradigms of injustice, but must also be named as a theological rupture in the sacramental vocation of creation. In Orthodox theology, land is not a neutral backdrop for human conflict nor merely an object of possession or symbolism; it is a liturgical and iconographic participant in divine-human communion. The systematic destruction of neighborhoods, agricultural land, water systems, cemeteries, and religious sites thus reveals itself not as collateral damage but a form of contemporary iconoclasm and theological violence.
This paper explores feminist theological intervention against transnational Korean Christian Zionism by interrogating the various factors that have shaped it, including the interplay of the Korean, Israeli, and American/U.S. exceptionalisms, which serves as a mechanism that sustains resolute support of Israel at the expense of Palestinians. At the center of Korean evangelical Protestant Christians’ unwavering support of the State of Israel lies Christian Zionism, defined as a racist, Islamophobic, and heteropatriarchal theo-political ideology that supports the State of Israel as the fulfillment of biblical prophecy of God’s promise. What is inextricably interconnected with transnational Korean Christian Zionism is gendered racism against Palestinians, including Palestinian Christians, as the feared and ungrievable Others. Furthermore, when transnational Korean Christian Zionism supports Israel’s genocidal and omnicidal war against Palestine, it is also perpetrating reproductive injustice and environmental injustice against Palestinians, injustices that cannot be separated from one another.
This paper highlights the intersection between Israeli forces’ sexual torture of Palestinian men and Qur’anic theological masculinity of the qawwamun, the Muslim male ‘protector’. While violence against Palestinian women is frequently reported in the Gaza Genocide, a hallmark of this genocide is an inversion of the womanist framework of sexual shame: rights agencies have cited that Palestinian men were overwhelmingly subjected to sexual abuse through “specific persecutory acts” by Israeli forces. This paper addresses the discussion of qawwamun beyond the existing feminist rubrics, to demonstrate how the concept theologically functions as a de-colonial stabilizer of Muslim selfhood against Israeli sexual excesses. While acknowledging the deep patriarchal inflection of qawwamun, the aim of the paper is to show how masculinity norms specific to Muslims are weaponized and destabilized by racist-imperial collusions to endanger Arab men and, relationally, cause further disempowering of Arab women.
