In-person November Annual Meeting 2025 Program Book

All time are listed in Eastern Time Zone.

Please note that this schedule is subject to change and is currently being updated. Please excuse our appearance as we finalize the schedule. If you have any questions, please contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org.
Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Marriott Copley Place, Vineyard (Fourth… Session ID: A22-304
Papers Session

This analysis explores the intersection of Kendrick Lamar's artistry, cultural critique, and changing religious perspectives through key events like his Super Bowl Halftime Show and the album Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers. By juxtaposing his performance with conventional understandings of identity and power structures, Lamar challenges the hypermasculinity and phallogocentrism inherent in hip hop, advocating instead for a rhythmic epistemology that prioritizes collective resonance and inclusivity. His shift from traditional Christian notions of salvation to Eckhart Tolle's concepts of healing and the Ego reflects a broader dissatisfaction with existing religious frameworks for addressing generational trauma. Additionally, the examination of his rap beef with Drake underscores issues of racial authenticity and identity, while highlighting the importance of critical mixed-race ethics that account for multiracial experiences. This multifaceted exploration affirms hip hop's role in shaping narratives around race, identity, and liberation in contemporary society.

Papers

Kendrick Lamar’s 2025 Super Bowl halftime performance subverted expectations, transforming hip-hop’s tradition of signifyin’ into an interactive video game. Through this performance, Lamar illuminated hip-hop’s negotiation with phallogocentrism—the privileging of masculine-coded lyrical dominance—and its transition toward pulscentrism, an emergent framework emphasizing rhythm, movement, and collective resonance over rigid textual authority. Drawing from Charles H. Long’s Significations, critical theory, and liberation theology, this paper examines how artists like Kendrick Lamar, Doechii, Megan Thee Stallion, and J Dilla disrupt logocentrism by privileging polyrhythmic structures, kinetic orality, and embodied knowledge. Furthermore, the rise of rhythm-driven genres like Afrobeats, reggaeton, and drill reflects hip-hop’s epistemic shift beyond masculinist lyrical consumption toward a more inclusive and transnational sonic framework. By theorizing a rhythmic hermeneutic of freedom, this paper argues that pulscentrism challenges colonialist knowledge structures, offering new articulations of identity, power, and resistance through hip-hop’s evolving soundscape.

This presentation analyzes Kendrick Lamar's spiritual transformation between DAMN. and Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers, arguing that Lamar's incorporation of Eckhart Tolle's philosophy signals a conclusive dissatisfaction with the resources Christian theology offered him to deal with generational trauma.  The resulting shift away from concepts like sin, salvation, and final judgment, and new prioritization of healing and freedom through Ego-attentiveness and present-moment awareness offers a stark, yet valuable challenge to Christian theology. 

 

Attending to and analyzing Lamar's work in Mr. Morale (2022) and following--including the Drake feud and his Super Bowl LIX performance--aims to provoke reflective and cooperative conversation around Lamar's evolving spiritual perspective, its implications for theological discourse, and the resources American Christianity (and others) might offer (or fail to offer) in dealing with generational legacies of spiritual deformation, violence, neglect, and/or abuse. 

This paper examines the recent rap beef involving Kendrick Lamar and Drake as a case study that highlights the need for the development of critical mixed-race ethics within religious studies. This viral rap beef captivated North American pop culture, not just for the stinging lyrics and West Coast beats, but also because of the ways it unveiled dynamics of power, race, and identity in hip hop. The paper argues that such dynamics within hip hop reflect the presence of the same dynamics in broader North American culture. By analyzing the artists' lyrics, public personas, and the reception history surrounding their feud alongside scholarly writings on multiracial identity, this paper unveils how each artist’s involvement in the beef reflects or disrupts prevailing narratives about race, authenticity, and belonging in hip hop and beyond.

Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Marriott Copley Place, Dartmouth (Third… Session ID: A22-318
Roundtable Session

This panel features scholarly engagement with Munther Isaac’s theological reflections on the role of Christian discourse in shaping responses to the crisis in Gaza. Writing as a Palestinian pastor and theologian, Isaac challenges dominant Western Christian narratives that, he argues, have long sustained a colonial project marked by displacement and discrimination since the nineteenth century. Through close readings of biblical texts and historical analysis, Isaac calls for a critical reassessment of the ways Christian theology can either obscure or illuminate structures of violence and inequality. Panelists will consider the broader implications of Isaac’s work for contemporary theological ethics and the politics of solidarity within Christian thought.

Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Sheraton, Tremont (Third Floor) Session ID: A22-301
Papers Session

This panel utilizes ethnography to center the voices of caste-oppressed Buddhists in India, Western Odisha, Bangladesh, and Pakistan. The first two panelists focus the relationship caste plays in Buddhism(s) transmitted through oral cultures in India. Panelist 1 examines the forms, cultural practices, and meanings of Buddhist songs for Dalit-Bahujan communities, showing how sonic culture reflects anti-caste cultural practices. Panelist 2 explores the role of myths, legends, and folktales within the Gandha community of Odisha for reconstructing anti-caste histories. The next two papers move outside of India to consider the role of caste and ethnoreligious identity within Muslim majority regions. Panelist 3 examines the impact of Bengali Muslim migration in the Chittagong Hill Tracts, Bangladesh, on indigenous Buddhist social structures. Panelist 4 traces the Buddhist lifeworld created by caste marginalized Buddhists in Pakistan.

Papers

Tathagata Buddha songs refer to a set of singing practices, hymns, and other musical performative dimensions that is particularly dedicated to Buddha, his preaching, and the sense of emancipation that the emergence of Buddhism is rooted in. This paper aims to explore what constitutes Buddhist sonic, particularly for communities who have perceived Buddhism as a way of revival of cultural identity. Through ethnographies of anti-caste singers, the paper aims to engage with the forms, cultural practices, and meanings of Buddhist songs for Dalit-Bahujan communities. While acceptance to Buddhism, since Ambedkar’s conversion in 1956, has been a significant moment for oppressed caste cultural revival, the paper will specifically engage with the ways in which sonic culture is significant and how it reflects anti-caste cultural practices.

Keywords: Music, Buddhism, anti-caste movement, cultural practices, emancipation.

This paper explores the historicization of myths, legends, and folktales within the Ganda community of Kurul and Malgodampada, Balangir, Odisha. Challenging the dominant historiographical exclusion of caste-oppressed communities, it examines how myths are not merely remnants of the past but serve as mediums for reconstructing history. Drawing from Ambedkar’s call for imagination in exhuming history, Vico’s insights on myth as social history, Russell’s synthesis of logic and mysticism, Carr and White’s criticism of dominant forms of historiography, this study interrogates how myths undergo logical scrutiny within communities to be articulated as ‘probable pasts.’ Through ethnographic data and semiotic analysis, it engages in Asad’s view on power’s role in defining ‘true speech.’ By tracing the discourses and practices around Bhima Buddha, Saat Bahin, and Bastarain Mata, among others, across Buddhist Tantric and Hindu narratives, the paper highlights myth’s role in anti-caste cultural praxis, reclaiming lost histories beyond narratives of mere ‘loss.’

This study explores how Bengali migration, primarily of Muslim settlers, has transformed indigenous Buddhist social structures in the Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT), Bangladesh. The demographic shift has intensified ethnic and religious tensions, affecting indigenous Buddhist communities such as the Chakma, Marma, and Tanchangya. This research examines how migration, religion, and caste-like hierarchies intersect, reshaping social relations and indigenous identity. While Buddhism in the CHT traditionally emphasizes inclusivity, local communities report that Bengali dominance has led to economic marginalization, land dispossession, and socio-political exclusion, reinforcing caste-like divisions. Using ethnographic interviews and historical analysis, this study highlights indigenous perspectives on religious coexistence, resistance, and adaptation in response to settler expansion. Findings suggest that migration has not only threatened indigenous autonomy but also altered Buddhist monastic and social structures, influencing perceptions of caste, identity, and intergroup relations. This research contributes to discourses on migration, religious pluralism, and indigenous resistance in South Asia.  

Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Marriott Copley Place, Berkeley (Third… Session ID: A22-302
Papers Session

If you have an interest in church-state relations, empire, protest, and regimes of control, you’ve found the right session! We welcome your curiosity and your questions as three panelists and a respondent discuss carceral reform institutions run by women religious in the 19th century U.S. West, churchstate violence in the colonial Philippines, and theologies of protest in recent anti-authoritarian uprisings in South Korea. 

