You are here

Online Program Book

This is the most up-to-date schedule for the 2023 AAR Annual Meeting. If you have questions about the program, contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org. All times are listed in Central Standard Time.

Karen LeBacqz was one of the first women in the field of American bioethics, serving on the first Presidential Bioethics Commission under Jimmy Carter, writing the Belmont report, the National Commission on Human Subjects, serving as an advisor to the projects in biotechnology, stem cell research, and the Human Genome Project, and publishing six books, among them Six Theories of Justice and Justice in an Unjust World.  She was instrumental in structuring some of the first policies to regulate science, and critical to advancing theological arguments within our field.  As a professor at the Graduate Theological Union, she taught a generation of scholars, stressing always the need to foreground questions of justice in bioethics. Yet, her work is relatively unknown in comparison to the men with whom she served: Callahan, Jonson, Englehardt, Brody, Gaylin,  and Jameton. This panel will reflect both on her contributions to the field and think carefully about the question of how and who is central to our developing canon.

This panel explores how religion intersects with brain-machine interfaces, neuroenhancement, and related technologies. Analyzing advancements in AI technologies, embodied cognition, and psychology, panelists will delve deeply into questions about bioethics, identity, agency, and moral responsibility raised by these technological prospects.

  • Abstract

    Emerging neurotechnologies combine neuroscience with AI to collect and interpret human brain data, connect brains to machines or other brains, and modify neural functions. This paper explores questions about human and individual identity, agency, and moral responsibility raised by these technological prospects. From a Protestant Christian standpoint, these questions are addressed in light of two biblical and theological themes: the image of God and the body of Christ. The *imago Dei* is understood “performatively”: not so concerned with defining humanity as with “actively *seeking* humanity” (Alistair McFadyen) where the humanity of some is placed in doubt. In dialog with Dietrich Bonhoeffer, I argue that a faithful performance of the *imago* will enact the vision of human sociality offered by the metaphor of the body of Christ: one of mutual interconnectedness without loss of identity, in which agency and responsibility can be shared and mutually supported without being lost or obscured.

  • Abstract

    In this paper I will explore the use of computer brain interfaces (CBIs) for moral enhancement. One of the types of enhancement that will be discussed is a reduction of violence. However, this raises questions about control and free will, so while there may be solid philosophical reasons to prohibit requiring this kind of moral enhancement, there may be compelling theological reasons why people might choose voluntarily to do so. The concluding section will focus on the relationship between moral enhancement and virtue. While there is not universal consensus, there does seem to be some agreement amongst scholars that using gene editing for moral enhancement cannot engineer virtue. The question posed here is whether CBIs and their use can bring about virtue, or if they simply allow people to act more morally. My tentative answer is that this is more complicated of an answer than with gene editing.

  • Abstract

    The ability to connect and exchange information facilitates the work of God. For many liberal theological traditions, this is the primary way God works in the world, through people and their relationships. The love of God is communicated through speech-acts among created beings. Consequently, in the postmodern conext of the Network Society and Information Age, theological interaction with technologies like brain-machine interfaces tends toward an affirmation of enhanced communication. Anything that may enhance our ability to connect honors our created nature as relational beings and the work of God in the world. Theologians generally recognize the importance of embodiment and the importance of embodied autonomy. Jeanine Thweatt, for example, suggests a contextual, compassionate somatic ethic that asks, “what can this body do? And what does this body need?”[1] Theologians affirm embodiment, but particularly in light of brain-machine interfacing, what matters about the particularities of embodied information and its flow?

  • Abstract

    This paper is concerned primarily with brain-computer interfaces (BCI) and the potential for harm when we seek more intimate communication and relationships through this emerging technology. Specifically, the theological insight of Thomas Aquinas and the philosophical work of Stanley Cavell are taken up to help us better understand our desire for community, the limitations of that desire, and the psychological violence that follows our crashing up against these limitations. It is argued that a goal of BCI technology for unadulterated communication and relationship is not only likely to fail but even be a source for psychological torment. The closer we as humans come to the inner life of others, the more we are faced with our perpetual separateness—a separateness that leads to violence both internally and, in extreme cases, externally. Such violence not only informs the current development of BCI in relation to disability but broader hopes for enhancement.

#CarltonPearson, #Pentecostalism, #BlackTheology, #RadicalInclusion, #ChristianUniversalism, #BlackChurch

The late Bishop Carlton Pearson was an extraordinary religious figure by almost any measure.This roundtable will consider how Bishop Pearson as a sonic and visual performative figure transgressed racial boundaries; how Pearson’s embrace of universal salvation might be situated within the Black radical tradition, and perform a type of Black radical constructive theology and liberative praxis more readily associated with Black, Womanist and Queer theologies; how Pearson’s Pentecostal consideration of Black suffering sparked the largest and most widespread theological rebuke of his ministry via the Joint College of African American Pentecostal Bishops suggesting Pentecostalism’s reliance on Black suffering for forms of order, theological normativity, and respectability; and finally, how Pearson mastered media performances of piety, even in death.

This session will explore varieties of antiBlack violence, and the viablity of Black theological imagination in response. Considerations will range from scripture to slave rebellion; spiritual violence in the Black churches and the violence of ideological conscription in the contemporary Movement for Black Lives. Special attention will be given to the complex dialectic of hopelessness against hope amidst the flesh and blood realities of Black life.

  • Abstract

    Prior to the decline of BLM, scholars who attempted to embrace group differentiation and resist capital engaged in genealogical ideology critique. Keeanga Yahmatta Taylor argues that BLM should aim for liberation while Christopher Lebron argues that BLM is based in a tradition of equal dignity that values racial progress. Although liberation is a desirable goal, Taylor’s rich historical account avoids proposing it as a method. Cone's black particularity offers ways to use Taylor’s differentiating aim as motivation, not merely a teleology, and politicize Lebron’s appreciation of dignity. Locating a multi-causal account of liberation in particular practices eschews ideological capture by providing chocolate for the water in which protesting publics swim; that is, particularity for ideology. This paper argues that black particularity illustrates a practice of existential discovery that resists ideological conscription. Cone views radical practices that employ collective rage and grief as more meaningful than the instigation of such processes. 

