You are here

Online Program Book

This is the most up-to-date schedule for the 2023 AAR Annual Meeting. If you have questions about the program, contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org. All times are listed in Central Standard Time.

In this session, the Chinese Christianities Unit features papers that push the historiographical boundaries of our field. While rooted in examinations of historic missionary work and local inculturation, the papers in this session explore how the competition of Chinese national ideologies, often regarded in studies of China and Sinophone worlds as secular, can be genealogically and historically traced back to various Christian threads. In this way, the study of Chinese Christian histories can be seen to contribute to the examination of national ideologies in China and beyond. Topics that the papers in this session explore include Chinese communist theologies, 'Cold War Christian Chineseness' in the thought of Y.T. Wu, the influence of Margaret Barber on Watchman Nee, and the appropriation of Christian Reconstructionism among urban elite Christians in China.

  • Abstract

    This paper examines the early Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) ideological evolution, highlighting its strategic appropriation and subsequent rejection of Christian elements in the pursuit of national salvation. Building on the framework of Goossaert and Palmer, it interprets the CCP’s inception as a religious endeavor, where Christianity initially served as a model for moral and social reform. Through a detailed analysis of Chen Duxiu and Yun Daiying’s transformations—from viewing Christianity as a valuable source of sacredness to denouncing it in favor of Communism’s promises of social overhaul and enhanced organizational cohesion—the study illustrates the CCP’s shift towards positioning Communism as the ultimate sacred narrative. This exploration into the complex interplay between religious faith and political ideology helps illuminate the forces shaping modern China’s religio-political landscape and the role of sacredness in its nationalist and revolutionary discourses.

  • Abstract

    The term “Sino-Foreign Protestant Establishment,” defined by noted Chinese historian Daniel H. Bays, is central to understanding the evolution of Christianity in early twentieth-century China. Flourishing during the Republican era and unraveling in the mid-20th century with the rise of the Chinese Communist regime, this roughly four-decade-long Establishment underwent a significant shift. This paper explores, by introducing the concept of “Sino-Foreign Protestant Estrangement,” how the religio-political mechanisms catalyzed the shift from Sino-Foreign Protestant collaboration to estrangement. It focuses on Y. T. Wu, a pivotal Protestant leader in post-1949 church-state relations. The study argues that the transition from the Establishment to the Estrangement was orchestrated through three key strategies: ideological reconstruction, institutional rebuilding, and individual decoupling, all aimed at removing foreign influences from the initial Establishment. These tactics culminated in what is termed “Cold War Christian Chineseness,” a new phase of Chinese Christian self-identity shaped by these transformative processes.

  • Abstract

    Margaret Emma Barber (1866–1930), a British female missionary, significantly influenced the spiritual development of Watchman Nee (1903–1972), a prominent leader of churches in China. Despite their significant impact, their mentoring relationship remains understudied in scholarly literature. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the dynamic interaction between Barber and Nee in the 1920s, shedding light on the complex dynamics between Western missionaries and Chinese converts. Drawing on historical documents, personal writings, and contextual analysis, the study will explore Barber’s guidance and Nee’s perception of Barber’s personality and mentorship. The research aims to contribute to a deeper understanding of the cultural and theological exchanges between Western missionaries and indigenous Chinese Christians in twentieth-century China and beyond. The study aims to enrich the narrative of Chinese Christianity by highlighting the significance of mentorship and cultural exchange in shaping its development across geographical and cultural boundaries.

  • Abstract

    The new generations of Chinese urban elite Christians have been searching for an intellectually robust political theology to guide their cultural ambition and their reformist drive. Some of their recent discourse, for example their endorsement of American Christian nationalism, their hostility toward the ordination of women, and their rejection of separation of church and state, calls into question what kind of political theology that had influenced them the most. For some influential and outspoken Chinese Christian leaders of the 21st century, the answer is clear. They adopted Christian Reconstructionism, sometimes also called theonomy, of American fundamentalists such as Rousas Rushdoony and Gary North. This paper traces the historical contingencies through which Christian Reconstruction theology made its way across the globe to China, and came to be favored by many Chinese Christians.

This session brings together five papers exploring 20th and 21st century Chinese religions at the "intersections" where different forms of practice (unofficial and state-sanctioned, religious and non-religious, traditional and modern, for instance) meet.

  • Abstract

    This text discusses the interaction and relationship between a local ritual master and a spirit medium. It includes a case study of a spirit medium named Hu Guanglin, who turned to a local ritual master (fashi 法師) for a solution when he was having trouble maintaining a stable connection with his deceased patriarchs (yinshi 陰師). Master Wu proposed a ritual known as Consecration, Confinement, and Stabilization (kaiguang fengding 開光封定) to stabilize Guanglin’s connection. Master Wu showed his autonomy from Daoism and authority over spirit mediums. However, using Daoist characters and bureaucratic communication methods in their talismans and documents suggests a Daoist influence. The masters of the Mount Mao Divine Arts (maoshan shengong 茅山神功) exhibit their power over low-ranking spirits and spirit mediums, demonstrating a continuation of the “master of gods” phenomenon within Schipper’s hierarchy of gods, ritual masters, and Daoism. 

  • Abstract

    Recent studies suggest that evangelism beyond social networks is more important for spreading religion in China than previously thought. Drawing upon neglected English- and Chinese-language sources and the author’s own interviews, this paper aims to enhance our understanding of how outreach to strangers in China occurs by examining the methods used by Hare Krishnas since 1977. It argues that the proselytization strategies employed by members of unofficial religions, like the Hare Krishnas, often differ significantly from those utilized by practitioners of state-sanctioned ones. While the latter rely on “strategies of attraction”—techniques designed to lure individuals to sacred sites where they can be engaged legally, the former actively seek out potential converts in secular spaces and at sites belonging to other religious institutions. It is difficult to generalize about religion in China as a whole, but comparing official and unofficial religions shows promise for making discussions more manageable and productive.

  • Abstract

    Building the Road to Modernity within Tradition:  The Construction and Consecration of Vajra-bodhi Stupa in Chongqing in 1931

    By focusing on the case of the Vajra-bodhi Stupa constructed in Chongqing in 1931, this research examines how Buddhism navigated its way between tradition and modernity to reconstruct its identity in Republican China (1911-1949). The stupa was built under the patronage and supervision of  Pan Wenhua (1886-1950), a lay Buddhist and the mayor of Chongqing. To modernize the city, Pan ordered the relocation of thousands of tombs in order to build roads and improve transportation in the city. In response to the local residents’ tradition of ancestor worship and fear of dislocated haunting ghosts, the stupa was built. This paper will discuss how Buddhists creatively intergrated traditional views and practices into their conception of modernity in Republican China through the construction and consecration of the stupa.

