You are here

Online Program Book

The AAR's inaugural Online June Sessions of the Annual Meetings were held on June 25, 26, and 27, 2024. For program questions, please reach out to annualmeeting@aarweb.org.

This is the preliminary program for the 2024 in-person Annual Meeting, hosted with the Society for Biblical Literature in San Diego, CA - November 23-26. Pre-conference workshops and many committee meetings will be held November 22. If you have questions about the program, contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org. All times are listed in local/Pacific Time.

A23-209

Theme: Perry Schmidt-Leukel’s “Different Comparison” of Buddhism and Christianity (Author Meets Critics)

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Panelists discuss with Perry Schmidt-Leukel his new book *The Celestial Web. Buddhism and Christianity. A Different Comparison* (Orbis 2024). Is his application of fractal analysis to religious diversity able to overcome post-structuralist critiques of interreligious comparisons? Which insights can be gained from his approach for the methodologies in Comparative Religion and Comparative Theology? How sound is Schmidt-Leukel’s claim that major typological differences between Buddhism and Christianity replicate within each of the two traditions? To what extent can his approach foster reciprocal illumination and interreligious learning? These questions are discussed by specialists in Comparative Religion, Comparative Theology, Buddhist-Christian Studies and Buddhist Studies / “Buddhist Theology”.

A23-210

Theme: Confucian Contemplation: Historical Landscape and Contemporary Significance

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Confucian contemplation, particularly quiet-sitting meditation, has been historically overlooked in contemplative studies. This is despite its deep integration in Confucian traditions, where figures like Cheng Yi and Yang Shi viewed it as crucial for moral self-cultivation and active engagement with the world. Zhu Xi's evolving stance further illuminated its philosophical depth. The underrepresentation is partly due to the practice's societal integration, the absence of texts with detailed techniques, and the scholarly necessity to reinterpret and recontextualize these traditions after their decline in modern times.The papers session advocates for including the Ruist perspective in global research, noting its potential relevance to modern professionals akin to ancient Ru scholars. It includes papers exploring early Chinese ritual fasting, the philosophical dimensions of quiet-sitting in the lineage of pattern-principle learning, Zhu Xi's meditation interpreted through a Chinese Catholic lens, and the efficacy of Confucian practices in contemporary pedagogy of liberal arts.

  • Ritual Fasting and Inner Cultivation in Early China

    Abstract

    “Fasting” 齋 was central to early Chinese ritual practice, whether in preparation for sacrificing to the spirits or other occasions of ritual significance. In this paper, I propose to examine the practices that gather about this imperative to “fast” (often written with the allograph 齊). Ritual fasting involved not only the proscription of various activities (social engagement and other sources of pleasure and distraction) but also contemplative elements that have not drawn as much scholarly attention. Drawing primarily on the Liji 禮記, I will discuss the details and practical logic of ritual fasting as well as its relationship to contemporaneous practices of inner cultivation.

  • Quiet-Sitting Meditation: A Philosophical Practice in Cheng-Zhu Learning of Pattern-Principle

    Abstract

    Confucian philosophers within the lineage of pattern-principle learning perceived quiet-sitting meditation as a pivotal philosophical exercise in the broader pursuit of self-cultivation. Cheng Yi considered quiet-sitting among various contemplative practices that fostered reverence, a virtue crucial for discerning and engaging with the pattern-principles inherent in the world. Yang Shi underscored quiet-sitting as a foundational and primary step in self-cultivation, attributing significant philosophical importance to this practice. Zhu Xi aimed to amalgamate the perspectives of Cheng and Yang, elucidating his understanding of quiet-sitting through three stages of his philosophical journey: initially dismissing its significance, later valuing it as the fundamental practice of reverence, and eventually regarding it on par with other contemplative practices, reverting to Cheng Yi’s stance. As the practice and its broader implications were deeply intertwined with ongoing intellectual dialogues concerning virtuous human existence within the pattern-principle tradition, the act of Confucian quiet-sitting inherently embodies philosophical dimensions.

  • Rereading Zhu Xi’s Quiet-Sitting Practice through a Chinese Catholic Lens

    Abstract

    With a focus on the quiet-sitting meditation of major Neo-Confucian figure Zhu Xi (1130-1200), this paper aims to shed new light on Zhu’s contemplative practice by adopting a comparative theological method. More specifically, it follows the interpretations of Zhu’s quiet-sitting put forth by Chinese Jesuit theologian Hu Guozhen (1948-) in his work to “inculturate” Christian prayer for fellow Chinese Catholics. Whether simply through oversight or because his study of Zhu on this topic was motivated by different concerns than those of most scholars, Hu’s reading of Zhu Xi has not been noted in contemporary scholarship; however, this paper argues his novel approach can help us think in fresh ways about Zhu’s quiet-sitting practice—especially its flexible approach to cultivating “reverence” as opposed to pursuing mental tranquility through strict techniques, and its relation to other practices like reading.

  • Confucian Contemplation and Experiential Learning

    Abstract

    This talk will share some of the findings from research I conducted in two upper-level seminars that I recently taught at two different Midwestern liberal arts colleges in which I included Confucian contemplative practices as modes of experiential learning. These seminars surveyed and analyzed contemplative practices primarily from an array of Asian traditions, but I also included case studies of both religions and modern, secular, and hybridized traditions in the West. An aim of this IRB-approved research is to assess the pedagogical effectiveness of using contemplative pedagogy as a form of experiential learning. The two Confucian contemplative techniques that I included as components of contemplative pedagogy in these seminars were quiet-sitting meditation and self-examination/self-monitoring. I will report on aspects of what students accomplished both inside and outside the classroom relating to these Confucian practices, on the data I collected and analyzed from students, and on the preliminary findings concerning their effectiveness, as types of experiential learning, in enhancing student learning. 

     

A23-211

Theme: From Tweets to Tiktoks: Reimagining Religious Influence through Women’s Social Media Use

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

This session examines women’s use of text, images, video, memes, and audio across various social media platforms and spanning four religious traditions in North America. By focusing on brujas on Instagram, Muslims on TikTok, evangelicals on Twitter, and Catholics on YouTube, the papers explore situated digital practices. How do women use media to contest dominant and hegemonic interpretations of religious texts and practices and put forth their own? How do they use humor, creativity, and referentiality to create digital content to assert authority and build community? What are some of the ways that the relationship between online and offline worlds are impacting religious experience? This papers’ session approaches these questions from a variety of perspectives to theorize some of the ways in which religious women’s use of diverse social network sites contribute to theorizing digital religion and digital archives and methods. 