  • Abstract

    Despite expanding the theological frameworks of embodiment, sexuality, and incarnation, the reality is that the inner logic of particular Black Church spaces requires or invites communal violence as a conduit to receive the work of God’s action in the world. Stemming from a broader exploration of the impact of exposure to religious violence on African American Millennials and Generation Z in Black Church spaces, this paper attempts to explore the sociopolitical and theological implications of practices of violence within the ecclesiology of the Black Church. Using results from a digital ethnographic analysis and interviews from Black gender and sexual minorities who experienced religious violence and trauma within Black Church contexts, this paper seeks to explore how explorations of Black ecclesiology must engage in trauma-informed and healing-centered theoethics to stop the occurrence of religious and spiritual violence within the Black Church spaces, specifically with Black gender and sexual minorities. 

  • Abstract

    The notion that Jesus was a nonviolent leader must be critically reexamined in a theological context.  A lack of written evidence of Jesus perpetrating violent acts does not mean he lacked violent intent. In fact, in his trial and his conviction for being the King of the Jews implies violent intent but, however, was unsuccessful with the insurrection. Similarly, Denmark Vesey, an insurgent against slavery in the United States, led a failed attempt insurrection and was tried and sentenced to death for his intent of violence. Using Denmark’s story as the methodology, this paper argues that Jesus attempted to instigate a violent insurrection, but did not succeed, resulting in his death for “treasonous” acts against his oppressor. If, according to Black Theology, God is on the side of the oppressed and Jesus’s liberation from Roman oppression could have involved violence, should a liberation theology support freedom through violence?

  • Abstract

    In this essay, we examine a contemporary religious movement, The Gathering: A Womanist Church that is centered around a theology of justice in action with an emphasis on a broad-minded belief system. These religious movements are intentionally less focused on doctrinal statements and correct beliefs for assimilation. Instead, this new movement is within the tradition of religion in action: the act of fighting for justice is the doctrine. We contextualize the dialectics of Black nihilism and Black theology through an appeal to the absurd in the face of hope.We argue that Black theology provides avenues to hope through a dialectic with Black nihilism. Black theology is one answer to Black nihilism. In turn, Black nihilism is a response to a failed Black theology of the past. Contemporary Black religious movements are a response and have made an epistemological and ontological turn to real notions of hope, meaning, and love.

The participants in this roundtable all agree that minority perspectives yield new insights into biomedical enhancements, particularly when persons are vulnerable to health disparities, including persons with disabilities, and persons of color. The presenters for this round table come from different denominational backgrounds and represent different minority perspectives and they bring those perspectives to bear on questions of bioenhancement.
Each presenter will briefly (5-7 minutes) highlight how they have come to evaluate particular bioenhanmcent technologies using insights from their religious traditions and minority communities. Presenters will describe how their theological methods and ontological suppositions reflect on the distinctiveness of human creatureliness in relation to technology and what difference bioenhancement might make for our conceptions of vulnerability.

Theme: Mind and Body

The foci of this panel present multifaceted thoughts by medieval philosophical viewpoints and neuroscientific discoveries on Mind and Body. These viewpoints and neuroscientific discoveries help us understand the path to spiritual fulfillment across Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and Christianity, which are based on various geographical locations within South Asia and major European civilizations, especially Roman and Greek. The first paper is about Buddhist, Jain, and Hindu views on the perfect and imperfect body and contemporary practices of the body. The second paper explores eligibility and ineligibility of mind and body in medieval Digambara Jainism. The third paper addresses some interesting neuroscientific discoveries on the relationship of mind and body that could be drawn from Christian practices.

Bodies can be envisioned in a multitude of ways that simultaneously help and hinder the religious imagination and experience: the flesh of a fat body reimagined as absently thin in the afterlife, the digital and simultaneously enfleshed body in the Zoom box, the malleable yet rigid embodiment of transness. This panel brings together five papers to think through the interconnection between bodies considered to be “other” and the associations of both violence and beauty that attend othered bodies. Based in theories of the body, this panel strives to envision bodies within religious spaces and identities that work through both positive and negative processes of enfleshment.  

  • Abstract

    Since the first century, some Christians have brought dead bodies back to life through prayer. While hardly ubiquitous, dead-raising is part of the supernatural landscape of Pentecostalism and evangelicalism. According to William Seymour, leader of the Azusa Street Revival, Jesus commanded it. This paper explores dead-raising around Bethel Church, a charismatic evangelical California megachurch with international influence. I argue that dead-raising offers scholars a rich, albeit unnerving opportunity to examine our frameworks for studying time, death, and religious bodies. When the dead rise, the forward march of time is reversed. Moreover, dead-raisers argue that the imperishable resurrection bodies of the distant future—the “eschaton”—become available now such that nobody has to die, full stop. To examine dead-raising is to pursue the breadth of Christian supernatural practice and Christians’ always shifting engagement with death. It is to resist burying the sources of our discomfort in the religious worlds we study.

  • Abstract

    According to Euro-American discourse, fat people, and fat women in particular, lack a future. Not only are fat persons more likely to die prematurely, fatness presents as a threat to the future of the nation comparable with Covid and the climate crisis. Within this narrative, fatness emerges as a ‘biopolitical problem’ (Evans, 2009) that takes shape in the present through the futurizing of fatness. Lurking behind such dreams of a fat-free future is a set of misogynist and racist assumptions as well as the entrenched fat phobic belief that fat people, especially women, are disposable. However, such a futurizing of fat is also resourced by Western Christian ideas about eschatological bodies. Through an engagement with Augustine’s presentation of fatness and future heavenly bodies, I explore how the theological futurizing of fat can incentivise a hearty celebration of fatness, opening up history to alternative possibilities to the fat-shaming present.  

  • Abstract

    The Christian hope for the future body is of perfection on the other side of resurrection—but what does embodied perfection entail? Many people in Christian faith communities share the assumptions of modern Western culture, uncritically absorbing and reproducing its stigmatising assumptions and body-shaming practices. This shapes their expectations of what the perfected resurrection body might look: slim, beautiful, and non-disabled. I will use a multi-layered account of identity to propose that the continuity of identity-forming embodied features is required to safeguard the continuity of identity through the transformation of resurrection. While we must admit a modest agnosticism regarding the actual outcome, the possibility of persons with disabilities and bodies of all sizes, shapes, and colours flourishing in the new creationchallenges our underlying assumptions about what bodies are good bodies. I will argue that human flourishing lies not in aesthetic flawlessness but in the fulfillment of the body’s *telos*.

  • Abstract

    This paper explores how racialized and gendered meaning-making occurs online by engaging feminist theorists in phenomenology, digital anthropology and biotechnology. This paper then considers the pedagogical implications of how the virtual bodies of women of color are located, perceived, and acted upon in the virtual learning landscape of theological education. These understandings are crucial to the application of engaged pedagogy in the virtual leaning landscape. Recognizing that to show up as one’s full self is to become vulnerable to violence, this paper concludes with an invitation to pedagogical promiscuity, an embodied learning approach that aims toward liberation for all learners.