Papers

Homes of the Good Shepherd, run by the Catholic Sisters of Our Lady of Charity of the Good Shepherd, reformed and incarcerated ‘fallen’ women and girls in the U.S. as early as 1843, making it the first institution in the nation to exclusive incarcerate women and girls. The Good Shepherds in the Western United States operated in collaboration with the state to incarcerate wayward girls before structures existed at the state level, showing an uncharacteristic willingness by western states to rely on Catholic institutions for state-building. This paper frames the construction of girls’ carceral institutions in the West as arising from the precarious collaboration of the Catholic church and of state governments, while placing the Sisters of the Good Shepherd within the larger context of the federal government’s reliance on Catholic sisters to run boarding schools for Native children. 

Against the background of the unsuccessful “emergency” military decree  by South Korean President Yoon, Suk Yeol December 3, 2024 this paper explores how popular culture social protests by college-age Koreans has developed from the 1980’s anti-authoritarian demonstrations against martial law dictatorships. The 2024-2025 protests saw newer formats of collective resistance and response using many of the dynamics popularized by the “soft power” associated with the Hallyu (“Korean cultural wave of K-Pop and K-Drama K-Pop and K-Drama). This presentation begins with a brief summary of the backgrounds of the Korean political protests in the 1980’s and in 2024-2025 . Next each genre type of protest demonstrations is outlined, highlighting both common elements, and performative differences, while lifting up key common denominators such as is the strong sense of collectivity found in both genres of protests. The paper concludes with a theological interpretation in line with the Convention theme of Freedom.

In late October 1841 some 500 members of a pious association of lay Catholics were killed in battle by Spanish forces in the colonial Philippines. When surviving members of the group were questioned as to the purpose of their uprising, they responded, “To pray.” This paper attempts to unpack this statement by placing the Cofradía in the broader history of the Church's response to expressions of popular piety. Under what circumstances are the devotional practices of the laity tolerated by or incorporated into the Church, and under what conditions are they suppressed? Why was the Cofradía's membership determined to pray, up to the point of violent confrontation and death, and what made this desire so threatening to Spanish authorities that the group had to be met with violence? What can this case tell us about the modern relationship between Church and State, or religion and politics?

Respondent

Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Hynes Convention Center, 103 (Plaza… Session ID: A22-311
Papers Session

This session brings together theoretical, ethnographic, community, and clinical chaplaincy innovations at the liberatory frontiers to professionally impact spaces of unfreedom and suffering. Examples of effective advocacy and transformation come from value-based community organizing to turn private grief into public witness confronting systemic injustice in workplace and movement chaplaincy; ways in which Asian and migrant communities' ethnicity, belief systems, and cultural understandings of healing, including in narratives of ancestors and ghosts, highlight tensions between Western models of care and non-Western spiritual traditions particularly related to trauma, displacement, and racialized structural exclusions informing clinical hospital encounters; advocacy in end-of-life spiritual care with patients who have severe mental health challenges sheds light on the limitations of standard models of care and possible alternatives; and a case study from European university chaplaincy of how to transform chaplaincy from a siloed, minoritized profession serving minority religious populations to a multifaith, whole-organization change agent.

Papers

In recent years, chaplains have wrestled with the perceived limits of their own profession in addressing systemic injustice and suffering. While spiritual care and accompaniment have been martialed by pastoral theologians and chaplains to confront personal suffering, these practices have begun to wander into zones of political contestation. In critically reviewing two models of chaplaincy operating in such zones, workplace and movement chaplaincy, I argue that the former illustrates the potential pacifying dimensions of spiritual care per se and the former exemplifies the limits of pastoral accompaniment. To effectively meet spaces of unfreedom, chaplaincy must deepen its identity within the intersections of other fields and discourses, specifically value-based community organizing. By deploying Dorthee Sölle’s work on suffering, this essay hopes to weaponize chaplaincy’s capacity to “allow suffering to speak” for the purposes of organizing for real power, turning private grief into an effective public witness.