  • "Why Is This Guy Preaching Again?": Rachel Held Evans and Feminist Counter-Messaging on Twitter

    Abstract

    In the 2010s, Twitter rose in popularity as a digital space for theological dialogue, debate, and grandstanding. For feminist Christians, Twitter activism was a vital form of activism with real-world consequences that was motivated by theological ideas about God’s ethical expectations. I argue that social media platforms were spaces in which evangelical women who were marginalized based on their gender and who grew up with an emphasis on evangelism could “inverse evangelize” conservative evangelicals with progressive theologies and progressive politics. By focusing on one well-known Twitter user, Rachel Held Evans, in her posts relating to two famous men, John Piper and Mark Driscoll, I examine the way that feminist women used Twitter posts to push against the logic of patriarchal theology. This paper shows how Evans, a woman who had less institutional power than either Piper or Driscoll, used Twitter to contradict their viewpoints in view of an evangelical and post-evangelical public.

  • “These are for girls only”: Experience, Authority, and the Practice of Naṣīḥa in Online Contexts

    Abstract

    When the “these are for girls only” meme went viral on TikTok in 2021, many Muslim women in North America used the meme to create content that comically addresses the commentary they receive about their Islamic practice and the boundaries they’ve established around it. This paper focuses on the concept of naṣīḥa, understood to be a discursive mode of communal regulation in accordance with constructed ideals, in digital contexts. It examines several TikTok videos in which Muslim women address their audience about who is or is not authorized to offer social commentary on their Islamic practice on the basis of shared experience. I explore these videos as sites of contestation surrounding authority, arguing that these women use their videos to counter hegemonic conceptions of who has the authority to determine proper practice. How might focusing on the concept of naṣīḥa, or social commentary, complicate scholarly understandings of top-down models of Islamic authority? This paper attempts to address this question.

  • “Taking Spirit To Market”: Brujapreneurs Make Digital Sacred Space on Instagram

    Abstract

    Over the last several years there has been a growing interest in popular culture on the modern-day witch. To contest the erasure of Afro-Indigenous spiritual perspectives, this paper looks at how digital sacredness the Instagram accounts of self-identified brujas of Afro-Caribbean descent. By creating digital sacred spaces that become the basis for their activism, the bruja’s social media presence acts against larger hegemonic structures, such as white supremacy, colonialism/imperialism, racism, and homophobia. By enabling the divine via social media the brujas are able to have a voice in the world that would seek to silence them. Their social platforms allow their voices to be easily amplified (read: go viral) in ways that did not exist before. Ultimately, this paper seeks to begin conversations on how digital media has transformed newer generations to engage with the cosmologies of Afro-Indigenous religiosity.

  • Do Nuns Just Want to Have Fun? #MediaNuns and the Millennial American Catholic Sister

    Abstract

    This paper examines the Roman Catholic sisters known as the Daughters of Saint Paul and their use of social media as part of their mission to use the media to evangelize. Through using modern forms, the Daughters of St. Paul emerge as leaders in Catholic media use. While their content challenges some stereotypes about Catholic nuns, their efforts seem primarily to serve recruitment goals, and their young millennial sisters are leading the efforts in making the nun life appear attractive to prospective future sisters that exist among their following. Through analyzing the Daughters of St. Paul’s use of Instagram, TikTok, and Youtube, this paper explores themes related to technology and religious traditions, technology and communal formation, virtual belonging, and politics and technology. Ultimately, while the Daughters of St. Paul are committed to using “new media,” they do so while preserving traditional aesthetics and messaging for the Catholic Church in America.

  • Conjuring Interiority: Womanist Reflections on Ancestor Veneration, Social Media, and a Philosophy of Aesthetics

    Abstract

    Philosophical approaches to Black aesthetics have included how Black human beings make meaning and see value in their everyday lives. The theorization of this cultural and social production has been essential to a philosophy of aesthetics, as shown through the work of Lewis R. Gordon and Paul C. Taylor. These philosophers have provided historical trajectories of Western philosophy and Black expressive culture to define blackness and racialization’s impact on how people show up in this world. Therefore, this paper seeks to come alongside Gordon and Taylor and explore the role of ancestor veneration in the project of Black value and meaning-making within technology. By drawing from womanist reflections on aesthetic interiority, I will examine the diasporic tradition of Southern Hoodoo on social media as a site for understanding how ancestors assist in the inner cultivation, transformation, and construction of individuals and communities.

A23-212

Theme: Heterotopias

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Michel Foucault labeled counter-spaces that influence, contest, mirror, and invert as heterotopias. Paper one considers heterotopia through transformations of a plot of land in Colorado, unveiling environmental challenges, adaptations, and the interplay of sacred spaces facing climate-related shifts. The second, co-authored paper offers a dialogic analysis of two U.S. social institutions – early nineteenth century prisons and mid twentieth century sexual closets – at a key moment in their historical formations. In the dialectic between imagined and materialized, they each produce another heterotopia – queer and spectral in form – in which other worlds are imagined, queering the hetero of heterotopia. The third, multi-authored paper showcases innovative ethnographic research of a revival of Victorian era-style spiritualism underway in British public houses (‘pubs’), the latest collective space for contemporary spirit communication. The fourth paper examines the ambiguous utopia/heterotopia that is the Métis community of Ste Madeleine in Manitoba, destroyed by the settler government.

  • Brothels to Books: Heterotopia and Protestant Morality in a Boulder, Colorado Floodplain (1884-1921)

    Abstract

    This paper considers the idea of heterotopia through a small plot of land in Boulder, Colorado. Located in a floodplain, it transformed from a red light district in the 1880s to a site of ramshackle dwellings in the 1910s, then to a city park and public library. This transformation was aided by several catastrophic floods that destroyed brothels and saloons, and it was propelled by moralizing forces. Relying on newspapers, oral histories, city and national archives, and city government reports, this paper will engage in a critical conversation with heterotopia through a space on the outskirts of morality and traditional notions of religion. By examining the interplay between human-driven meaning-making and climate-related events, this microhistory narrates the efforts of social forces to define and control the floodplain but also unveils the environmental challenges, adaptations, and the interplay of sacred spaces in the face of climate-related shifts.

  • Prisons and Closets: U.S. American Protestant Materializations of the Secular

    Abstract

    This co-authored paper offers a dialogic analyses of two U.S. American social institutions--early nineteenth century prisons and mid twentieth century sexual closets--at a key moment in their respective historical formation. Building on Michel Foucault's theorization "heterotopias," we analyze these sites as spaces of containment for perverse masculinities, with attention to these material spaces of containment as sedimentations of religious and non-religious imaginations, practices, and institutions. We explore, in particular, how religious imaginaries shape and are shaped by material spaces regarded as “secular.” These secular heterotopias, we argue, were and are materialized through particular Protestant discourses. At the same time, in the dialectic between the imagined and the materialized, they each produce yet another heterotopia--queer and spectral in form-- in which other worlds are imagined, thus queering the hetero of heterotopia. 