  • Abstract

    In Alberta, Canada, current Premier Danielle Smith banned bottom surgery for transgender youth, despite the fact that no kids have received bottom surgery. Smith’s policies create the trans youth body as a site of panic and of parental control. “Body” and “flesh” are laden with Christian history, which marks some bodies as sinful and claims flesh as the defining characteristic of family bonds. Read through Hortense Spillers and the incarnation, flesh becomes a site of generative possibility, of interdependence. Interdependent flesh persists where the legal and normative family fails, allowing the wild creativity of gender diverse children to flourish as part of queer community.

“Single Mothering as Critique and Vision,” is a roundtable session on single mothering as an ethical, theological, philosophical, and historical act from which to challenge contemporary systems and theories of social reproduction and to imagine alternatives. We ask what it means to single mother under white supremacist heteropatriarchy and capitalist ableism. Single mothering serves as a binary breaker against the hierarchies constructed under contemporary systems of social reproduction: mother/whore, straight/queer, independent/dependent, mature/immature, able/disabled, and productive/unproductive. Hence, rather than the single mother representing lack, we offer theological, theoretical, and religious visions of single mothering as a force for more just approaches to social reproduction. Scholars have long pointed out the gendered, raced, and classed dynamics of care labor, and offered alternative visions of family. However, lacunae exist in terms of single mothering as a theological, theoretical, and political frame. This roundtable addresses this absence.

Despite impressive accomplishments, CSR has been constrained by being wed to cognitivists models of the mind. 4E approaches, especially enactive cognition, bring cognitive science into meaningful partnership with cultural, historical, and phenomenological studies, reintegrating these disciplines with psychology and biology, presenting a path toward a more comprehensive study of religion. This roundtable panel’s starting point is a Religion, Brain, and Behavior symposium on John Teehan’s article, “Toward an Embodied CSR: Enaction, Evolution, Emergence,” that makes a case for integrating 4E approaches into CSR. It brings together two scholars who employ 4E cognition in their work (and who contributed to the RBB symposium), with two scholars who take a more cultural studies approach (but who also address cognitive models of religion) into conversation with the author. The article is a jumping off point for a larger discussion of the potential contributions, and limitations, of integrating 4E cognition into the study of religion.

The papers in this session engage Bonhoeffer's thought in relation to politics and various political theology discourses, including secularism and Christian nationalism; queer theory; global and racial capitalism; whiteness, fascism, anti-racism, and anti-Semitism; and retributive justice and violence.

 

  • Abstract

    Focusing on competing understandings of the kingdom of God, this paper contrasts the political theologies of German pastor/theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer and American senator Josh Hawley. The paper traces the connections between Bonhoeffer and Hawley’s visions of the kingdom of God and their political choices. While Bonhoeffer’s interpretation of God’s kingdom informed his costly repudiation of Christian nationalism in his context, Hawley’s interpretation bolstered his unwavering support for Christian nationalism in his context.    

  • Abstract

    Despite their very different contexts and styles, there are some striking resonances between Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s late theology and Jack Halberstam’s The Queer Art of Failure (2011). On the one hand, Bonhoeffer proposes a “view from below”, claiming that “suffering is a more useful key, a more fruitful principle than happiness for exploring the meaning of the world in contemplation and action.” On the other hand, Halberstam develops queer theory as “knowledge from below”, which can assist with countering “the logics of success that have emerged from the triumphs of global capitalism.” In this paper, I bring Bonhoeffer’s reflections on suffering and weakness into conversation with Halberstam’s insights into failure. Specifically, I explore how Halberstam’s work might help to supplement and radicalise some of Bonhoeffer’s reflections in his late theology.

  • Abstract

    In contemporary soteriological discourse, several voices have raised the concern that atonement theologies that assume divine justice has a retributive element end up justifying violence.  Though this may be the case in some instances, Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s theology and ethics present a more complicated picture.  While Bonhoeffer presumed retributive justice was operative in God’s saving work in Christ, this never resulted in an outright justification of his work in the resistance. 

  • Abstract

    This talk addresses the religio-racial transformation of “the whiteness project” through the machinery of antiracism and anti-antisemitism. It turns to the mid-twentieth martyr-theologian and ethicist Dietrich Bonhoeffer, glimpsing this machinery in his late writings to imagine a postfascist Western future. That future entailed subjecting Jewishness to whitening, thereby figuring Jews no longer as targets (traditional supersession) but now agents (a new supersessionism) of Christian (post)colonial empire. This is Bonhoeffer’s unwitting renewal of “the religion of whiteness” (W. E. B. Du Bois), where in its distinction from and yet relation to “white people” whiteness is a locution for planet-wide racial capitalism. Imagined now as racially “plastic,” Jews are hailed into the West’s civilizational project while Jewishness becomes a site for Western post-Holocaust self-renewal. With the term “Judeo-Christianity,” I sketch how this maneuver works in Bonhoeffer’s Ethics to illuminate the religio-racial terms of the present, including the current crisis in Palestine.

The papers in this session explore Bonhoeffer's theological legacy in relation to various aspects of theological education, including decolonial methods, theological formation, and pastoral care.

  • Abstract

    This paper describes the experience of teaching Bonhoeffer in Oceania from the perspective of Pacific Theological College in Suva, Fiji, and in turn, the influence of Bonhoeffer on pedagogy and methodology. The paper uses this context to interrogate contemporary issues in contextual theology, dialoguing with Jione Havea’s important chapter, “The Cons of Contextuality…Kontextuality” (2011). It then describes some emerging Pasifika theologies that centre relationality with land and ocean, identifying some resonances with Bonhoeffer’s key notions of sociality, Christocentrism, and ethics of responsibility.

  • Abstract

    Writing about the “changing landscape of theological education” is nothing new; in fact, it has constantly been changing through various stages over the past millennia. While his context was different, Dietrich Bonhoeffer also experienced a highly structured system on one side and rapid (and deadly) change on the other. His book Life Together details his experiment in intentional communal theological education, and his writings on theology and spiritual care demonstrate what is at stake for the Church in contemporary society, especially among those at the margins. This paper traces Bonhoeffer’s theological and pedagogical insights to offer proposals for the future of theological education, focusing on embracing innovation with humility, prioritizing relational pedagogy, engaging contextually and prophetically, and fostering lifelong learning and vocational discernment.