This study explores how the Christian-rooted framework of chaplaincy shapes spiritual care in American hospitals and its challenges in meeting the diverse needs of Asian and migrant communities. It examines how ethnicity, belief systems, and cultural understandings of healing inform experiences of life and death, highlighting tensions between Western care models and non-Western spiritual traditions. Migration histories, ancestral ties, and ghost narratives shape how patients experience fear and grief, aspects that conventional psychological treatments often overlook. By examining hauntings, this research positions hospitals as liminal spaces where ghosts materialize—representing unresolved trauma, displacement, and structural exclusion that continue to influence clinical encounters. Additionally, it examines interracial and interreligious encounters in clinical settings, highlighting how different racial and ethnic groups navigate shared spaces of healing. Through ethnographic fieldwork, this study advocates for structurally competent, culturally responsive models of spiritual care beyond dominant biomedical and Christian paradigms.

This paper explores the challenges of end-of-life spiritual care with patients who have severe mental health challenges. I argue that chaplains can play an important role as an advocate for these patients. I also argue that chaplains can approach their work with greater skill and care when they are aware of a patient's medical diagnosis, and can advocate with the medical team for the continued possibility of sustaining religious experience even amid severe mental illness. In addition, I explore how mental health challenges make it complicated if not impossible to adapt some standard models of end-of-life care, but that ways of caring for patients with mental health challenges can be found. 

In Europe, a University chaplaincy is typically perceived as a solitary wizened tree in a desolate landscape providing meagre shelter for a few ‘adherents’. Such centres risk becoming ‘repositories of religion’ (Dinham, 2016), for a minority group at an otherwise secular institution, whether providing higher education, healthcare, penal or other services. Isolated chaplaincy professionals, themselves minoritised, serve people also institutionally minoritised.

This paper analyses the opposite perspective. 

Our work moved a multifaith chaplaincy from a religious repository, into an embedded whole-organisation change-agent. Our experience shows how a chaplaincy can be re-interpreted as a much-needed rhizome (Deleuze/Guattari: 1980) that produces and replicates caring resources on religion/belief to the organisation. 

What could be learned from these insights, in terms of innovations in liberatory edges, professional frontiers and, above all, perspectives? What is gained—and what challenges arise—when chaplaincies offer a fresh understanding of their role and practise listening, researching and responding? 

Business Meeting
Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Marriott Copley Place, Vermont (Fifth… Session ID: A22-330
Papers Session

This panel explores the dynamic interplay between empire and sacred worlding within Sikh practice. By examining historical and contemporary contexts, we aim to uncover how Sikh communities have navigated and resisted imperial forces while simultaneously cultivating sacred spaces and identities. Through interdisciplinary approaches, panelists will discuss the ways in which Sikh practices challenge hegemonic structures and foster resilience, spirituality, and community cohesion. This dialogue will provide insights into the transformative potential of sacred worlding in confronting and reimagining empire.

Papers

This paper presents the first critical edition of Guru Gobind Singh's Ẓafarnāma (1705), a powerful critique of Mughal imperial authority that articulates the Sikh doctrine of Double Sovereignty (mīrī-pīrī). Based on my forthcoming monograph, The Zafarnama of Guru Gobind Singh: A Critical Edition, Translation, and Commentary with a preface by Wheeler Thackston, this work examines thirty-eight manuscripts to correct pervasive textual distortions in modern printed editions. Nearly a third of all verses in current editions contain serious defects including broken meters and missing rhyme patterns. By returning to near-contemporaneous Gurmukhī manuscripts, this research recovers the Guru's bold assertion of sovereignty and transforms apparent praise for Emperor Aurangzeb into a coherent critique of imperial authority. The phonetic nature of Gurmukhī script additionally preserves historical Mughal Persian pronunciation. This critical edition establishes new foundations for understanding how religious authority confronts imperial power through extensive manuscript documentation, grammatical analysis, and historical contextualization.

This paper presents a creative and interdisciplinary approach to teaching Gurbānī Sangīt (the music of Sikh scriptural hymns) at a North American college as part of efforts to decolonize Liberal Arts education. Grounded in the decolonial notion of ‘listening as a way of knowing’ (Feld 2024; Becker 2004), the courses emphasize practical engagement with the pluriversal vision enshrined in the songs transmitted in Sikh Scripture and Gurbānī oral literature, as an ecology of knowledges (Santos 2014) inclusive of Bhakti and Sufi voices. This experiential approach provides an avenue to reflect on the role that kīrtan, or the singing of devotional poetry, had - and still has - in transmitting spiritual knowledges from the Global South. Additionally, by reviving the pre-colonial pedagogy, Gurbānī Sangīt classes create opportunities to explore Sikh history, philosophy, and practices while learning firsthand the rāga and tāla system, along with traditional instruments to perform kīrtan’s heritage compositions.