  • Pub Psychic Nights as Heterotopia: Exploring Experiences of Marginal, Unlikely, and Transformative Spaces in Contemporary Spirit Communication

    Abstract

    In Britain, a revival of Victorian era-style spiritualism is arguably underway. Yet, instead of seances or mediumship demonstrations in domestic homes, theatres, or the Spiritualist Church (as during the ‘golden age of spiritualism’), public houses (‘pubs’) have emerged as the latest collective space for contemporary spirit communication. Drawing on innovative ethnographic research, and engaging with Foucault's concept of heterotopia, we argue that pub psychic nights destabilise social norms and empower marginalised participants, as well as encourage reflection and the potential for real-time social change, especially for working-class women. The broadly accessible and commonplace nature of the British pub helps to scaffold and promote the development of alternative beliefs and practices, beyond more traditional locations for spirituality. Despite critiques, in a context where religious institutional affiliation has dramatically declined, pub psychic nights function with transformative potential and offer new spaces that combine spirituality with social change.

  • Re-theorizing Heterotopia: Towards an Ambiguous Utopianism

    Abstract

    In this paper, I propose that a more theoretically promising understanding of the concept of ‘heterotopia’ is possible only if we attend to its utopian roots. To do this I examine the ambiguous utopia/heterotopia that is the Métis community of Ste Madeleine - a small settlement near where I grew up that was destroyed by the settler government. By re-theorizing ‘heterotopia’ conceptually from utopian studies, and particularly the work of Louis Marin, we arrive at a more theoretically useful concept for analyzing the actual places/spaces that Foucault gestures toward in his original articulation of the concept. 

A23-213

Theme: Thinking about Orthodoxy

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

This session includes four papers spanning different time periods, cultures, and methodologies to explore new understandings within Orthodoxy. From hermeneutical reframings, to phenomenological interpretations, and theological insights to cultural heritage, this panel provides space for diverse topics to be brought into conversation around understandings of Orthodoxy and the types of thinking that can be applied to gain new insights around topics within Orthodox Christianity. 

  • Origen of Alexandria’s Appraisal of the Mosaic Law

    Abstract

    In this paper I will evaluate the reception of Mosaic Law (hereafter just Law) by Origen of Alexandria (c. 185 – c. 254 C.E.). Within in the polemics against “Christian heretics” and Judaism, Origen ascribed an important place to the Law preferring allegorical interpretation to the “heretical” and “Judaizing” approaches to the law, which included both rejection and literal interpretation.  Origen of Alexandria treated the Mosaic law on the one hand as relatively lower in value to Christian message while at the same time defending its divine origin and limited but continuing relevance. While a chronological evolution is apparent in Origen’s thought, I argue that there is a great deal of continuity in Origen’s view of the Law between the Alexandrian and Caesarean period.

  • Joban Prayers: A Maximian Contemplation of the Cosmic Job – Christ

    Abstract

    St. Maximus the Confessor states that "the mystery of the Incarnation of the Logos is the key to all the arcane symbolism and typology in the Scriptures." This project explores to what extent Maximian Logos/Logoi theology aids an inclusivist interpretation of the Book of Job within the Judeo-Christian Traditions. Joban scholarship is typically siloed to discussions of theodicy; however, the Scriptural account of a pagan saint is prophetic in content and provides a pedagogy for the religious 'other'. Applied theological structures include Maximian Christology and Mystagogy which is aided by Pope Gregory the Great's threefold spiritual hermeneutic in Moralia in Job. The exploration concludes that Christology and Job provide theological grounds for an inclusivist interpretation of salvation and hopes for further explorations in Patristic writings on Job.

  • Contesting Ontological Eastern-ness: Florovsky’s Neo-Patristic Synthesis as a Postmodern and Postcolonial Response to Orientalism and Slavophilia

    Abstract

    This paper contends that Orientalism and right-wing Slavophilia are based in the same colonial epistemology aimed to disentangle, legitimize, and hierarchize the sociopolitical categories of “East” and “West.” With this as a backdrop, I will propose a reading of Florovsky’s neo-patristic synthesis as a postmodern and postcolonial response to both, attempting to reconstruct a foundation for self-actualized Orthodox Christian identity neither in subjugation nor in contrast to Protestantism and Roman Catholicism. I will explore how this differs from a Slavophilic reading of neo-patristic synthesis, which I call “neo-patristic reactionism,” focusing on method and historiography. Lastly, I will discuss its implications for contemporary Orthodox ecclesiology and ecumenical relations, including an appraisal of its flaws and limitations.

  • Wounding Presence of Prayer in Orthodox Iconography

    Abstract

    As objects of devotion and veneration, icons invite the beholder to an encounter with the one depicted. But the presence an icon promises is grounded on a metaphysics of presence and absence, which, refuses stability or mastery and ultimately entails an essential difference between the icon and whom it depicts. In this paper I explore how phenomenology illuminates this encounter with the icon’s metaphysics of presence and absence. Drawing on Jean-Louis Chretien’s analysis of prayer, which explores the experience of presence and absence in prayer as both wounding and blessing, I argue that the traditional metaphysical accounts of the icon are amplified by consideration of how presence and absence is an experiential reality revealed in the prayerful encounter of the one depicted, an encounter that carries with it the possibility of wounds that bless.

A23-214

Theme: Esotericism, Ideology, and Violence

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

If esoteric religious practices are, by definition, "hidden," then who exactly do they exclude, and what are the social consequences of such exclusions? This panel examines the relationship between esoteric practice and violent ideology in three diverse historical and cultural circumstances. From the Middle Ages to the twentieth century, these panelists explore the interconnections between esotericism and discourses of universalism and traditionalism. These panelists demonstrate some of the ways in which esoteric discourses of prisca theologica and secrecy can and have led to intolerant and violent cultural formations. 

  • Esoteric Universalism and Crusader Evangelism in the Work of Ramon Llull

    Abstract

    Ramon Llull is an extraordinary figure both as a Christian apologist and as a collater of the various streams of knowledge that converged in medieval Spain. Predating Marsilio Ficino's *prisca theologia* by a few hundred years, Llull sought to chart the hidden unity amongst the Abrahmic faiths despite their apparent diffusion. This esoteric universalism is a theme of Western esotericism that runs through the present, with both benign and not-so-benign historical outcomes. While pointing out what is noble and in accordance with Christian truth in his Jewish and Muslim interlocuters, Llull advocated for further crusades on the grounds of his "Art". Influenced by intellectual historian Tomoko Masuzawa, this paper is a contribution to the dialogue on Euro-Christian universalism and its aftereffects, for better or worse. 