     

  • Abstract

    This project follows Chinese Buddhists who traveled to Japan studying Esoteric Buddhism from 1910 to the 1930s, returning to China spreading their teachings among monastics and laity. It will start with Gui Bohua’s (桂伯華 1861-1915) turn to Esoteric Buddhism to deal with the death of his family and then consider a series of monks and laypersons who sought ought initiation at the Shingon headquarters of Koyasan 高野山. These Buddhists sought not only to study a lost part of Chinese Buddhism but also to develop a potential alternative to western modernity. They spread Esoteric Buddhism throughout the Chinese Buddhist landscape while simultaneously improving Sino-Japanese relations during the spread of Japanese colonies throughout the Sinosphere. Finally, a case study of Taixu’s 太虚 Wuchang Buddhist Studies Academy *foxueyuan* 武昌佛学院 highlights its lay community’s shift from academic to Esoteric Buddhism.

  • Abstract

    The incorporation of Buddhist temples into urban redevelopment within China’s market transition became phenomenal after the 2000s. Domestic and international real estate developers collaborated with local governments and state-owned-enterprises in the construction of commercial complexes by converting under-used spaces around renowned Buddhist temples. Among these scattered projects of temple-centered redevelopment across China, this article identifies two during which the Hong Kong-based developer, Swire Properties, consecutively built open, low-density shopping centres in Chengdu and Xi’an around the Daci temple and Jianfu temple respectively since 2010. Named as the “Taikoo Li”, these two projects attest to unique logics of planning and operation, while nurturing discursive, cultural, and material practices, religious as well as non-religious, in people’s everyday life. Drawing upon an extensive ethnographic study in urban contemporary China, this article bridges a dialogue with postsecularist debates in Euro-American contexts, and proposes a methodological experiment that reinvents "postsecularity" as plural, contextual, and subjective.

In this roundtable, a group of scholars who have collaboratively compiled a sourcebook of new critical translations of works relating to women in Chinese religions will speak about their forthcoming work, its contribution to the field, and its applications in the university classroom. Tentatively titled Teaching Women in Chinese Religions, the work focuses on women’s life-stages and how religious practices and rituals shaped norms around female identity and bodies. With chapters on roles like daughter, wife, mother and non-mother (nuns and shamans), and life-stages like girlhood, marriage, and widowhood, the book contributes to filling a critical gap in the diversity of teachable texts about women’s religious lives in Chinese history and culture. The panel aims to introduce the themes of this work, give audience members practical approaches to using its contents in the classroom, and create a forum for open discussion of best practices for teaching religion, gender, and literature.

As do humans, Buddhist agents, materials, traditions and practices migrate. Between ethnic groups, crossing borders and travel overseas. This round table engages in a critical investigation of theory and research methods in the study of the migration of Buddhism in relation to contemporary Chinese societies. By coming together and sharing different approaches the panelists in this roundtable will reflect on the richness and complexity of this broad topic. In this session, Buddhism is treated broadly and inclusively, and looking at Chinese societies in their multiplicity.
Unpacking the different facets of this nexus, our session aims to share hands-on methodological tools and relevant theoretical considerations that scholars are facing when doing research in the nexus of migration and Buddhism. The session will therefore focus on research practices, challenges in collecting data, positionality, data and theory triangulation, and other particular demands related to research on communities, institutions, and agents of Buddhism in Chinese areas and overseas Chinese communities. A second aim of this roundtable is to critically question normative definitions of migration and the manner this concept is pertinent in describing the modern migration of Buddhism in Chinese societies.

By coining the term “gendered dilemma,” the panel investigates the situations with the presence of multiple gender norms, leading to inconsistencies and contradictions, consequently forging a new set of power/knowledge regimes. The dilemma surrounding sexual constructs, the concept of lust, and visions configures a rich multivocality in response to the tension and reconciliation emerging from the clash between the Buddhist and pre-established socio-cultural gender norms. Three papers in this panel seek to broaden the historical scope, spanning a transformative period of Buddhism from the late second to the eleventh century, presenting an examination of the “gendered dilemma” by textual comparison and analysis of early Chinese Buddhist sūtras with Confucian classical texts, a discourse analysis of gender convertibility in Mahāyāna sūtra narratives, and art historical analysis of female agency in possessing visuality in Northern-Song scriptures.

  • Abstract

    This paper investigates the problem of lust embedded within a few of the earliest renditions of Buddhist scriptures translated from second to third-century China. Earlier Confucian classical texts cemented a discourse that presupposed the male gender’s natural inclination to lust. However, the early translated Buddhist texts in China introduced a new discourse that ascribed bodily lust as the female gender’s natural inclination. It is commonly accepted that the literate elites eventually accepted both discourse sets. However, the initial period when the Buddhist discourse was introduced must have presented a dilemma for the elites to reconcile similar and different gendered notions with the existing discourse. The result was a new discourse that firmly amalgamated both sets of ideals and redefined lust expressed by the male and female genders. The consequences of three different discourses would set a new basis for future literati interpretations of gender relations in medieval China.

  • Abstract

    This study examines performativity within inconsistent narratives surrounding gender and sexuality in early Mahāyāna Buddhist sūtras, particularly exploring the theme of sexual convertibility in Sūtra on Transforming the Female Form, Chapter 6 of Vimalakīrti-nirdeśa-sūtra and Chapter 12 of Saddharma-puṇḍárīka-sūtra. By analyzing the magical displays of the Goddess to Śāriputra regarding body forms, and the transformative sexuality of Taintless Light Girl and dragon girl, juxtaposed with biological categories about sexuality in Brahmajāla-sūtra, the paper argues that sexuality, distinct from gender, plays a role in constructing gender dichotomy and hierarchies; its superimposition with gendered body forms results in inconsistent narratives that persist as gender dilemmas in the sūtras. The study underscores gender/sex convertibility displayed in a performative manner, showing a tendency of reconciliation of contradictions in narratives. This study introduces a novel intra-religious approach to gender issues in Buddhist sūtra literature, providing insights into narrative modes linked with Buddhist doctrines and rhetoric devices.

  • Abstract

    Ten sandalwood-scented Buddhist scrolls were discovered next to the body of Lady Sun (b. 995-1055), a Buddhist practitioner from a scholar-official family. Each scroll features frontispieces, printed or painted with ink and gold, with several bearing Lady Sun's signature. This study examines Lady Sun's visual preferences, her engagement with the materiality of these scrolls, and the sensory experiences she actively pursued within the constraints of medieval visual culture and gender norms. At a time when print culture was burgeoning, but dominated by literate male elites, Lady Sun's collection stands out. Not only did she own and sign printed scrolls that stylistic tracing to imperial printing projects of Buddhist canon, but she also commissioned hand-painted identical copies for printed sūtra with altered visual programs, thus personalizing her devotional practice and negotiating her religious and social identity with established patriarchal visual structures that restricted women's access to visual and religious autonomy.