  • Abstract

    Bonhoeffer's seminary at Finkenwalde has sometimes been referred to as an experiment in Protestant monasticism.  His lectures on Pastoral Care, reconstructed from his outlines and surviving student notes make clear that he believes that Gospel-centered pastoral care requires both intellectual and spiritual formation to achieve its task.  For Bonhoeffer, psychological distress comes from a human sin that prevents an individual from hearing the Gospel, and identifying this sin is the primary task of pastoral care. Bonhoeffer also attempts to differentiate pastoral care based on what seems to be a polemical portrait of psychoanalysis. This paper explores the usefulness and limitations of Bonhoeffer's focus on theology and how it might be enriched by greater dialouge with psychological sciences and medicine.

This co-sponsored session examines various dimensions of the legacy of Bonhoeffer’s political theology and ethics.  Bonhoeffer’s theology emerges in dialogue with contemporary theory, Bonhoeffer’s own Lutheran contemporaries, or the work of Martin Luther himself. Papers in this session offer new perspectives on Bonhoeffer through the lenses of Moral Injury, dialogues with the Black Pentecostal Tradition, earthly love poetry in the Song of Songs, and Martin Buber’s personalism.

  • Abstract

    In “Moral Injury and Human Relationship,” Michael Yandell explores the many layers and scales of responsibility in the waging and fighting of war. After locating himself as a US veteran and reviewing core literature in the study of moral injury, which is yet only in its nascence, he draws on Bonhoeffer’s account of conscience and shame to offer substantive theological engagement with more clinical definitions. Against the backdrop of the growing understanding of moral injury and Yandell’s theological response that draws upon Bonhoeffer’s theology, this paper will reverse the hermeneutical flow to explore how moral injury might be a helpful category for understanding Bonhoeffer’s theological moves most nearly associated with his decision to join a conspiracy. These include the claim that “everyone who acts responsibly becomes guilty,” his preference for concreteness over abstract principles, and his notions of “free, responsible action” with hope for only a “relative sinlessness” in Christ.

  • Abstract

    In this paper, I analyze the underlying logics of Bonhoeffer's view, found in Letters and Papers from Prison and Ethics, that the church can enjoy a clean break from injustice through prayer and confessional practices. I do so first by engaging the work of Ernst Käsemann, who offers a post-war critique of clean break thinking in light of the German Church’s ongoing entanglement with white supremacy. I then turn to the the Black Pentecostal Tradition, and its own confrontation of white supremacy through tongues speech, to develop an account, in conversation with Bonhoeffer and Käsemann, of the type of prayer that might confront white supremacy in our day and accomplish Bonhoeffer’s desire for the church to one day regain the authority to speak liberative and redemptive words evoking those spoken by Jesus.

  • Abstract

    Though a student of Harnack, Bonhoeffer did not shy away from figural exegesis since his early period. He approached Genesis 1-3 from a theological perspective and interpreted the Psalms as Christ's own prayers. However, during his time in prison, he began to affirm earthly love by turning to the Song of Songs, a book traditionally interpreted through the lens of the love between Christ and the Church or believers. In a later letter, he even told Bethge that reading the this book as an earthly love poem was ‘probably the best “Christological” interpretation’.(DBWE 8, 410.)This affirmation of earthly love from the standpoint of holy scriptures and Christology is uncommon in Christian theology. So why could reading the Song of Songs as an earthly love poem be considered a Christological interpretation, and even the best one? This paper aims to explore Bonhoeffer’s exegetical logic behind this fragmented reflection.

  • Abstract

    Although the German title of Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s prison letters—Resistance and Submission [Widerstand und Ergebung]—suggests a direct reference to political activity, it actually comes from his reflection on two ways to confront one’s “fate.” “I’ve often wondered,” he writes in a 1944 letter to Eberhard Bethge, “where we are to draw the line between necessary resistance to ‘fate’ and equally necessary submission.” This essay situates Bonhoeffer’s remark within the frequent references to “fate” [Schicksal] among German theologians working between 1919-45, including Emanuel Hirsch and Werner Elert. It then shows how Bonhoeffer creatively engages with the question of fate by retrieving Martin Luther’s concept of social realities as “masks” of God, an insight that leads him to adapt his personalist philosophy. Finally, I demonstrate how Bonhoeffer’s treatment of fate is related to his disavowal of tragedy, both in his Ethics and in an unpublished note from the archive.

This roundtable presents recent and ongoing research on Buddhism in the land that is now known as Australia. It will consider: historical and contemporary complexities of racial and religious diversity; cultural norms regarding religion and spirituality in Australia; the multicultural governance of diversity in Australia; the impact of Australia’s geographical positioning; and transnational flows of religion and culture in shaping Buddhism in Australia. The presentations examine 1) preliminary findings from the first nationwide study of Buddhism in Australia; 2) the use of digital media by Buddhist youth to negotiate religious belonging, visibility and identity; 3) triangulated flows of religion and culture among Indigenous, White-Australian and Asian immigrants in the Far North of Australia; and 4) the influence of Buddhism on deathcare practices in Australia. In doing so, we identify emerging insights about Buddhism in this overlooked region, and bring these into conversation with scholarship on Buddhism in the West.

Buddhist Studies has increasingly attended to what Helen Jin Kim characterizes as the “transpacific turn,” namely the transoceanic cultural flows through which Buddhist identities and communities are constructed. In situating their subjects within multiple transoceanic imperial contexts, these papers orient contemporary Buddhists within modernist frameworks that disrupt a simple West/East binary. Paper 1 re-examines the fault lines of the disciplinary boundaries of Buddhism in the West to draw out various subaltern Buddhist modernities. Paper 2 utilizes an ecological and colonial studies framework to consider the ecological consequences and neocolonial limitations of Tibetan nāga practice in North America. Paper 3 situates Shaku Sōen’s discussions on Buddhist notions of social equality within anti-colonial solidarity and imperialist projects

  • Abstract

    This paper explores the historically and ethically ambiguous nature of Buddhist notions of social "equality." The Japanese-American True Pure Land priest Yemyo Imamura (1867–1932) identified Buddhism's supposed commitment to caste equality as crucial to its flourishing in a multi-ethnic democracy. The paper focuses on the experiences of Zen master Shaku Sōen (1860–1919) on Sri Lanka under British colonial rule to investigate the genealogy of Imamura's claim. Sri Lankan Buddhism, Sōen argued, fostered inequality along lines of race and caste, undermining social cohesion and abetting the colonial regime. Japanese Mahāyāna Buddhism, in contrast, was predicated on equality and provided the basis for a liberatory anti-colonial politics. Ironically, Sōen's Mahāyāna was based on the apologetics of Singhalese Christians such as James de Alwis (1823–1878), and soon declined into ideological support of Japan's own colonial ambitions. This history throws into doubt Buddhism's capability of generating a robust notion of "equality."