  • Embracing Evola and Glorifying Guénon: Traditionalism, Nationalism, and Orthodoxy among the Digital Far Right

    Abstract

    Drawing on ethnographic research and digital data collection, this paper considers the entanglement between the esoteric philosophies of Rene Guénon, Julius Evola, and Aleksandr Dugin and far-right nationalist ideologues. Utilizing case studies of digital content produced by American converts to Russian Orthodoxy (and its political framings), I tease out how philosophically intolerant, anti-modern conceptions of the body and person—proliferated through memes, podcasts, and video streams—are intimately tied to understandings of traditionalism, racism, and the disciplinary structures of political authority in the 20th century European context. I show that the project of traditionalism espoused on far-right social media is not linked to primordial truths but rather to the 20th century philosophical conceptions of what counts as modern, right, wrong, true, false, salvific, or damning. In doing so, I contend that traditionalism provides the vocabulary to help alleviate far-right anxiety about rapid social change, economic crisis, and shifting political dynamics.

     

     

  • Navigating Extremism and Esotericism: Savitri Devi and the Spread of Religious Eco-Fascism

    Abstract

    The proposed paper explores the complex relationship between esotericism, violence, and the far-right through the work and life of Savitri Devi Mukherji (1905-1982), also known as Maximani Portas and 'Hitler's priestess.' This critical discourse analysis focuses on her uniquely problematic ideology of violence which combines modern aryanism and radical Hindu nationalism with Malthusian 'deep ecology' and contempt for Christianity and Judaism. In doing so, I aim to highlight and contextualize her formative effect on violent international neo-Nazism and white nationalist politics, continuous from the mid-1960s onward. Through recently published data gathered from the digital *Savitri Devi Archive,* I follow her lasting global impact in spreading this antisemitic revisionist history (Figueira 2002). In addition, I also situate her influence within various contemporary esoteric, New Age, and environmentalist movements, especially through her religious eco-fascism which included devout reverence for Hitler, deified as an avatar of the Hindu god Vishnu.

A23-215

Theme: Maternal Agency and Choice: Raising Children in or against Religion/s

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

This roundtable explores maternal agency, choice, and children’s upbringing within or against religious frameworks. Although maternal agency (mothers’ ability to make autonomous decisions that shape their children’s lives) is a crucial aspect of parenting, it is significantly influenced by religious beliefs and practices on maternal agency. For many mothers, religion is a guiding force in shaping decisions regarding themselves and their children, from moral teachings to ritual participation and community engagement. For others, religion poses challenges, constrains their agency, and prompts questions about autonomy and freedom of choice. Contributors will share perspectives and empirical research on the dynamics of navigating the intersection of motherhood and religious norms within a framework centered on matricentric feminist approaches as they explore the experiences of mothers who grapple with the tensions between observing religious traditions and asserting autonomy in child-rearing in several religious contexts, past and present, including Antiquity, Christianity, Judaism, Buddhism, and Daoism.

A23-216

Theme: Reimagining Queer Existence: Religion and Resistance in African Contexts

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

This panel delves into the intricate interplay between queer existence and religion, examining intersections of identity, influence, and resistance within diverse cultural contexts. The panel discussion will be preceded by the screening of short clips from three queer-affirming African movies or a full movie from one of the options: "Inxeba" (John Trengove, South Africa, 2017), "Walking with Shadows" (Aoife O’Kelly, Nigeria, 2019), and "The Blue Caftan" (Maryam Touzani, Morocco, 2022). These clips will prepare the audience for a paper by Stefanie Knauss on the recent development of positive representations of queerness in African cinema, with particular attention to resistance both to anti-queer Christian and Islamic discourses as well as some of the assumptions implicit in Western models of queerness and sexuality. Questions and discussion to follow.

  • Imagining Gay Life in Africa: Contributions and Challenges of African Cinema

    Abstract

    In this presentation, I turn to three African queer-affirming films – Inxeba (John Trengove 2017), Walking with Shadows (Aoife O’Kelly 2019), and The Blue Caftan (Maryam Touzani 2022) – to investigate how they imagine gay life and love in Africa (specifically, in South Africa, Nigeria and Morocco), and what role religion plays in these visions. Drawing especially on African film studies, African queer theories and theologies, I argue that with their stories, the films challenge both African and western social and theoretical discourses on gay identities and relationships in several significant ways, contributing thus both to a new imagination of gay individuals as a part of African societies, and to the development of theories of sexual and gender identities that attend to the particularities of the African context.

A23-217

Theme: Moving Towards Abolishing Caste in North American Universities: A Roundtable with the University of California Collective for Caste Abolition

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

For many years now, campuses across North America have organized to fight for anti-caste protections. While fighting for anti-caste protections is important, it is only the first step that opens the door towards building caste competencies within North American academia, heavily entrenched in its anti-Black and white settler colonial foundations. Beyond the multicultural model, which seeks to incorporate caste as a measure of diversity, equity, and inclusion, the University of California Collective for Caste Abolition is invested in organizing for material and structural change within the UC system and beyond. In this roundtable, the UC Collective for Caste Abolition will share the history of its formation, and its current work and visions to illustrate how institutions across North America may heed the call and participate in the movement for caste abolition. might continue their activism toward caste abolition.

A23-218

Theme: Muslim Feminism, Decoloniality, and Tradition

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

The 2024 IGW session will be a non-traditional position paper session that aims to engender a conversation about the current state of women and gender studies in Muslim contexts past and present. We invited participants to engage with three broad themes: the study and practice of Muslim and Islamic feminisms, decolonial approaches as they intersect with Islam and gender, and the role of "tradition" and athority in the study of Islam and gender. Four scholars offer short position papers on the divine feminine between decoloniality and tradition, Muslim #MeToo, ordinary women as producers of Islamic knowledge and doctrine, and the reproduction of religious practice in Islamic law. The short presentations will be followed by a facilitated discussion with those in attendance at the session on wider repercussions of these papers and the direction(s) our field is moving in.   

  • Ordinary Women as Makers of Islamic Doctrine

    Abstract

    My position paper argues for the Islamic authority of ordinary Muslim women who are lost in the blur of a gendered everyday life in the home, dwelling at a remove from activities of the mosques and madrasas. I join feminist scholars of Islamic Studies in critiquing “ulama-ology” (cf. Dana Sajdi, 2013) i.e., the patriarchal politics of knowledge that privilege ‘ulama-led discourses written and uttered by men. I argue in my presentation for the role that diverse religious interpretations by ordinary Muslim women – i.e., women unlinked to Islamic institutions of mosques and madrasas, infantilized and silenced by men as ‘nāqiṣ al-‘aql’ (of deficient intellect) – play in shaping the meanings of texts and traditions in Islam. This demographic of Muslim women live an ordinary life performing gendered care and service work, and they make up the majority of Muslim women in the larger MESA region. I synthesize findings from my ethnographic research on women in Pakistan where ordinary Muslim women agentially create and transmit Islamic knowledge, particularly related to taboo aspects of sexuality and hygiene, situating these findings in the larger interpretive quest of locating feminist voices in the field of Islamic Studies.