     

Bodies and technologies of reproduction

This roundtable brings together scholars working on a wide range of materials, cultures and periods to discuss the body and technologies of reproduction. The reproductive body is the site and technology of much religious and spiritual practice in East and South Asia. Narratives of embryology—whether physiological and saṃsāric or spiritual and transcendent—inform such practices. Bodily practices are often understood in relation to reproduction and may directly impact procreation. This roundtable focuses on how the reproductive body informs religious practice and narratives of bodily procreation. The roundtable features contributions on the placenta as the source of mortality in Shangqing Daoism, embryogenesis narratives in Epic and Purāṇic literature, the Daoist body as a self-contained site of asexual reproduction, the Indian alchemical *Rasaratnākara* on embryo development and procreation, spiritual embryology in haṭha yoga, embryology and cosmology in Chinese female alchemy, and childlessness and ontogenesis in Bengali (Baul) songs of *sādhanā*.

Given that a core foundation for Christian spirituality and spirituality in general is the human capacity for self-consciousness and the concept of slow knowing (lectio / visio divina) and given that designers of artificial intelligence are working towards greater capacity for “AI self-awareness” and speed in knowing, what do we conceive as the future interaction between AI and Spirituality? AI’s potential contribution to spirituality, morality, contemplative practices, and prayer are engaged in this session.

  • Abstract

    If Artificial Intelligence (AI) can enhance human morality, could AI also enhance spirituality? In considering the relationship between AI and spirituality, this paper examines the potential benefits and risks of moral enhancement through AI and relates some of these arguments to Hugh of St. Victor’s notion of the ark of wisdom. I argue that while AI can indeed assist morality, a key aspect of spirituality, there are other key facets in the cultivation of morality such as the practice of memorization and the internalization of reading that belongs exclusively to the human agent. If Hugh’s spirituality as depicted in the ark of wisdom is sound, then it follows that while AI can enhance spirituality, it only does so to a limited degree. While AI and spirituality should remain partners, they must remain partners by delineating key practices of spirituality.

  • Abstract

    A famous poem by R. S. Thomas, “The Empty Church,” one of the poems that widely associates him with Holy Saturday, describes an existential search for God in a post-religious age. But today, the poem also captures something telling about spiritual life in our era of artificial intelligence—indeed, perhaps the spiritual life of artificial intelligence itself. This is because, in addition to its existential theme, the poem takes the form of a broken sonnet. The sonnet form evokes completion, closure, harmony, though in “The Empty Church” its fracture instead registers as noise, mimicry, simulation. The poem thus functions as an allegory of artificial intelligence, mimicking the quest for God in a search for the poet who might complete or repair its busted form. Thomas’s poem helps us understand the emergence of AI as a neural network with its own pathologies, its spiritual life a weakened version of our own.

  • Abstract

    Christian spirituality is inherently relational. As a discipline, Christian spirituality is devoted to the study and practice of being in relationship with God, oneself, others, and all of creation. The development of artificial intelligence and the anticipation of future, more advanced, artificial intelligences, raises questions about the practice and scope of Christian spirituality. This paper explores cautionary and constructive possibilities for partnerships between human beings and artificial intelligence. For example. how can the development of potential artificial consciousness expand the understanding of not only how, but who or what, may practice contemplative Christian spirituality? This appraisal draws upon several ideas and sources, including the 14th century mystic, Richard Rolle, Walter Wink’s social theology, Michael Burdett’s theology of technology, and the practice of contemplative prayer.

  • Abstract

    Images created by generative AI have raised controversy in the art world, where critics question the ability of AI to be creative since generative programs base their output on that of previous artists.  The formulaic nature of icon painting would seem to make it ideally suited to generative AI.  Nor would the virtual world preclude the veneration of icons.  Yet most Orthodox theologians remain suspicious of digital technology.  Theologically, AI generation raises fears of a new Docetism that separates spirit and matter.  A second concern is rooted in the role of both icon and iconographer within the temporal community and the community of saints.  Through prayer and contemplation, an icon establishes a relational triad linking iconographer, saint, and viewer.  AI severs the relationship between iconographer and saint and has the potential to mislead viewers, since it is embedded in neither the community of the faithful nor of the saints. 

This session examines the interplay between Christian spirituality, ecological discourse, and the contemplative facets inherent within religious belief and practice. Drawing upon a diverse array of theological paradigms, these papers center on deliberative engagements concerning the urgent need of creation stewardship and the call for Christians to assume custodial roles in the preservation of the Earth as an adjunct to spiritual praxis. Also considered is the emotive resonance elicited by instances of environmental degradation, fostering discourse on the ethical mandate for compassionate responses and proactive engagement with the vulnerability of our ecological home.

  • Abstract

    Aiming at developing Pope Francis’s call to attend to the gaze of Jesus (Laudato Si’ 96-100) this paper offers a reflection on St. Ignatius Loyola’s “Contemplation on the Incarnation” from the Spiritual Exercises alongside poet Warsan Shire’s “What They Did Yesterday Afternoon” to explore the possibility of acquiring a “green gaze” for the earth as the broken body of God. Such an approach acquires the (possible) gaze of Jesus, but shifts attention away from Francis’s emphasis on praise and wonder at creation, and towards the need to respond to brokenness and suffering. Taking a cue from Shire, this paper argues that Francis’s ecological vision can be strengthened by stronger attention to theologies of liberation which in their own way echo Shire’s poetic question “Where does it hurt?,” and likewise facilitate an experience of the world’s response: “Everywhere, everywhere, everywhere.”

  • Abstract

    Christian theology has traditionally spoken of creation as a book, a means of revelation that can be metaphorically read by human creatures for a variety of purposes. The thirteenth century theologian Bonaventure takes up this tradition, giving the Book of Nature a significant place in his theology. This paper considers Bonaventure’s theology of the Book of Nature in conversation with the concept of the hospitable text, articulated by Rowan Williams. Read in this way and along with Bonaventure, creation becomes a text that invites the reader to pray, both in contemplation and in petition. This paper argues that creation’s invitation to petitionary prayer calls on human creatures to fulfill their priestly role in relationship to creation, even as it grounds humanity in humility. Human creatures are invited to plead with God for creation as it groans under the curse, to recognise their complicity in the cause of its groaning, and to seek creation’s redemption. This paper concludes by considering Bonaventure’s exemplar of St. Francis as one whose response to creation’s invitation demonstrated a life of prayer that integrated contemplation and action.