  • Abstract

    While the Buddhism in the West Unit of the AAR may at this juncture be tempted to re-brand as a Global Buddhism(s) Unit, fittingly inspired by the capacious intellectual space created by the esteemed *Journal of Global Buddhism*, there is a risk of glossing over important fault lines and subsuming our usual “problem space” (to borrow from the anthropologist David Scott) into the same framework, simply enlarged. There are indeed dynamic delineations in the Buddhist world that are worth thinking through, such as majority/minority religion and caste/casteless/subaltern Buddhism, all of which intersect in creative ways with socio-economic status, issues of inter-generational transmission or lack thereof, and, of course, geographical contexts saturated with history. Building on prior scholarship, I draw out the distinctively subaltern modernism of Black Buddhists in the U.S. and the U.K., and suggest that India is in fact the site of a paradoxical “Wild West” of contemporary Buddhism.

  • Abstract

    Despite their localized nature, North American Tibetan Buddhist communities have begun adapting indigenous Tibetan mountain deity (yul lha) and nāga (Tib. klu) practices to the American landscape. This article will explore some of the potentials and limitations of transplanting place-based religious practices through two lenses: ecology and colonialism. It will begin by analyzing several examples of how Tibetan Buddhists in North America are adapting these practices yul lha and nāga practices to the North American landscape. It will then think through some of the positive ecological consequences of North American nāga pūjās and consider how indigenous Tibetan approaches to sustainability may be imported alongside these religious practices. Finally, this article will think through the complicated dynamics of a diaspora community populating their new landscape with imported religious deities and consider the neocolonial limitations of nāga practice in its ability to work towards socioecological justice.

The panel aims to explore how early South Asian Buddhists utilized languages, embraced, and critiqued Brahmanical language theories, developed their own theories of language, and achieved literary innovations through multilingualism. We will examine the practical and theoretical aspects of language as understood by the early South Asian Buddhists. Individual presentations will encompass topics such as the stage of fluid Middle Indo-Aryan languages and their role in the formation of Buddhist canons. We will reconsider the fluidity of the MIA texts and the process of linguistic standardization in light of intellectual reflections on the nature of language in commentarial and scholastic texts, as well as associated knowledge of languages (Abhidharma, grammar, etymology, etc.) Additionally, we will seek to understand how regional and transregional languages functioned in their cultural historical contexts, allowing the textual traditions to establish transregional connections and contribute to the formation of local literary, religious, and political identities.

  • Abstract

    One topic that has long sustained the interest of Buddhist studies scholars and historians is the advent of writing in South Asia and the early written transmission of Buddhist literature. Now that we have a large body of evidence from the Gandhāran Buddhist literary tradition, which provides the earliest extant material witnesses of Buddhist manuscripts, we can begin to ask new questions about a Gandharan scribal or literary culture. What might the regional forces have been just before and after the turn of the common era that led Buddhists to write down their texts in Gandhara? What role did Gandhara’s unique language and script (Gāndhārī/Kharoṣṭhī) play in developing its own scribal culture? Given the important role of language in the identity of different Buddhist communities, can we identify in Gandharan Buddhist materials anything like a Gandhari Buddhist language politics?

  • Abstract

    I aim to explore Yogācāra texts reflecting the Buddhist history of Sanskritization. In the northern Abhidharma and Yogācāra literature, the term vyañjana means alphabet syllable or letter for constituting expressions of Buddhist teachings. Commentators on the Abhidharmasamuccaya (AS) state that vyañjana consists of 42 arapacana syllables regarded as originally formulated in the region of Gandhāra. Following the definition of vyañjana in AS, however, the Yogācārabhūmi explains 48 alphabet syllables used for formulating Sanskrit expressions. This change reveals the Sanskritization and the Brahmanization that Yogācāra confronted and accepted. Yogācāras modified their attitude toward Sanskrit and adjusted the Buddhist terminology in accordance with the vocabulary in the Sanskrit grammar. Moreover, Yogācāra did not limit their curriculum to the Buddhist doctrine and discipline but included Sanskrit grammar, mathematics, and astronomy of the Brahman tradition. My presentation will show that the examination of Yogācāra literature helps us widen our knowledge of Sanskritization in the Buddhist tradition. Furthermore, I will also argue that Indian Yogācāra commentators in 6th C.E. were aware of this Sanskritizaiton earlier Yogācāra confronted and documented this awareness.

  • Abstract

    The Vedic knowledge form of semantic derivation is an indigenous commentarial method widely embraced across the Buddhist and Brahmanical traditions. These religious traditions utilized this method to elucidate their sacred texts, investing significant effort in reconfiguring the explanations to support their religious theory and practice. This paper delves into the diverse explanations found within the Gandhari commentaries, Pali texts, and Yaska’s Nirukta. It highlights how Buddhist texts in South Asia inherited these interpretations and showed traces of early sources in the Middle Indic forms. In the instance where a noun can be explained in a way that contradicts its current contextual usage, Buddhist commentators elaborated extensively in their commentaries to reconcile such contradictions. The study demonstrates that Buddhist semantic derivation has a longstanding tradition predating the early commentaries, consistently aligns with an underlying Buddhist ideological framework, and reflects an underlying understanding of the stable relationship between sound and its referent.

  • Abstract

    Across Buddhist literary traditions, texts are often rewritten and repurposed. Multiple tellings of stories appear in a range of forms, excerpts of certain texts are interpolated into others, editors expand and contract sources, and translations abound. This paper asks what Buddhists are doing when they engage in such practices, and with that, what revisions can reveal about South Asian Buddhist theories of language. A close, comparative reading of three related texts serves as the basis for exploring a few of the ways Theravāda Buddhists have utilized language creatively, both to bring entirely new texts into being by altering the language of earlier texts, and also to re-imagine and re-present other texts by engaging with language’s surplus of meaning.