Studies of Sikh diasporic religious politics and identity are often framed by territorial assumptions centred on Punjab. This paper examines how everyday spiritual values, aesthetics, and practices shape contested articulations of sacred space across the UK, South Asia, and East Africa. Advancing the concept of sacred worlding as a political ontology, it explores how religious practice, politics, and history intertwine within poetic, craft, and musical expressions of Sikh heritage.

Our findings reveal that diasporic support for creative heritage takes contested material and embodied forms, shaped by intersections of caste, gender, and generation. These tensions reflect and produce divergent territorialised and deterritorialised concepts of Sikh sacred space. We argue that sacred worlding offers a framework for understanding the plural, symbolic, and sensory production of religious projects. It deepens empirical analysis of creative religious expressions, contextualises diasporic settlement journeys, and reframes the geographies of diasporic religious politics across interconnected scales and sites.

Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Sheraton, Berkeley (Third Floor) Session ID: A22-305
Roundtable Session

This roundtable brings together scholars of early Chinese religion, Daoist studies, and contemplative studies to explore new directions in their fields through the lens of Harold D. Roth’s influential work. Roth’s research has significantly impacted how scholars understand early Chinese texts and practices, emphasizing the central role of contemplative practice and challenging long-held assumptions about the context of textual production in early China. His contributions also extend to the study of classical Chinese thought more broadly, cross-cultural religious ethics, and the emerging field of contemplative studies. Panelists will reflect on Roth’s legacy, engage critically with his methods, and discuss how his work informs new research across religious studies, history, philosophy, contemplative studies, and more. Featuring diverse disciplinary perspectives, this session highlights the continued relevance of Roth’s scholarship while raising new questions for future inquiry.

Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Sheraton, Berkeley (Third Floor) Session ID: A22-305
Roundtable Session

This roundtable brings together scholars of early Chinese religion, Daoist studies, and contemplative studies to explore new directions in their fields through the lens of Harold D. Roth’s influential work. Roth’s research has significantly impacted how scholars understand early Chinese texts and practices, emphasizing the central role of contemplative practice and challenging long-held assumptions about the context of textual production in early China. His contributions also extend to the study of classical Chinese thought more broadly, cross-cultural religious ethics, and the emerging field of contemplative studies. Panelists will reflect on Roth’s legacy, engage critically with his methods, and discuss how his work informs new research across religious studies, history, philosophy, contemplative studies, and more. Featuring diverse disciplinary perspectives, this session highlights the continued relevance of Roth’s scholarship while raising new questions for future inquiry.

Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Sheraton, Liberty C (Second Floor) Session ID: A22-316
Papers Session

.

Papers

In this paper, I examine how Latinx Queer theologies reimagine ethics as affective and temporal resistance to the geographic inequalities sustained by colonial Christian traditions. Drawing from Marcella Althaus-Reid, Mayra Rivera, Hugo Córdova Quero, Anderson Fabián Santos Meza, and Enrique Vega-Dávila, I explore how affect and temporality shape Christian responses to ecological and political violence amid the global resurgence of fascism as a modern colonial inheritance. Through an analysis of these thinkers’ critiques of power and embodiment in Latin America and the United States, I argue that extending their insights to contemporary fascism reveals and unsettles the uneven geographies of belonging caused and upheld by the Trump administration and their consequences for Latinx Queer Christian communities. In this way, I attempt to contribute to scholarly-activist discourse of reimagining eschatological and soteriological interventions that assert collective, intersectional notions of livability against colonial Christian traditions.