  • Abstract

    Pope Francis’s 2015 encyclical *Laudato Si’* reignited theological attention to conversations in *deep incarnation,* ecotheology, and Franciscan spirituality. In the face of the environmental crisis, calls for ascetic renunciation and divestment imply that solutions to the crisis reside in spiritualities of self-discipline and mastery. Yet, *Laudato Si’*s account of St. Francis of Assisi’s spirituality of asceticism suggests that the logic of self-mastery is tied to the mastery of others insofar as both involve displacing or diminishment. My paper contrasts an asceticism of mastery and necrophilia with an asceticism of kinship and joy in order to illuminate how St. Francis’s cosmic spirituality is oriented toward communal and ecological wholeness. Francis’s asceticism of kinship culminates in joyful healing and praise. In order to offer an account of St. Francis’s asceticism of kinship I explore *touch*points between *Laudato Si’*, Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s phenomenology of sight and “flesh,” and Bonaventure’s cosmic Christology.

  • Abstract

    Our ongoing ecological crisis is rooted in global economic arrangements that use quantitative measures of value as the sole determinants of a good life. Paradoxically, these measures are both anthropocentric and, in their carelessness of our animal happiness, antithetical to the flourishing of human beings. Modern Christianity’s familiar dualism of soul and body, spirit and matter, inhibit its power to disrupt this engine of alienation from our creatureliness. In this paper I argue that where this conceptuality fails, Christian spiritual disciplines can nonetheless succeed in offering radical forms of resistance. I draw from Br. Paul Quenon’s memoir, In Praise of the Useless Life, to explore the material consequences of joyful liberation from reductive measures of utility. To reject utility is to discover the harmony between our animal happiness and our participation in “the cosmic dance,” while exposing and deactivating the ecocidal lie of “a good life” under contemporary economism.

Diversity in Christian spirituality has been the norm since the ancient development of its practices, traditions, and prayer forms. Regretfully individuals and communities – living with or in the shadows of disability – historically have not been included in this diversity and even at times have been willfully rejected from it. This session aims to critically analyze from multiple perspectives the positive contributions of how persons living with disabilities have provided a deeper understanding of, and contributed to, the dynamics of spiritual and human growth.

  • Abstract

    This paper delves into the distinct spiritual expressions of autistic individuals by examining the life and writings of Julian of Norwich. I consider three elements of Julian’s spiritual life that correspond to key features of autism. Although it is speculative to interpret historical figures through contemporary concepts like autism, Julian as a model illuminates the importance of recognizing diverse ways of experiencing Christian spirituality. Such an exploration is necessary to broaden understandings of autism in theological discourse. First, I examine her life as an anchorite as a divergent social path that nonetheless allowed her to be in community on her own terms. Second, I explore the intensity of her focus as exhibited by her writing. Last, I consider her mystical experience in terms of heightened sensory sensitivity. Reconsidering Julian through the lens of autistic experience provides a fresh perspective on neurodivergent expressions of Christian spirituality.

  • Abstract

    This paper examines the practices of tracing and praying to crip ancestors among key disabled activist-writers. Through analysis of their essays, poetry, and memoirs, I argue that such practices function in part to resist a curative social imaginary that erases disability from our collective histories and futures. I contend that Christian theologians might learn from disabled activist-writers’ embodied attention to the past as a resource to reimagine the future without disability’s erasure. This paper develops a negative theological hermeneutic in which the search for crip ancestors in the archive and in scripture exposes the violence of the past that prevents the recovery of disabled lives. Ultimately, I argue, following Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha, that our stumbling upon and seeking crip ancestors “in the void of not always knowing… what their legacy means” generates desires for liberated futures.

  • Abstract

    This paper reads Julian of Norwich’s 14-15th-century visionary text A Revelation of Love alongside Alison Kafer’s Feminist, Queer, Crip (2013). Kafer’s notion of “crip-time” provides a lens through which to theorize an “else-when” of disability in the medieval past and elucidate the mode of temporality deployed in mystical writing. Julian of Norwich’s A Revelation ––in its deep engagement with illness, impairment, and paralysis––has been read by scholars in religious/disability studies as a devotional and theological model of a disabled person experiencing God. However, considering the role of time in medieval mystical literature through disability studies exposes a complicated––perhaps theologically necessary––ambiguity between the somatic experience of illness and the curative temporality of Christian soteriology, inviting us to question whether the political goals of disability studies can work in tandem with the “crip” and curative temporalities of medieval mystical traditions.

  • Abstract

    Within the theological study of disability, prayer has most often been discussed in the context of creating inclusive liturgy, deconstructing harmful approaches (prayer used to “heal” someone with a disability), offering complimentary therapy to manage pain or promote psychological well-being. Prayer, as an individual spiritual practice by disabled people, remains underexplored within the field of disability theology. Prayer as a way to transcend the physical pain and social isolation that often accompanies disability (due to the social construction of disability). My paper explores the liberative aspects of prayer (transcendence) for disabled people. Drawing on her personal experience of disability, Susan Wendell articulates the need for transcendence from the “rejected body.” Simone Weil expands Wendell’s conception of spiritual transcendence, offering prayer as a mode of spiritual transcendence from affliction. I argue that prayer can lead to spiritual transcendence, which alleviates suffering for disabled people through union with God.

The idea of ‘affordances’ is catching the imagination of a growing number of theologians. First proposed by psychologist James Gibson, the notion highlights how living beings perceive and draw upon their natural or designed environments in terms of what they offer or ‘afford.’ On our panel, theologians discuss how the notion of affordances allows us to rethink our work with texts and traditions, doctrines and communities, spaces and places, people and things. In discussion with one another and the audience, we explore new avenues of thought, pitfalls and potentials.

Panelists will discuss Judith Wolfe's The Theological Imagination: Perception and Interpretation in Life, Art, and Faith (Cambridge University Press, 2024), followed by a response from the author.

.

  • Abstract

    This paper explores the pneumatological-sociological picture of the Holy Spirit that appears in much contemporary theology, in which the Spirit is strongly associated with local communities and social movements, and decidely not with "institutions" (complex formal organizations). This picture is elaborated through reference to several examples and illuminated by a discussion of its socio-political context. The picture fits a neoliberal context in which national and international political economies are protected from democratic contestation. The paper also responds to moral, political, and theological worries about institutions in light of concerns that the neglect of institutions undermines resistance to neoliberalism. Finally, an alternative picture is sketched in which human "ritual play" generates a variety of organizational forms that potentially participate in the Spirit.

  • Abstract

    This paper turns to means the Holy Spirit employs to orient one to Christ’s person-forming work. Drawing out the narrative significance of bodily limits, as depictions of one’s need for God’s help, God’s power to provide, and enjoyment of divine gifts, shows that Protestants, like Luther, Wesley, and Calvin, deployed figurative language and metaphors of disability. These narrative deployments emphasize the Spirit’s use of sensation to stimulate awareness of divine activity. Indeed, analyzing disability’s textual function reveals how *hearing* the Word, the *taste* of faith, and pleasing *visions* construct a sensorial habitus. The Spirit, then, uses this habitus to carry one to the Word, restore relationships, and inspire fellowship. In contrast to criticisms of the Protestant tradition as overly intellectual and disinterested in sensation, the paper concludes to gesture towards a pneumatology that unearths Protestantism’s surprising compatibility with disability justice through its attention to sensation.