This omnibus session showcases work by newer scholars in the field of Buddhist Studies. Papers address two common themes: Buddhist landscapes and children in Buddhism. Topics include contesting the ‘decline’ paradigms of Indian Buddhism by attending to built landscapes, autogenous phenomena (or rangjön) and monasteries as pilgrimage sites in Tibet, quiet and pure sensory experiences on Mount Putuo in contemporary China, the soteriological capacity of children in medieval China, and contemporary Japanese lay Buddhist childcare programs in the Tendai tradition.

  • Abstract

    This paper challenges the prevailing notion of an abrupt termination of Indian Buddhism in the thirteenth century CE. It does so by examining material culture from archaeological contexts of identified Buddhist monasteries in the Magadha region. The paper primarily relies on the data collected during a systematic village-to-village survey conducted during 2021-22. In addition, a variety of textual and epigraphic sources have also been used to reconstruct the social and political context of the region during the long period between the eleventh and seventeenth century CE. The study of changes in both continuity and discontinuity in the Buddhist landscape of Magadha after the alleged decline offers a unique insight into the medieval history of Indian Buddhism in the region.  Through this micro-regional approach, the study provides a nuanced perspective on the history of diverse religious traditions in eastern India, contesting the ‘decline’ paradigms surrounding Medieval Buddhism in India.

  • Abstract

    As one of Central Asia's most popular pilgrimage sites, Ganden Monastery in Tibet is renowned for the autogenous phenomena (or rangjön) found along its circumambulation route. These rangjön depict deities and other phenomena thought to have spontaneously and miraculously manifested in the rockface. The goal of this paper is to describe the significance and function of Ganden's rangjön. Analyzing pilgrimage guide texts related to Ganden, it argues that rangjön are complex phenomena that are best understood as both material and discursive constructions with implications in the social, religious, and geographic spheres. And that the presence of rangjön represents a method by which a manmade monastery became a sacred place, one that then played a key role in the growth of the Tsongkhapa devotional cult and the rise of the Geluk tradition. As a corollary, I argue for the thus far overlooked importance of monasteries as pilgrimage sites in Tibet. 

  • Abstract

    This paper examines qingjing, a Chinese expression referring to the quiet and pure sensory experiences, in contemporary Mount Putuo, the abode of Guanyin (a compassionate deity) in China. While existing studies have focused on red-hot sensory experiences and sociality in Chinese contexts, this paper emphasizes qingjing as a sensory experience that is opposite to red-hot but ideal in Chinese religious life. Through ethnographic fieldwork, this paper argues that qingjing is based on the presumably strong efficacy (ling) of Guanyin and Mount Putuo to respond to visitors’ wishes and related to a reverse sensory experience: xianghuo (incense fires). Though seemingly contradictory, qingjing and xianghuo both represent the efficacy of Guanyin and Mount Putuo and thus constitute each other. This paper specifies three logics: qingjing in the “absence”, “complementation”, and “distraction” of xianghuo. Beyond the perspective of sociality, this paper contributes to the general understanding of sensory experiences in Chinese religious life.

  • Abstract

    In Buddhist thought, do children have the capacity to attain enlightenment? Or are they bound by their ignorance, unable to ascertain the Dharma until they develop a certain level of discernment? This paper examines concepts of children’s ritual efficacy and soteriological capacity in medieval Chinese Buddhist miraculous tales and hagiographical accounts from the third to tenth centuries CE.  It considers in what circumstances, in what capacities, and for what purposes children appear as religiously agentive in accounts of Buddhist practice in medieval China. Reflecting indigenous Chinese concepts of biophysical and moral development, medieval Chinese Buddhist miraculous tales and hagiographical accounts ascribe ritual efficacy and soteriological capacity to children from roughly six-years-old (seven sui 歳) onward. By exploring portrayals of children’s religious practice in medieval Chinese Buddhism, my paper invites scholars in Buddhist studies to reconsider how historical and cultural notions of childhood shaped basic tenets of Buddhist thought.

  • Abstract

    This paper examines contemporary Japanese lay Buddhist childcare through a case study of the Tendai-derived lay Buddhist organization, Kōdō Kyōdan, and its childcare programs. Against the backdrop of Japan’s low birth rate, Kōdō Kyōdan established its three childcare programs at its headquarters in the city of Yokohama at the turn of the 21st century to address demographic concerns at both the national and organizational levels. Drawing on ethnographic research conducted since 2018, this paper explores lay Buddhists’ understanding and practice of hōshi (serving) in their relationships with the religious organization, family, and society in the context of public caution against religious proselytization. This paper argues that by reflectively responding to societal and organizational expectations, the childcare staff members at Kōdō Kyōdan negotiate their religious and social identities in a dynamic context marked by changes in their parent religious organization and in Japanese society at large.

This panel considers how Buddhist texts display an awareness of their audiences and—relatedly—seek to take agency in their own reception. A common trope in Buddha-biographies, emphasized in discourses on "skillful means," is the Buddha's ability to anticipate the needs of his audiences and adapt his profound teaching to their terms. Working from a range of perspectives, our panelists demonstrate how Buddhist texts themselves incorporate subtle techniques for engaging their audiences, often at the level of affect, from depicting idealized audiences in-text to providing explicit rubrics for preachers. Others, meanwhile, use powerful affective cues to create certain kinds of audiences, distinguished by their feelings on certain matters. While recent literary scholarship has begun to consider the strategic roles Buddhist texts take in their reception, this panel reveals an awareness and creative engagement with the concept of audience to be the fundamental yet neglected element underlying these diverse pedagogical operations.

  • Abstract

    This paper presents an intertextual reading of the _Concentration of Heroic Progress_ and the _Precious Banner Sūtra_ toward uncovering how these Mahāyāna sūtras invite their audiences to receive them. I argue that whereas the _Concentration_ presents itself as possessing unmediated soteriological power, the _Precious Banner_ exchanges such power for status as a normative authority to which response is necessary. To make this argument, I focus on the stories of Māra told in these sūtras. As Lamotte noted in his translation of the _Concentration_, pointing to the “conversion of Māra,” these sūtras share thematic features. What Lamotte seems not to have noticed, however, is that these stories of Māra are mirror images of one another. This paper, then, follows up on Lamotte’s note to show that these sūtra share a discernible intertextual relationship and that the shared inverted narratives of Māra reveal how these texts want to be received. 