  • Centering Rahma in Contemporary Islam— The “Divine Feminine” between Decoloniality and Tradition.

    Abstract

    What is the relationship between religious authority and power? In contemporary Muslim theology, women’s growing prominence as religious leaders appears to be related to an increased conceptual awareness around rahma, Divine Mercy, rahim, the womb, and al-Rahman, the God of Mercy. I trace this connection in the writings of prominent Muslim theologians and scholars and ask how and when it is leveraged to support new modes of Muslim religious authority and praxis. I argue that the feminist move towards the tradition represents a Muslim engagement with the global feminism debate and allows for gender-fluid and non-hierarchical readings of the Qur’an.

  • Ritual Obligation, Gender, and Reproduction in Islamic Law

    Abstract

    When it comes to the issue of patriarchal legal praxis in fiqh, Muslim feminist theory and praxis have remained in a relative stalemate. There are Muslim feminists who argue that Islamic law can be reformed and those who argue that fiqh is completely irredeemable. In this position paper, I draw on the work of autonomous Marxist-feminist scholar Silvia Federici to reconceptualize ritual obligations as a form of reproduction. Federici's conception of reproduction challenges classical Marxist thought on reproduction. Rather, Federici's work is an invitation to understand how knowledge, information, ideologies, and the materiality of daily life are forms of reproduction. Through Federici, I argue that thinking about ritual obligations as the reproduction of religious life requires Muslim feminists to think about what aspects of religious life they want to reproduce. As a result, they're better poised to do the work of dismantling patriarchal legal praxis in fiqh.

  • Muslim #MeToo: Towards a Decolonial Islamic Liberation Theology

    Abstract

    Islamic Liberation Theology recognizes that margins shift. The #MeToo Movement has been the locus of one such margin: the sexually abused. Focusing on iterations of #MeToo amongst Muslim societies, this paper finds that while both Islamic Liberation Theology and Muslim #MeToo are committed to the Islamic tradition, neither substantively engage Islamic Law, representative of a larger pattern within Islamic feminism. Additionally, analysis of the neoliberal discourse underlying the #MeToo Movement and how it has informed #Muslim MeToo responses is missing. This paper seeks to begin a conversation on these limitations, namely, the sidestepping of Islamic Law and inattentiveness to decolonial concerns. Instead of dismissing Islamic Law as irrational or irredeemably patriarchal, I argue that engaging its indigenous interpretive methodology (ʾuṣūl al-fiqh) addresses the decolonial concerns of external co-option and epistemic delinking, while providing an avenue for the Islamic Liberation Theology component of praxis inspired reinterpretation.

A23-219

Theme: Disability Ethics from a Catholic Perspective

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Mary Jo Iozzio's book Disability Ethics and Preferential Justice: A Catholic Perspective (Georgetown University Press 2023) is the mature work of a long-time scholar of theo-ethical reflection on disability. In it, Iozzio develops a theological lens for uncovering ableist assumptions and practices in both religious and secular contexts, while also drawing on Catholic social teaching to articulate strategies for deliberate action in the church and society at large. This panel serves to celebrate Iozzio's work and critically engage it from the perspectives of liberation theology, disability theology, and Catholic moral theology. Iozzio will be present to engage the other panelists and the audience in conversation.

A23-220

Theme: Author Meets Readers: Tom Oord's *The Death of Omnipotence and Birth of Amipotence*

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

In The Death of Omnipotence and Birth of Amipotence, Thomas Jay Oord argues that God's power is uncontrolling love. He claims that common understandings of omnipotence fail to fit Christian scriptures and die a death of a thousand qualifications when explored philosophically. Further, Oord believes that classic views of divine omnipotence make the problem of evil insoluble. Is Oord right, or does he exaggerate the case against omnipotence? Are there better ways to think about God's power? Featuring panelists who weigh in on issues of divine power, this roundtable session will also offer extended time for comments from the audience.

A23-221

Theme: Theodicies under suspicion

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

How might theodicies serve to mask and marginalize structural violence? (either tacitly or explicitly) “Theodicy” here works as a category for arguments that defend religious or metaphysical claims from contradictions based on events of the actual world. We have selected proposals that articulate a theodicy, and then critically analyze how it functions to justify structural conditions such as inequalities, civil violence, xenophobia, political structures, or disparities of health, education, etc. Proposals may work with typical sources (e.g. texts, scriptures) or less-conventional sources (e.g. oral traditions, social media, laws, etc.).

  • The Price of Providence: Central Banking and the Book of Job

    Abstract

    This paper considers an economic dimension of theodicy as a legitimating discourse: reconciling the tension between a sovereign's ultimate power and yet inability (or their ultimate benevolence and yet refusal) to intervene into a system of distribution and valuation to create justice. It begins with a theo-political reading of the Book of Job, linking the text's insistence on (divine) sovereignty as the sole basis of wisdom and justice with Modern Monetary Theory's contentions in debates over the role of the Federal Reserve. The specter of Job is raised again with Hobbes' Leviathan: in the attempted 1611 monetary renovations of James Stuart, we observe an ostensibly 'divinizing' monarch perform uncharacteristic impotence before the demands of foreign markets, in which the cost of re-capitalizing domestic market liquidity is effectively forced onto the bearers of base-metal currency. 

  • The “Partial Theodicy” of Donna Haraway’s Chthulucene

    Abstract

    Theorists of ecological crisis privilege concepts of ambiguity and partiality as simultaneously truer to material realities andmore politically and ethically promising. Taking Donna Haraway’s Chthulucene concept as a case study, this paper asks if this move successfully avoids theodicy. Though Haraway defines the “time-place” of the Chthulucene in opposition to the salvific logics of theodicy, her celebration of ambiguity emerges from a reading of ecological breakdown as the source of a renewed vision of entanglement. In other words, ecological crisis becomes an opportunity to materialize a reformulated best-case scenario. I argue that Haraway’s attempt to circumvent theodicy recapitulates its errors: naturalizing loss and assigning a silver lining to structural violence. I call this persisting logic of theodicy a “partial theodicy.” 