  • Abstract

    In *Yves Congar’s Theology of the Holy Spirit*, Elizabeth Groppe argues that Congar’s distinctive contribution to pneumatology lies in his integration of anthropology and ecclesiology. This paper builds upon this insight and uses Congar as a foundation from which to construct an integrated pneumatological theology of preaching. Theological reflection on the activity of the Spirit in preaching continues to lack a robust integration between anthropology and ecclesiology, often focusing on the individual preacher at the expense of the community. What if we instead began with the Spirit-filled community as the starting point for a theology of preaching? A coversation between Congar's pneumatology and the practical field of homiletics, this paper approaches preaching not only as an application of theology but also as a source of theological reflection. I reveal how reflecting more deeply on the Spirit's activity in the community gathered for the preaching event can help advance our pneumatology.

  • Abstract

    In this paper, I propose an approach to a theology of social transformation in dialogue with Irenaeus’ thought, bringing the aesthetic concept of glory—divine and creaturely—into dialogue with theo-political societal transformation.

    Irenaeus’ view of the power of divine glory to transform humans and humanity may provide conceptual raw material for a constructive political theology and theo-political aesthetic of sustainable systemic transformation. Drawing on Irenaeus’ Adversus haereses, Epideixis, and other extant writings, I begin by sketching the theocentric character of Irenaeus’ understanding of politics and his embrace of symphonically-differentiated unity. I consider the socio-political implications of Irenaeus’ juxtaposition of paradigmatic models of change—Christ’s radical work of recapitulation—and progressive models of growth—the Holy Spirit’s multivalent work of fostering spiritual progress in human lives across the spectrum of the divine οἰκονομία and in the collective homo by whom Irenaeus tells a communal story with a unified protagonist.

.

  • Abstract

    An influential contemporary trend in pneumatology, pioneered by Thomas Weinandy and Sarah Coakley, uses resources from traditions of prayer to explain how the Spirit is equal to the Father and Son. Several thinkers who participate in what Coakley calls “incorporative” pneumatology draw on figures like John of the Cross to argue specifically that the Spirit’s activity in originating other divine persons is equal to that of the Father and Son. Despite the promising novelty of this approach, some have criticized these thinkers for attenuating trinitarian distinction without overcoming trinitarian inequalities. My paper contributes to incorporative pneumatology by supplying two new insights that I take from John of the Cross: his iterative theory of apophatic language and his nuptial framework for examining active trinitarian love. I argue that the combination of these two insights accounts for the equality of trinitarian activity in terms of nuptial love without jeopardizing trinitarian distinction.

  • Abstract

    Theological talk of the Spirit strikes at the root of the problem of theological utterance itself. To speak truly of God presumes that one speak in the Spirit. Yet, if the Spirit is the Spirit of prayer, then theology is led ever deeper into prayer's region of vast silence. Held within this silence, how can theology open its mouth? The paper considers two styles of theological speech, both of which prioritize the unutterable as touched on in prayer. These are John Caputo's "weak" theology and Sarah Coakley's systematics. It then turns to the desert moanstic tradition, which places theology under the discipline of silence. A contempoary theology that aims to follow after prayer must enter its unsettling silence, as well as those other unsettling silences that surround us: those of voices suppressed, lives cut short, and the ever more likely great silence of the species. 

  • Abstract

    Although the influence of Paul Claudel upon twentieth-century theology is well known, little attention has been given to the way that Claudel’s oeuvre can help us not only to rethink a kind of sacramental cosmology but also the ways in which pneumatology is bound up with this project and reveals it as something more than just a retrieval of the premodern sacred. Through a reading of Claudel's second Great Ode, 'Spirit and Water', I argue that Claudel’s pneumatology points towards a theological resacralization of the finite that includes human subjectivity and creativity, indeed, one that gives a central place to the body, creaturely finitude, and to the shaping work of the human imagination. In this way, Claudel points us to a robustly theological account of human subjectivity in a sacramental cosmos, an account that escapes the aporetic modern theological shuttle between the epistemological turn-to-the-subject and reactionary reassertions of premodern metaphysics.

.

  • Abstract

    This paper considers at least some of the pneumatological dimensions of redemption through a particular focus on what Bernard Lonergan called “the just and mysterious law of the cross,” with an eye towards the subversion of notions of redemptive violence. Elements of Lonergan's trinitarian theology, and particularly the way in which the missions of the Word and Holy Spirit elevate human beings to share in the life of the Trinity through charity — the same charity that informed Christ's redemptive act, and which is given to the redeemed in and as the Holy Spirit — provide the fundamental theological basis. This is further refined by M. Shawn Copeland's womanist appropriation of these categories, calling for a eucharistic solidarity, which keeps alife the dangerous memory of the lynched Jesus, thereby undercutting any recourse to sacral violence, while also recognizing the reality of violence within history and the redemption enacted in history.

  • Abstract

    The last months have witnessed a worldwide spike in antisemitic and Islamophobic violence as communities are scapegoated for events thousands of miles away. This reality demands a response from theologians, especially given our historical complicity in such violence. Queer and political theologians have begun addressing scapegoating violence, but their proposals do not explain theology’s significance beyond the ecclesial community. I argue for a political theology that deploys practices of mourning to position the church (as Christ’s body) against the political powers responsible for victimization. The goal is twofold: first, that religious communities liberate themselves from the privilege enabling them to enact scapegoating violence; and, second, that believers would be formed into people who stand in solidarity with, or even in front of and in defense of, other victims. Normed by Christ and trained by the eucharist, Christians “complete what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions” by suffering for others’ sake.

  • Abstract

    Contextual theology, by drawing attention to the ways in which context affects theology, has critically reshaped the way we do and think about theology. From a contextual perspective, theology is merely speculative or naively subjective unless theologians acknowledge the contextual underpinnings of their work. But the concept of “context” itself warrants critical examination as well. Drawing upon ethnographic fieldwork with Adivasi (indigenous) Christians in India, this paper offers a critique of the way context functions in contextual theology and proposes a new way of understanding the revelatory capacity of our contexts. Building upon the work of Kathryn Tanner and Kevin Hector on the mediation of the Spirit, I argue that the Spirit works through our negotiation of diverse perspectives on context. My emphasis is on the disruptive potential of the Spirit, who draws us into relationship with others who interpret and engage with our contexts in different ways.