  • Abstract

    This paper considers what the _Lotus Sūtra_’s emotional depictions of its own, in-text audience tells us about how it intends to be received and ritually embodied by its readers. As a _sūtra_, the _Lotus_ recounts a sermon delivered by the Buddha to an audience of disciples, frequently shown responding to him with intense expressions of joyous assent. The Buddha, meanwhile, explicitly encourages such affective responses in passages such as the “Chapter on the Merits of Responding with Joy.” This metatextual feedback loop, I argue, both influences reader response, aiming to provoke similar feelings in the reading present, and foregrounds expressions of joyful affect as crucial to Buddhist soteriology: a perspective corroborated and practically elaborated by medieval Chinese ritual texts such as Zhiyi’s _Lotus Samādhi Repentance_. Overall, this paper suggests how the _Lotus Sūtra_’s metatextual strategies—and their ritual elaborations—contributed crucial yet overlooked affective dimensions to East Asian Buddhism.

  • Abstract

    Guided by Susanne Mrozik’s exploration of virtue as an embodied phenomenon in South Asian Buddhist traditions, this paper attends to the corporeal specificity of human beings in Buddhist literature. However, rather than focus on the relationship between virtue and living bodies, I would like to direct our attention instead to the corporeal specificity of dead bodies—and how the idea of consuming those bodies signifies a threat to the consumer’s humanity. In this paper, I argue that early Buddhist texts promoting vegetarianism mobilize the shocking image of the cannibal in order to make arguments to their audiences about the permeability of one’s identity. I hope to show that attention to the themes of cannibalism invoked in some of the most influential early vegetarian _sūtras_ can help us better understand how the acts of consumption—both consuming and being consumed—signify a fundamental loss of humanity within these texts.

  • Abstract

    This paper explores how Buddhists and Buddhist texts envision the relationship between themselves and their audiences by examining the comments Shi Huijiao 釋慧皎 (497-554CE) made in the last two sections of his _Biographies of Eminent Monks_ compilation. It looks closely at the role of the scripture chanters and recitation guides in teaching and the qualities they should possess, as discussed by Huijiao in his comments. It argues that for Huijiao, touching the hearts of the audiences is at the core of the relationship between texts/teachings and audiences. His emphasis on touching the heart as the scripture chanters' and recitation guides' most effective pedagogical means to reach the soteriological transformation of the audiences, with both their voice and their content, highlights the Buddhist deep understanding of human emotions and resonates with the teaching tradition of the Buddha and those who speak for the Buddha in India and beyond.

Justin Henry's _Ravana's Kingdom: The Ramayana and Sri Lankan History from Below_ (OUP, 2023), shortlisted for the AAR Best First Book in the History of Religions 2023 prize, offers an innovative study of the reception of the Ramayana, the famed Hindu epic, among Sri Lankan Buddhists spanning from the medieval period to the present day. Three panelists will offer critical perspectives on the position of _Ravana’s Kingdom_ amid the theoretical spectrum of the History of Religions discipline, Henry’s engagement with "many Ramayanas" at the margins of the Indic world, and the relevance of the book to ongoing issues of interreligious antagonism and interreligious cooperation in Sri Lanka. The panel will contextualize _Ravana's Kingdom_ alongside other recent monographs marrying rigorous, text-critical philological research with theoretical interventions related to contemporary "lived religion," populist movements, and religion and politics.

Yunnan Province, located in southwest China, has long been a hub in transregional Buddhist networks. However, it has received less scholarly attention than Silk Road sites and maritime routes. This panel’s four papers demonstrate Yunnan’s significance as a place for encounters between different forms of Buddhism and Buddhists of different backgrounds, with a focus on political themes in the late imperial period (1368–1911). Each paper uses a specific case study— Xitan Temple, the Yongle Buddhist Canon, an _abhiṣeka_ ritual text, and the _Săpº kammavācā_—to foreground a different encounter zone that connects Yunnan to Tibet, the Ming (1368–1644) court, middle-period South and Southeast Asia, or Theravada Southeast Asia. The papers draw on diverse sources in various scripts to reveal different facets of Buddhist encounters in Yunnan. The panel shows the benefits of treating Yunnan as a whole, rather than separately addressing Sinitic, Tibetan, or Pali forms of Buddhism.

  • Abstract

    This study looks into how Xitan Temple 悉檀寺, located on Chicken-foot Mountain (Ch. Jizu shan 雞足山; Tib. Ri bo bya rkang), facilitated material, human, and ritual encounters between Tibetan and Chinese Buddhism. Drawing upon the Sixth Zhwa dmar Chos kyi dbang phyug’s (1584-1630) pilgrimage account, Xu Xiake’s (1587-1646) 徐霞客 travel diary, temple inscriptions, and mountain gazetteers, this paper examines the ways in which Mu Zeng 木增 (Tib. bSod nams rab brtan, 1587-1646), a Naxi Chieftain who governed the Lijiang (Tib. ‘Jang Sa tham) area in northwestern Yunnan, played a critical role in Mt. Jizu’s transformation into a sacred site by patronizing both Tibetan and Chinese Buddhism. This will shed light on the power dynamics among different ethnic groups in Yunnan, and how this influenced decisions on the religious market.

  • Abstract

    The Ming Court probably bestowed seven sets of the Yongle Northern Canon to areas in Yunnan. In one case, the Wanli Emperor (r. 1573–1619) issued a decree to present the canon to Huayan Temple on Jizu shan in the fourteenth year of Wanli (1586). His mother, Empress Dowager Li (1545–1614), issued a decree the following year that imperial court would exempt 1284 _shi_ 石of grain-tax from the local people (almost equal to 65,736 kg of rice) to bring prosperity to the country and blessings to the local people. This paper examines the Ming court’s bestowal of the Yongle Northern Canon in Yunnan to analyze the relationship between the Imperial Court and the border province in the southwest and to explore why the court disproportionately favored temples on the sacred Buddhist mountain Jizu shan. One purpose was clear: to consolidate the border region and to protect the empire.

  • Abstract

    This paper nuances the dominant view that the Buddhist kingship of the Dali kingdom drew upon the Sinitic teaching of the _Humane King_. It does so by calling attention to a group of unstudied Esoteric Buddhist ritual manuals for the consecration (Sk. _abhiṣeka_; Ch. _guanding_) of the Dali rulers and by showcasing the ideal of divine rulership embodied in the final part of the ritual. I argue this section is modeled after the enthronement part of the Hindu kingship ritual _pratiṣṭhā_, through which the king reigns as an incarnation of the Buddha. Such a merging of the king and Buddha in one person was never attained in the _Humane King_ model but constitutes a parallel with the Hindu-inspired _buddharāja_ (Buddha-king) ideal in contemporaneous Southeast Asian Buddhist kingdoms. In drawing the parallel, this paper advocates repositioning Dali in a cosmopolitan world consisting of the synchronous pursuit of an Indian-inflected divine kingship.