  • ‘Transnationally Asian’ Theodicies: Troubling “Social Formations” in Transpacific Counterpoetics

    Abstract

    In this paper, we explore political theodicies in “transnationally Asian” literatures after 2010. We claim that the literary cultures of these transpacific networks and communities constitute what Yunte Huang calls a “counterpoetics” that attempts to challenge what Gary Okihiro calls the “social formations” that shape the power structures of transpacific arenas. Herein lies the theodicy: we argue that these transpacific counterpoetics also have trouble naming the powers that constellate these social formations. We move across three literary cultures: military apocalypses arising from Korean diasporas, geopolitical tensions in Sinophone and Vietnamese communities, and ecological disasters circulating from the Fukushima subduction earthquake in Japan. Our paper contributes to the global critique of political theodicies by showing in the transpacific region that evil might be seen in the wounds of war and disaster, but naming what exactly inflicts this violence is difficult – and generates even more pain in its indeterminate articulation.

A23-222

Theme: Re-membering the Pioneers: Honoring Feminist and Womanist Practical Theologians

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Early womanist and feminist practical theologians passed on their legacies to later generations. This session honors some of these trailblazers through storytelling, recollections, research, and personal encounters. The session is not only retrospective as we look back to these ground breakers, but the discussions will be prospective as participants plant forward-thinking seeds of thought and praxis. Together, we can enrich the landscape of practical theology with a high-yielding and verdant future.

A23-223

Theme: Pragmatism and Empiricism in American Religious Thought Unit and Transformative Scholarship and Pedagogy Unit Papers Session

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

.

  • Deepening Belonging: A Call to Radical Spiritual, Cultural, and Political Transformation

    Abstract

    This paper addresses the urgent need for developing pedagogical practices that cultivate relationality, openness, and conscientização amidst what Henry Giroux (via hooks and Freire) has named as the current rise of political authoritarianism, anti-intellectualism, fascism, white supremacy, and the assault on critical education and pedagogy. Through the lens of "Deepening Belonging," a co-created contemplative practice by two educators of color, we explore how nurturing of belonging and relational flourishing can serve as foundational to democratic education. Rooted in the Latin American tradition of Convivencia, this practice embodies values such as mutual respect, adaptability, open-mindedness, and collaborative learning, offering a counter-narrative to the individualized, outcome-oriented, competitive, and consumerist paradigms often prevalent in educational settings. By fostering spaces for compassionate listening, deep witnessing, and embodied ritual-making, "Deepening Belonging" not only challenges oppressive structures through spiritual awareness but also nurtures the capacities necessary for creative democratic engagement and civic participation. 

  • Dialogic Classrooms as Pathways to Democratic Habits in Uncertain Times

    Abstract

    What happens in the world happens in our classrooms: post-truth claims, polarizing discourses, silencing, legislation designed to limit or prohibit the teaching and learning of specific ideas, students who are still learning to navigate social and scholarly realities after years of Covid isolation.  These challenges are not just academic.  What happens in our classrooms will happen in the world, and though higher education has long been conceived as a space where students learn the skills vital to a thriving democracy, current conditions make the creation of such spaces feel tenuous or even impossible.  This paper presents Dialogic Classrooms as one approach that equips our students to engage authentically and civically across differences such that they are able to cultivate the skills and habits necessary for robust and active citizenship, even under pressures that work against such vital engagement. 

  • Navigating an Us and Them Society

    Abstract

    Contemporary society is deeply divided along cultural, regional, religious, racial, and socioeconomic lines. What is more, these forms of division are intertwined with growing levels of political sorting and polarization. If not checked, extreme polarization and sorting can be highly destructive to democratic culture and structures. My presentation utilizes material, assignments, and processes from a course as well as a student organization that teach students strategies for navigating the polarized environment.

A23-224

Theme: Indigenous Plant Medicine, Sacred "Psychedelic" Healing, & Restorative Reparations

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

In critical studies of Indigenous medicine, sacred plants, ethnobotany, and "psychedelic" hallucinogens, this panel explores how Indigenous sacred plants and medicinal knowledge been commodified to create modern medicine (e.g. psychedelics). What have been the costs for Indigenous peoples and how have they been persecuted for medicinal plant usage? Noting sacred plants' commercialization among non-Indigenous communities, how have locals fought against this knowledge theft and resource extractions? Presentations examine the "psychedelic renaissance," allopathic medicine, psychedelic holding practices, Western exploitation of Mazatec sacred mushrooms, and how to center voices such as curandera María Sabina to interrogate possibilities for reparations of commodified Indigenous sacred medicines.

  • Honguitos at the Doctor’s: An Indigenous Perspective on the Medical Use of Psilocybin

    Abstract

    The “psychedelic renaissance” has forced questions of cosmology to the foreground in allopathic medicine. Where they would have otherwise been treated as incidental, mystical experiences have suddenly become central to treatment. While providers attempt to build effective protocols for the use of chemical agents like psilocybin, foundational medical literature continues to dismiss the Indigenous practitioners from which these agents were expropriated. This paper will look to Mixteca wisewoman Maria Sabina’s traditional practices as a standard, using a ritual-focused framework of relationality to evaluate current protocols for the allopathic use of psilocybin. By comparing traditional Indigenous and allopathic practices, I will argue that skillful engagement with cosmology is prerequisite for effective work with psilocybin. In line with recent calls to respect Indigenous traditions, I will close by suggesting serious amendment for allopathic medicine’s current mode of engagement with plant entheogens and derivatives such as psilocybin.

  • The Separation of Spirit and Wellbeing?: Core Questions and Practices for Psychedelic Healing

    Abstract

    The salient inquiry offered in the call for papers invites reflection on the constellation of psychedelic medicine/medicalization, culture, and spirituality (as differentiated from religion) and relationship among them. At the heart of this constellation is the relationship between healing and spirituality. In this paper, we will explore four forms of psychedelic holding practices: administrators/distributors, sitters, assisted psychotherapists, and curanderos. Each of these four forms require different skills, qualities of presence, spiritual partnerships and pair with different medicines. As we move forward in our collective awareness and capacity, it is not sufficient to lump all consciousness medicines under the single umbrella of “psychedelics” if we are to be clear on our intention for working with them, the setting in which they are administered, and the skill set required by the practitioner for safe and effective use—whether for spiritual growth or healing of suffering.