  • Abstract

    In conversation with Amos Yong, Ashon T. Crawley, Keri Day, and J. Kameron Carter, I present my own account of an ethical pneumatology describing the Spirit's work to bring upheaval to communities suffering under injustice. In support of that account, I trace the pneumatologies at play in the Azusa Street Revival. Yong notes that phenomenological pneumatologies were utilized to sanction white supremacist attacks against Azusa, while ethical pneumatologies were cited by Azusa’s leaders to justify the countercultural character of their worship. Crawley contends that where Azusa did affirm aesthetics, it was in the privileging of incoherence— through the gift of glossolalia—so that persons and communities might be liberated from the settler colonial logics developed to justify white supremacist dominance. By engaging these analyses, I consider the ongoing entanglement of aesthetic pneumatologies with white supremacy and articulate how ethical pneumatologies can better resist the same. 

.

  • Abstract

    This paper offers a potential solution to the collusion of theological claims about humanity and dehumanizing violence, socially mediated forms of harm that undermine human dignity. Using the work of theologian Edward Schillebeeckx and philosopher Judith Butler, it promotes the force of Christian eschatological hope as a methodological pathway beyond such harm. Schillebeeckx’s thought responds to experiences of contrast and suffering by reimagining humanity in line with the Reign of God and promoting a form of theology that works to defend the humanum, the new humanity announced by God coming into creation. Butler examines the ways a “world” conditions human subjectivity as circumscribed by violence. Their political philosophy promotes a nonviolent force of hope as a practice of worldbuilding. In integrating Schillebeeckx’s and Butler’s reflections on violence and humanity, this paper challenges theology to implement the force of hope to actively dismantle forms of dehumanizing violence through generating new worlds.

  • Abstract

    This presentation argues that political theology clarifies the problem of populist conflict, and it offers resources that can help us address it. I will focus my reflections on Justice and Love by Mary Zournazi and Rowan Williams (2021). Zournazi and Williams present a compelling case for the view that religion is a force for peace. In my reading, however, they underestimate the role of religious traditions in encouraging violence, and they overstate the value of civility. In response, I will argue that political theology can incorporate the commitment to political conflict described by feminist theorists such as Judith Butler, Bonnie Honig, and Joan Wallach Scott. In my view, medieval negative theology models a politics that is capacious enough to incorporate connection and conflict, sympathy and refusal, appreciation and anger.

  • Abstract

    Two methodologies dominate queer theologies: an apologetic hermeneutics that seeks to normalize queer people, and a paranoid hermeneutics that seeks to upend systems of determining and validating what is normal. The apologetic approach fails to dismantle insider-outsider systems of recognition; it merely redraws the borders. The paranoid approach reduces the ethical value of queerness to an antisocial ascetic ideal; it thus eclipses the pleasures of queer worldmaking. This paper describes an alternative methodology that I call (with apologies to José Esteban Muñoz) reparative-disidentification. Two recent texts exemplify this approach: Lamya H’s Hijab Butch Blues and Ashon Crawley’s The Lonely Letters. These texts offer what neither the paranoid nor the apologetic mode can achieve: a queer economy of representation that circumvents straight, white, capitalist systems of recognition altogether, clearing ground for otherwise worlds in which queers receive the wahi of their queerness as an invitation to experiment with new relational forms.

In The Disabled God Revisited: Trinity, Eschatology, and Liberation (T&T Clark 2023), Lisa Powell offers a constructive critique of and elaboration upon Nancy Eiesland's seminal text The Disabled God: Toward a Liberatory Theology of Disability (Abingdon Press 1994). At the heart of Powell's proposal is a portrait of the Trinity that emphasizes God's deep solidarity with creation, the marginalized, and the disabled. As she sketches this portrait, Powell brings disability and liberation theologies together with an unlikely conversation partner - Barth studies. The result is an account of divine origins that includes vulnerability, care, and interdependence. This panel is an appreciative interrogation of Powell's book, examining it from numerous theological perspectives. Powell will be present to engage the panelists and the audience in conversation.

This panel offers alternative ecological paradigms and social movements that intersect with environmental activism across cultural and religious landscapes. The first paper introduces the concept of maroon ecologies, highlighting their resistance against property-driven conceptions of freedom and relevance for alternative socialities in neoliberal capitalism. The second paper examines the interplay between labor, faith, and land reform in El Salvador, emphasizing the role of liberative Christian visions to foster solidarity and cooperative engagement with the environment. The third paper focuses on Kallen Pokkudan, the 'mangrove man' of Kerala, analyzing his ecological activism through new materialist theory and addressing the challenges faced by the Dalit Pulaya community. The editors of "Liberating People, Planet, and Religion '' connect the discussion to Christianity's ability to challenge exploitative capitalism and promote ecological and economic justice for the flourishing of all beings. Together, these papers offer critical insights into environmental activism, faith-based solidarity, Dalit identity, and religion’s potential for social transformation.

  • Abstract

    This paper examines the burgeoning field of maroon ecologies: environmental thinking about and with those people who escaped from slavery and built alternative societies apart from the plantation regime. Rather than representing yet another back-to-the-land approach to ecology, marronage is a useful paradigm for resisting conceptions of freedom grounded in property. This paper first considers how Lockean understandings of the relationship between property and labor result in a conception of freedom as self-ownership—which also transform humanity’s relationship to the other-than-human world. The second section then considers how marronage’s relationship to land—especially the provision grounds and wild landscapes—interact to form an alternative sociality to that imposed by capitalism’s property regime. Finally, the paper considers the challenge of thinking marronage in the context of neoliberalism. How can maroon ecology—an imaginary shaped by the act of escape—help us in a moment in which neoliberal capitalism seems virtually omnipresent?

  • Abstract

    This paper explores the intersection of labor and the environment in the geography of the plantation and cooperative efforts that have sought to resist and transform it. Specifically, it considers the constructive role that liberative visions of Christ have played in people’s movements for land reform in El Salvador, especially in the late 20th century. These efforts are rooted in forms of solidarity between workers, faith communities, and the land. Further, I propose that the witness of these traditions can serve to cultivate deep solidarity with professional class communities in North America, as it provides systemic understanding of issues of migration and farm labor, and articulates alternative constructive visions of cooperatively working and dwelling with the land.

  • Abstract

    This proposal aims to explore the intersection of environmental activism, Dalit identity, and ecological philosophy through an analysis of Kallen Pokkudan's autobiography, "Kandalkaadukalkidayil Ente Jeevitham." Pokkudan, renowned as the 'mangrove man' of Kerala, offers a unique perspective on the reestablishment of mangrove forests and the challenges faced by the Dalit Pulaya community in Kerala's Kannur district. Through his narrative, Pokkudan not only recounts his life story but also reflects on the historical dehumanization of Dalits within India's caste system and the potential for societal transformation.