Throughout this paper, I explore the moral imperative and spiritual obligation of reproductive justice seekers and Denver organizers to advocate and organize for migrants in the wake of Donald Trump’s reelection and promise to enact the largest deportation this country has ever seen. As a Latine social ethicist, I engage liberative, faith-aware ethical frameworks drawn from the tenets of Latin American social ethics: lo cotidianoel acompañamiento, and doing ethics en conjunto. I argue that because of our culturally Catholic upbringing and lived experiences as migrants or children of immigrants ourselves, organizers like me hold epistemological privileges in advocating for these communities at the legislative level. We are the trusted messengers. 

Maize, a sacred gift from the god Quetzalcoatl, has been at the heart of Mesoamerican civilizations for millennia, shaping not only diets but also societal structures, rituals, and cultural identity. I explore how maize continues to be a powerful symbol of resistance in contemporary Mexico, particularly through its role in the fight against globalization and genetic modification. Likewise, I highlight Mexico's recent ban on genetically modified (GMO) corn as a pivotal moment for food sovereignty, indigenous rights, and environmental justice. By analyzing both historical and contemporary cultivation practices, along with the photographic work of David Lauer, which documents the resilience of indigenous maize cultures, I demonstrate how maize serves as both a living cultural artifact and a political tool of resistance in the face of global challenges like climate change and corporate agricultural control. Building upon the concept of México Profundo by Guillermo Bonfil Batalla, I argue that maize is not only central to Mexico's physical sustenance but also to the soul of its indigenous communities, offering pathways to biodiversity conservation and cultural preservation. My overall research examines how cultural values shape our understanding of the world and challenges us to reconsider what truly sustains us.

Brazil’s increase in ecological catastrophes is directly associated with the permanence of ancestral colonization dispositifs in governing territories and populations—especially among the poorest, most peripheral, and racialized. From the perspective of the Yanomami shaman Davi Kopenawa, the Falling of the Brazilian Sky—our climate apocalypse—has its cosmopolitical origins in the colonial invasion of Amerindian territories by the “napë” [white men] and the extractive violence of the “people of the commodity.” Based on the ethnographic description of what would come to be considered one of the greatest environmental crime-disasters in the modern history of mining industries in the world, the collapse of the iron ore tailings mine in the city of Mariana (Minas Gerais, Brazil), I aim to create a critique dialogue between Process Philosophy, Philosophy of Multiplicity, Amerindian cosmologies, and Black Feminist Theory to explore the state of cosmopolitical conflict observed in Brazilian ecological catastrophes

Saturday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM | Hynes Convention Center, 203 (Second… Session ID: A22-300
Papers Session

Emerging technologies continue to raise some of the most important questions in bioethics - around life and death, what it means to be human, and what it means to truly care for other humans. Papers in this session will address various aspects of intersections between biomedical technology and religious perspectives: genetic testing, AI and organoid intelligence, and life-sustaining technologies and risky truth-telling that a patient is going to die. The speakers will present various genealogies, perspectives, and areas of professional practice in their reflections on some of the most pressing bioethical questions.

Papers

By revealing previously unimaginable knowledge about human bodies, genetic testing and data collection hold the potential to fall into a certain pattern of medicine that views patients as objects to control, resulting in an isolating approach to healthcare. This is a particularly harmful problem for already marginalized groups like those living with disabilities and communities of color. Christian anthropology’s understanding of the human person as relational, dependent, and creative illuminates an alternative framework for the purpose and employment of genetic testing. In particular, Alejandro García-Rivera’s imaginary of the garden illuminates a way that genetic technology can be limited according to human frailty and directed towards a flourishing rooted in the interdependent nature of human life. In short, genetic technology should be employed according to a view of human persons as interdependent, fragile, and relational to serve individual and collective flourishing rather than serve as isolating and controlling. 

“Organoid intelligence” (OI) is an emerging field that aims to leverage the processing power of the human brain, which has been shown to match supercomputer processing at a tiny fraction of the energy requirement. OI builds upon recent developments in brain organoids that promise to replicate aspects of learning and memory and possibly aspects of cognition in vitro. Brain organoids are networked together to form a biological computer. This paper argues that the idealization of the human brain as a computer already de-humanizes us. To this end, this paper offers a genealogy of cognitive science and its resultant disappearance of the human in two parts: (1) the spatialization of the mind, and (2) the cybernetic mechanization of the mind as computer. The resulting cognitive science and neuroscience simply assume the mind as a computer and an ersatz incarnation of a dataist metaphysics.