  • Respecting the Sacred Mushroom: The Initiation and Magico-Religious Healing Practices of María Sabina

    Abstract

    In 1957, Gordon Wasson published an article called “Seeking the Magic Mushroom” in Life magazine where he described his ecstatic experiences in a healing ceremony led by the indigenous shamaness María Sabina. In doing so, Wasson revealed the millennial secrets of the Mazatec shamanic tradition to the Western world. The article led to foreigners invading Huautla de Jiménez—a poor, small and remote town in the mountains of Oaxaca—in search of God. They disrupted the daily lives of the locals and profaned sacred mushrooms by failing to respect Mazatec customs and rituals. Later in her life, Sabina lamented introducing Wasson to her ancestral practices. This paper introduces the audience to the initiation and magico-religious healing of María Sabina to contextualize her critique of foreigners’ use of sacred mushrooms. It argues that centering Sabina’s voice provides a basis for conversations about reparations for exploitation of indigenous sacred medicines.

A23-225

Theme: Queer Memories: Religion and the Politics of the Past

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

This panel explores the intersections of queerness, memory, and religion. How do queer religious individuals or communities make memories? How have traditional religious pasts been queered in memory and memorials? What resources do queer studies in religion offer to the study of religion and memory? Through ethnography, comparative literature, public art, and theology, these papers explore the politics and religion of queer memories.

  • Experiencing Queerness and Catholicism: LGBTQ+ Stories about the Catholic Church in Flanders

    Abstract

    This presentation explores the experiences of LGBTQ+ individuals in Flanders concerning the Catholic Church based on oral history research conducted with 17 interviewees. The current welcoming initiatives of the Flemish bishops, along with the strong Catholic heritage of the region and its history of support for LGBTQ+ individuals, render this context exceptionally intriguing. This presentation highlights two key findings. Firstly, individuals interviewed can be categorized into three groups based on their current stance towards the church: those rejecting it entirely, those who have gradually secularized, and those who firmly identify as Catholic. Secondly, the interviews reveal that people’s sense of inclusion or exclusion from the church is significantly influenced by their image of ‘the church’, shaped by memories of upbringing and past life experiences. Consequently, the presentation concludes that achieving an inclusive church necessitates a profound shift in personal perceptions, extending beyond changes in teaching, practice, and leadership.

  • Precarious Memories of Precarious Time and Bodies: Reading Oyuki Konno, *Maria Watches Over Us*

    Abstract

    As a “memorial” literary text that queers the religious past (and present), this paper explores a Japanese (juvenile) novel series, Maria Watches Over Us (1998–2012), by Oyuki Konno. This work can be interpreted as a literary resource for creatively remembering the ambiguous desires of adolescence, erotic and otherwise, especially within the context of religious education. In this work, female students maintain diverse forms of intimacy with one another—from very close “friendships,” a somewhat polyamorous yet hierarchical “sisterhood,” to lesbian romantic relationships—at a fictional girls’ Catholic school. Through a close reading of the text, this paper argues that Maria Watches Over Us “queers'' the past and present of a religious educational milieu in the Japanese context (and beyond). This study concludes by utilizing Foucault’s theory to emphasize the importance of (re)visiting both the comfort and discomfort that arise from the ambiguities of sexuality, relationality, and religious imagery. 

  • Constructing Coalitional Memories Where Religion, Race, Gender, and Nation Collide

    Abstract

    This paper looks to queer feminist authors and activists for insights about coalition-building amidst ongoing traumas stemming from structures of coloniality. M. Jacqui Alexander’s theory of palimpsestic time, Aurora Levins Morales’ focus on narrating histories of interconnection, and artist/activist JeeYeun Lee’s organizing will frame an example of coalitional activism in 2021 that re-enacted memories of disputed Indigenous land rights in the same location as the 1983 Parliament of World Religions. Attending to the entanglement of racism, sexism, religious supremacy, and settler colonialism shows how identities, histories, and even city structures hold the legacies of violence that continue to persist today. I argue that re-narrating histories that focus on the intersection of religion, race, gender, and nation can move decolonization from a metaphor to a practice. Both trauma and spirituality, in different but interconnected ways, show how the past must be acknowledged as embodied in the present.

  • A Queer Ecclesiology: Tradition as Embodied Memory

    Abstract

    This paper constructively synthesizes Paul Tillich’s theology, Christian Danz’s pneumatology, and Judith Butler’s theory of performativity. The synthesis demonstrates how both Christianity and gender/sexual identities can be regarded as embodied forms of communication in which memory plays a constitutive role, recasting tradition and memory as synonymic within an ecclesiastical context. Moving beyond Tillich and Danz, this paper makes clear the dynamic and interconnected relationship between memory, gender/sexual identity, and God through the role of ontology. By re-framing identity through a queer-memory model of ecclesiology, this paper proffers that through memory both gender/sexual identity and Christian identity are constructed in communities that orient us through tradition (received meaning). Therefore, it contends that memory takes on an ontological function – tradition shapes our understanding of being – one that can free Christian communities from heteronormativity's gender essentialism, which problematically concretizes not only the gender binary but also conceptions of God.

A23-226

Theme: Noah’s Arkive: A Roundtable Book Panel Discussion

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

To reflect on climate catastrophe, writers and artists often turn to biblical tellings of Noah’s ark. In _Noah’s Arkive_ (University of Minnesota Press, 2023), Jeffrey J. Cohen and Julian Yates brilliantly examine lives and afterlives of the ark story with ecological attention. “The brute sketchiness of the biblical injunction ‘make yourself an ark’,” they write, “demands that its readers think hard about the difficulties of preserving a community against deluge, about who gets included and who excluded, about how the threat of the flood is experienced differently by varied groups of people and animals.” This session assembles a transdisciplinary ark of its own to respond and think-with Cohen and Yates. With biblical scholars, queer and feminist theologians, scholars of religion, ecology and society, this session hopes to explore the possibilities this book may provoke for religious studies, ecotheology, and the environmental humanities. The authors will offer a response.

A23-227

Theme: Religion, Migration, and Human Rights Activism in a Time of Hardening Borders

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

Presenters in this session will examine religious thought and practice in situations where borders are violently guarded, the rights of migrants (and others) often brushed aside, and democratic norms come under attack. The papers explore diverse forms of religiously-inflected activism that arise under situations of significant human rights violations. The first paper uses a Christian ethical lens to examine rights across borders when strict ideologies of sovereignty diverge from facts on the ground. The second considers how gender-based rights violations in immigration detention arise out of the context of detention itself. The third elucidates the role of religion in undocumented Filipino Americans’ activism to resist violence in the immigration enforcement system. And the fourth considers how religious actors and scholars have acted across borders to resist manipulation of historical memory, advocating for both democratic norms and the rights of migrants and the most vulnerable.