    This study will employ new materialist theory, particularly object-oriented ontology (O-O-O), to analyze Pokkudan's ecological activism as a form of "arboreal activism" and "dark ecology." By emphasizing emplaced subjectivity and distributed agency, Pokkudan challenges caste-based discrimination and anthropocentric supremacies, advocating for a relational way of being rooted in deep solidarity and egalitarianism.

    Keywords: Kallen Pokkudan, Dalit identity, mangrove forests, ecological activism, object-oriented ontology, casteism


           
  • Abstract

    Too often, religious engagements with economy and ecology have placed emphasis on individual morality, action, and agency at the level of consumption patterns or have suggested mere modifications within existing economic paradigms. Contributors to a new volume — Liberating People, Planet, and Religion: Intersections of Ecology, Economics, and Christianity, which will be published in July 2024 (Roman and Littlefield) — call into question the adequacy of this approach in light of the urgency of climate change which is always ever entwined with ongoing patterns of exploitation, oppression, and colonialism in current economic systems. The basic intuition driving this volume is that while Christianity has by and large become the handmaiden of exploitative capitalism and empire, it might also reclaim latent theologies and religious practices that call into question the fundamental valuation of labor without recognition or rest, of extractive exploitation, and a “winner take all” praxis. The volume's editors, Joerg Rieger and Terra Schwerin Rowe, will discuss the conceptual framework of the volume and some of the key insights it gathers.

This panel explores cutting-edge scholarship using current cognitive theories applied research to the study of religion, religions, or religious-related phenomena. It is intentionally broad on scope, focusing on the most-recent and novel applications of CSR.

  • Abstract

    Social scientists have long proposed that funerary rituals foster group cohesion. Our research rigorously tests and refines these long-standing qualitative claims by uncovering the causal mechanisms and quantifiable effects of this universal human behavior. We conducted two preregistered sequential studies following the national funeral of Queen Elizabeth II, exploring the psycho-social pathways to identity fusion and their impact on pro-group commitment among 1,869 British spectators. The initial study, involving 1,632 participants surveyed within two weeks of the funeral, validated predictions that intense sadness during the event correlated with heightened identity fusion and pro-group commitment. The subsequent longitudinal examination, involving 237 participants over 12 months, delved into the causal psycho-social pathways to identity fusion. As expected, the visceral quality of memories exerted a transformative effect on personal identity through processes of personal reflection, ultimately leading to identity fusion via perceived sharedness within the group.This research contributes to accumulating evidence that sharing emotionally intense dysphoric experiences with others, including viewing sacred rituals, leads to incredibly potent social bonding. 

  • Abstract

    Collective rituals involve coordinating intentions and synchronizing actions to align emotional states and social identities. However, the mechanics of achieving group-level synchrony is yet unclear. We report the results of a naturalistic study in the context of an Islamic congregational prayer that involves synchronous movement. We used wearable devices to capture data on body posture, autonomic responses, and spatial proximity to investigate how postural alignment and shared arousal intertwine during this ritual. The findings reveal a dual process at play: postural alignment appears to be more localized, with worshippers synchronizing their movements with their nearest neighbors, while physiological alignment operates on a broader scale, primarily driven by the central role of the religious leader. Our findings underscore the importance of interpersonal dynamics in collective gatherings and the role of physical co-presence in fostering connections among participants, with implications extending to our understanding of group dynamics across various social settings.

  • Abstract

    In this paper, I argue that embodied cognition helps to undermine the Humean dualism of facts and values. I draw on two contributions to embodied cognition, the concept of affordances (originally developed by Gibson) and the enactive approach (originally developed by Varela, Thompson and Rosch). Gibson argued that the perceiving animal would typically be engaged in some goal-directed activity, and he speaks in this context of the animal’s perception of “affordances,” i.e., value-laden opportunities in their environment. The enactive approach treats cognition as a dynamic system that arises from the interactions between an animal and its environment. Together, these two concepts open the door to a realist account of values. Insofar as religious practices are regimens for training participants in the perception of affordances, we can underaind them as helping people move from novice to competent to expert at recognizing real good and bad in the world. 

  • Abstract

    This study investigates predictors and consequences of identity fusion, a profound sense of unity with a group, towards Turkish citizens and Syrian refugees following the catastrophic earthquakes in Türkiye on February 6th, 2023. Surveys were administered in-person to 120 Turkish earthquake survivors in the most heavily impacted areas. Results revealed challenges in establishing relationships between emotional intensity, perceived sharedness, and identity fusion due to extreme emotional intensity during the earthquake. However, mean fusion levels significantly increased with perceived shared suffering, validating predictions. Identity fusion also predicted pro-group commitment, measured by volunteerism pledges of Turkish earthquake survivors. As expected, Turkish earthquake survivors exhibited higher pro-group commitment scores than their Syrian counterparts. The study contributes to understanding the complex dynamics of identity fusion in post-catastrophe contexts.

  • Abstract

    This paper analyzes CSR theories of SA attribution, and tests them through an online survey from 40 native Filipino speakers who currently reside in the Philippines. Preliminary data suggest that when gods are involved as the subject, they are coded with non-human case markers. We also see differences depending on whether gods are framed in Tagalog or English terms: human case markers are used for English terms for gods (Lord, God, Jesus, etc.) while non-human markers are used for Tagalog terms (Diyos, Panginnon, Hesus, etc.). Such findings support certain of CSR’s theories but also problematize the more universalizing claims around cross-cultural supernatural agent attribution at the heart of certain foundational CSR theories.

  • Abstract

    Between 30 and 60% of the population have experienced sense of presence in the form of a deceased loved one (Castelnovo et al., 2015; Elsaesser et al., 2021; Streit-Horn, 2011). These experiences (i.e., ghosts, grief or bereavement hallucinations) may generally be called after death experiences (ADEs). In this paper, I will argue that 4E cognition, or the notion that cognition is shaped by dynamic interactions between the brain, body, and physical/social environments, plays a key role in understanding the cognitive underpinnings and behavioral outcomes of ADEs as both universal experiences and those deemed religious or spiritual. Drawing from mixed-methods experimental research in cognitive neuroscience, I posit that sensorimotor manipulations of a bereaved individual may induce experiences of presence more readily than in non-bereaved. Based on clinical data and preliminary findings, I will explore how future research relying on 4E cognition principles may impact the study of religious or spiritual phenomenon.

     

Approaches to formalize CCC include neuroimaging studies, computational modeling, phenomenological analysis, and ethnographic research. Each approach aims to identify cognitive capabilities involved, understand cultural influences, and integrate findings into a biocultural theory of CCC. The proposed panel, comprising diverse studies on demonic presences, tulpamancy, alien encounters, and shamanic guides, seeks to synthesize these insights. It aims to delineate variations in experiences and their underlying neurocognitive mechanisms while considering cultural dynamics. The panel also intends to engage in discussions with attendees, potentially leading to a collaborative book on a comprehensive theory of CCC phenomena.