  • Abstract

    Bilingual Pali-vernacular versions of the Vinaya, including the core Pātimokkha rules and their ritual framework, are some of the most widespread forms of monastic exegesis in the Theravada world. These bilingual compositions, or bitexts, typically follow an interphrasal format, in which Pali words or short phrases are followed by expanded glosses in a local vernacular. As part of a broader inquiry into how bitexts shaped Buddhist translation across mainland Southeast Asia, this paper focuses on a single Pali-Dai example of the Pātimokkha from early modern Sipsongpanna (today’s Xishuangbanna Autonomous Prefecture in Yunnan province, China). This paper compares this text—preserved in facsimile form as part of the massive _Zhongguo beiyejing quanji_ project—with other manuscripts in Laos, Cambodia, Myanmar, and Thailand to reveal how the translation choices made by Dai scholars—into Dai as well as into Chinese—made the Pātimokkha respond to local conceptions of scriptural authority and temporal power.

Anthropologists of Buddhism encounter marginalia constantly, from scribbled notes in a book or the smudge of pigment in a ritual manual, to figurative ducking in and out of the crowd at a possession event. Despite being far from young, the stunted development of the sub-field within Buddhist Studies is partly attributable to a pejorative view of this ethnographic project as the marginal scribbles to Buddhist Studies’ normative text critical and philological work. Heeding Gellner’s (1990) and Sihlé and Ladwig’s (2017) calls for an ethnographic, comparative, and inter-textual Anthropology of Buddhism, this panel brings together interdisciplinary scholars situated across the Buddhist world working towards a rapprochement of text and context by drawing on both these disciplines. Each paper plays with, trespasses, and reconstitutes boundaries by openly thinking through Buddhist Studies’ diverse marginalia, questioning the outmoded binary of text-primary and ethnographic approaches.

  • Abstract

    Ethnographic writing is what anthropologists do. But interlocutors? This paper develops a response to intellectual projects encountered in the field that come uncomfortably close to the ethnographer's own terrain. By engaging with these intellectual projects on their own terms, I argue that Buddhist Studies offers models for the anthropologist of Buddhism to better approach textual cultures of expertise and intellectualism. Likewise, ethnographic engagement offers opportunities for Buddhist Studies to expand the scope of intellectual practices, especially who gets to count and how. Instantiated through reference to para-ethnographic writings and my own fieldwork on domesticity within Newar Buddhist cultures of expertise, I offer a methodologically plural and dialogical approach that emphasizes the complexity and perplexity of any iteration of a text or performance of an interlocutor.

  • Abstract

    This research shows the practical importance of abhiññā (supernatural powers) in the Southeast Buddhist tradition. As a contemporary example, I focus on a Burmese Buddhist meditation technique formulated by the Burmese monk Pa-Auk Sayadaw (1934-). Supernatural powers, though acknowledged as one of the Buddha’s and Buddhist saints’ venerated qualities, have been marginalized as an unorthodox practice unessential for Buddhist liberation. Similarly, in Myanmar, the exhibition of supernatural powers has been suppressed as animistic magic by the government during the nation-rebuilding time. The devaluation of the practice is still evident after different Buddhist meditation techniques of Burmese origin became popular worldwide. The Pa-Auk meditation technique teaches supernatural powers to all practitioners as elective but requires it for prospective meditation teachers. I examine how teachers and practitioners understand the values for the true path through my observations and interviews with them at different branches of the Pa-Auk meditation centers since 2018.

  • Abstract

    What might lay-Sri Lankan Buddhists who engage in charitable giving to the poor as merit-making practice and American convert-Buddhists who engage in mindfulness practice to explore racialized dukkha share in common? They both consist of Buddhists practicing the Theravada tradition in vernaculars that depart widely from the normative philological evaluative take on what does and does not constitute “real” Theravada Buddhism. Thinking comparatively on ethnographic research conducted in these widely different socio-historical contexts, this paper explores how as an anthropologist, the Buddhist social life exemplified by these two contemporary case-studies— often relegated to the marginalia of what counts as real Buddhism—surface an important problem in the field of Buddhist Studies. Namely, the tendency to judge contemporary Buddhist vernaculars against a canonically based conception of orthodoxy. On a more personal note, the paper also explores the complexities of being an ethnographer and a native “Buddhist” studying contemporary Buddhist marginalia.

  • Abstract

    In the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, hagiography (rnam thar) is a vast and popular genre of literature that tells the life-stories of Buddhist figures. Although hagiographic literature itself points to a complex relationship with oral narratives, scholars tend to categorize hagiography as written expression that is both stylized and distinct from history. This paper examines two ethnographic accounts of the life of a religious master – one oral history given by a 25-year-old lama and another account by his teacher. The lama presents a life that is filled with self-doubt, non-religious desires, and fatigue with his position. His teacher presents a narrative of miracles, extraordinary signs and an exaggerated educational history. This paper examines oral history as a dialectic process between intersubjective interlocutors, suggesting that by understanding this dialogic process we must rethink the stability of the hagiographic text and imagine the narrative interests of hagiographic-ethnographers of the past.

  • Abstract

    This paper looks at chanting, marginalia, and intertextuality in the making of Myanmar Buddhist nuns, preparing them for the government monastic exams. I demonstrate the need to understand both Buddhist texts themselves and how these texts are used, shaped, practiced, and in turn how these processes influence Buddhist knowledge communities. I find that understanding marginalia and chanting is instrumental in understanding the changes that have occurred in the transfer of knowledge within the last few decades. Without the observation, participation, and the questioning of teachers, students, and their methods and practices, we would only see scribbles on a page with no context.

  • Abstract

    This paper explores the often-overlooked phenomenon of spirit possession, in the Kathmandu Valley, among Newar Buddhist women, known as dyaḥmāṃ. Despite their integral role in local Buddhist practices, their practices, as those of other spirit mediums in the Buddhist world, often find themselves at the margins of what gets to count as Buddhism. Drawing on ethnographic data and vernacular texts, this paper challenges the dichotomy between possession and Buddhism, arguing that possession is a vital aspect of Buddhist practice rather than its other. By examining collaborative rituals between dyaḥmāṃ and Buddhist priests, the paper demonstrates how possession traditions are deeply intertwined with mainstream Buddhist beliefs and ethical norms. Additionally, it advocates for a more inclusive approach to Buddhist studies that incorporates vernacular texts and ritual perspectives, thereby expanding our understanding of what constitutes Buddhism.