  • Double-Crossed: Rethinking Filipino American Faith after Crimmigration

    Abstract

    As many as 370,000 Filipinos live in the United States without legal status. Under the Trump presidency, their daily lives were plagued by fears of state violence in the forms of incarceration and deportation. Despite his promises, President Biden has not succeeded in changing U.S. immigration policies. Seizing on a crisis at the Southern border, nativists have continued to depict undocumented immigrants as “illegals” who are a danger to American society, even though empirical studies have consistently shown otherwise. In this paper, I examine the lived realities of undocumented Filipino Americans in order to challenge assumptions about their Christian faith and ethics. By situating their decisions historically and sociologically, I show that they are not only victims of largely-hidden legal violence, but that their communities offer important contributions to the work of nonviolent resistance.

  • Gender-based violence in immigration detention centers

    Abstract

    Based on religious scholarship of “micropractice,” I demonstrate how immigration detention work produces violence. Through examination of incidents of gender-based violence in immigration detention contexts across history–from ships moored off the California coast to modern private prisons–I show how workplace micropractices culminate into incidents of gender-based violence.  Through methods of control, surveillance, and humiliation, those involved within the immigration system learn how to treat immigrants that they encounter; if you spend every workday demeaning immigrants, what is one more personal act of degradation? I propose that in order to end gender-based violence within the immigration system, and the violence of the immigration detention system itself, we must look not just at the religious ideologies that support xenophobia, but also the ritual practices that sustain it.

  • Religion’s Influence on Memory Activism for Democracy: Korean American Diaspora Activists and the Remembrance of a Pro-democracy Uprising in South Korea

    Abstract

    This paper investigates religion’s ongoing contribution to the transmission of the memories of the May 18 Uprising, a historic South Korean pro-democracy uprising against the authoritarian Korean government, and the generation of new multi-racial activist networks in the U.S. Based on qualitative research and drawing from feminist and womanist theo-ethical frameworks on memory, I examine the role of religion in three sites of social memory: haunted bodies, political art, and religious networks. In these three sites, the Christian religion and the Korean spiritual traditions preserve the memory of the movement and regenerate its radical spirit. I argue that such a confluence of religious traditions provides fertile ground for mobilizing resources for cultivating transnational democratic (political and cultural) belonging. More broadly, my presentation invites conversation on how religion uniquely contributes to keeping memories of progressive social movements “alive” for a liberative and decolonial democracy.

  • The Border and the Wound: Rethinking Rights in Times of Toxic Westphalianism

    Abstract

    The particular intersection of the novel and the unchanged in today’s relations between borders, sovereignty, and migration—which can be called “toxic Westphalianism”—represents both a moral challenge and an opportunity to rethink rights with respect to violations of migrant rights in border spaces. In light of the history of Westphalian sovereignty, in which nonhuman considerations were excluded, theological elements were sublimated, and non-European territories were colonized, the examination of borders as systems of exclusion renders visible elements that can be brought together in challenging but promising ways. The situation demands Christian ethical attention, both as a moral concern and because of Christianity’s ambivalent historical relationship with sovereignty. Such attention facilitates rethinking rights in terms of encounters that ramify across wider social relationships. This account of rights does not occlude the universalism that typically accompanies assertions of rights so much as deploy it within specific acts of contestation or resistance.

A23-228

Theme: Diagnosing Digital Archives: New Theories and Methods for Studying Religion Online

Saturday, 12:30 PM - 2:30 PM

How do we deal with the ever-evolving nature of digital religion and its many expressions? The papers in this panel all grapple with how to build, assess and derive new insights from digital archives. Authors consider the in-built biases of computational analysis and newspaper databases, how we manage digital archives created by religious organizations, and digital objects that manage affect around racial reckoning.

  • Decelerating Digital Archives: Critical Reflections on Computational Analysis

    Abstract

    This paper thinks critically about the violence of digital archives and computational methods by engaging with the role they play in the erasure and flattening of marginal communities, advocating for a deceleration of digital archives. I place my methodological pitfalls from a computational project against the important theoretical work of archivist Dorothy Berry, art historian Jennifer Roberts, and scholars engaged in a post-colonial study of religion like Saba Mahmood and Tomoko Masuzawa to demonstrate the urgency of deceleration to prevent the further disenfranchisement of marginal communities. Reflecting on a computational project I conducted using Seventh-day Adventist periodicals on religious liberty from 1886 to 1919 to analyze positive rhetoric about the Catholic Church, I describe how my project and its shortcomings serve as a low-stakes example of the power in decelerating digital archives, and I use it to speak to the much higher stakes of digital work that involve marginal communities.

  • Digital Archives: Popular Monastic Media in Thailand

    Abstract

    Media related to monks in Thailand provide much material for assembling digital archives. This presentation describes the use of monastic media within Thai popular culture to create two digital archives: 1) pictures of famous monks from temples and practitioners meant to generate faith, and 2) social media images of monks engaged in inappropriate behavior. I describe the process of selecting the photographs for these archives, and my research process, which involves collecting opinions and feelings from lay Buddhist focus group participants. In analyzing the opportunities and challenges of this methodology, I argue that archives derived from popular culture constitutes a way to easily receive comments and feedback from participants, providing a snapshot in time of a religious field, and a way to visually represent a research topic. I also look to future challenges creating a home for a publicly accessible digital archive of Buddhist monastic aesthetics.

  • Grief Reminders when #BlackLivesMatter

    Abstract

    This paper examines grief within white Christian discourse about antiblack violence in the United States. Drawing from Sara Ahmed’s notion of affective economies, the paper tracks how grief—or an absence of grief—surfaces and conceptualizes “grief reminders” as a pastoral practice of affective conditioning and realignment. I argue that “grief reminders” occur when a faith leader identifies grief as both a necessary response to loss and as a theological and ethical imperative for the proper practice of faith. The paper interrogates how grief reminders work as affective scripts and relate to white Christian understandings of human personhood and grievable life. Methodologically, the analysis of digital artifacts undergirding this paper raises questions about how digital media is implicated in the circulation of religious affect and how religious scholars, and theologians in particular, can engage digital archives in their study of lived religion.

  • Fragmentary Accounts of a Popular Religion: Newspaper Reports and the “Zalma Angel” of 1895

    Abstract

    In the late nineteenth century, newspapers around the United States documented the emergence of many “new religious sects.” These movements were so pervasive that newspapers began to compile and joke about them for popular entertainment. Unfortunately, many of these groups have gone unrecorded by scholars due to the lack of archival materials. Using the 1895 “Zalma Angel” as a case study, this paper probes the utility of newspaper databases as a source for studying this trend within popular culture and the limitations built into the creation of these archives. Based in rural Missouri, the fragmentary accounts of the “Zalma Angel” movement varied considerably. From ridicule to limited descriptions, the circulation of details and tone of the reporting outlined normative American religious sensibilities. As a case study, the “Zalma Angel” demonstrates the limits of studying historical popular religion and the role that newspapers played in selectively constructing and obscuring fringe religions.