  • Abstract

    How is the subjective experience of demons different from the experience of benevolent spirit companions? This presentation explores how negative emotional valence, lack of control, and high-arousal characterize malevolent agent encounters. Moreover, the ways we respond to malevolent spirits, both spontaneously and in religious/therapeutic contexts, resemble strategies for responding to (e.g., resisting or reconciling with) hostile agents in real life. Benevolent spiritual companions, much like friends in real life, diminish the perception of hostile spiritual forces, and can be summoned as allies in spiritual struggles. The dynamics of Cognitive Companion Construction (CCC), both hostile and benevolent, reflect an amplified imaginative process of social-cognitive simulation – in which the mind synthesizes negative and positive agent encounters into a symbolic (generalized) form, so as to update and generalize our responses to social actors (including the self) in real life.

  • Abstract

    This paper explores the phenomenon of alien abductions and other sustained personal relationships with aliens—what I term “alien interfacings”—through the lens of Cognitive Companion Construction (CCC), an approach which seeks to understand the cognitive underpinnings allowing the human mind to construct and perceive an ostensibly external agent through internal mechanisms. Aliens are one such type of constructed companion. Through combined factors of expectation, cultural priors, and sensory deprivation through hypnosis or meditation, experiencers generate dense narratives of alien interfacings which often bear powerful transformative results in their lives. These narratives, and the alien interlocuters with whom experiencers build relationships, are created by a combination of cultural and cognitive mechanisms. This paper seeks to better understand the internal narration mechanism, the mental vocabulary upon which it draws, and what such a narrative says about the culture in which it is generated.

  • Abstract

    Cognitive Companion Construction (CCC), as a provisional model, suggests the examination of the preceding factors in encounters with immaterial beings or agents often deemed supernatural. A meditation tradition rising out of the internet in the past decade offers a seemingly novel exposition of how one might create a persistent encounter with an immaterial being or supernatural agent. Tulpamancy prescribes a training curriculum of visualization and narrative development that is equal parts excogitation and phenomenological creation of the imagined agent. Through the lens of CCC, the agents encountered in Tulpamancy are situated as cognitive constructs. The emic terminology and prescriptive practices of Tulpamancy resemble an experiential model supported by the CCC framing, in which a Tavesian building blocks approach and predictive coding theory structure the agent encounter as trainable, repeatable, and companionate as a result of cultural priors both inherent and explicit in Tulpamancy practice.

  • Abstract

    The presentation discusses Cognitive Companion Construction (CCC) within shamanism, drawing on insights from CSR and addressing traditional and neo-shamanic practices. Methodological challenges in studying shamanism cross-culturally are acknowledged, emphasizing the need for multidisciplinary approaches. Cognitive capacities observed in shamanism include altered states of consciousness, symbolic thought, narrative construction, and the search for meaning. Research suggests that such experiences are facilitated by cognitive processes like hyperactive agency detection and theory of mind. Cultural contexts significantly shape the expression of shamanic practices, with variations reflecting societal understandings of the cosmos and social cohesion mechanisms. Distinguishing between collective and distributive modes of effervescence on a continuum, the paper theorizes the mechanisms that contribute to the emergence and expansion of novel practices like contemporary neo-shamanisms. The conclusion emphasizes the interplay between cognitive capacities and cultural contexts in shaping CCC within shamanism, contributing to a deeper understanding of religious beliefs and practices within CSR.

This panel examines noncanonical and paracanonical genres to highlight the ways karmic thinking is embedded in three different social contexts. First, against the backdrop of the Yuan Mongol court’s demotion of Confucian literati and elevation of Buddhist monks, Confucian dramatists promoted Confucian family moral responsibility through the use ofBuddhist karma in both individual and collective terms as a transformative force for the entire family. Secondly, Ming literati argumentation on whether a monk could finish a blood-copy of the Huayan Sutra through three successive reincarnations reveals how late Ming literati conceived of karma and reincarnation. And finally, the third historical case examines sponsorship of the printing and distribution of the Yongle Northern Canon as a means to generate merit for one’s own future rebirths, consolidate power, and support Buddhist monastic institutions. Our discussant will juxtapose these noncanonical understandings with those of Buddhist canonical theories of karma, particularly Yogacara.

  • Abstract

    Chinese Yuan dramas (zaju 雜劇) often employed notions of Buddhist karma in their plots and subplots. To highlight this dramatic aspect, I will analyze the karmic components of the play Kanqiannu mai yuanjia zhaizhu (A Slave to Money Buys a Creditor as His Enemy). The dramatic plot connects two unrelated families through karmic retribution and the transfer of blessings, a method akin to the transfer of merit. The text of the play shows how a family member’s good and bad deeds not only bring good and bad karma to oneself, but also alter the collective karma of the entire family, affecting its collective rise and fall. I argue that such plot features were a means for Confucian dramatists to promote family-oriented collective values within the unique context of the Yuan Dynasty (1279-1368), at a time, when Confucian literati were disparaged and Buddhist monks were privileged.

  • Abstract

    This project focuses on the rhetorical modes of assessing reincarnation and karmic connections presented in prefaces and postfaces by Chinese literati from the Ming dynasty to the Republican Era who venerated the blood-copy of the Huayan Sutra by the Yuan dynasty monk Shanji善繼 (1286-1357). An intergenerational production, the progenitor of the project was thought to be the eminent monk Yongming Yanshou永明延壽 (904-975), who reincarnated as Shanji, and who completed the project through a second reincarnation as the great early Ming statesman Song Lian宋濂 (1310-1381).Literati argumentation often adopted a uniquely Buddhist method of historical proof premised on assessments of reincarnation, karmic connections, dream encounters, and personal realization. This work analyzes their assessments to better understand how these concepts functioned within the contexts of elite literati Buddhist belief and engagement with venerated artifacts like this very unique intergenerational blood-copy of the Huayan Sutra.

  • Abstract

    In general, Buddhists believe that one can improve one’s karmic fortunes and generate merit through copying, printing, distributing, or reading Buddhist scriptures (John Kieschnick, 2003, chapter three). In my fifteen year study of the Ming dynasty Yongle Northern Canon, I have discovered that the colophons, inscriptions, notes and prefaces attached to this project indicate that emperors, empresses, officials, eunuchs, and many others believed that if they gave donations for the printing and distributing of the Buddhist canon, they could accumulate enough merit for a better rebirth or to be reborn in the Pure Land of Amitabha Buddha. This paper will analyze these paracanonical sources in order to highlight how members of the court understood karma and used their positions and financial resources to print and distribute this multi-volume set. I will focus on references to this merit-making in the writings of members of the royal family, eunuchs, and monks.