You are here

Online Program Book

This is the most up-to-date schedule for the 2023 AAR Annual Meeting. If you have questions about the program, contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org. All times are listed in Central Standard Time.

M18-107

Theme: Dharma, Post-humanism, and AI

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Marriott Riverwalk-Alamo Ballroom, Salon C

The category of post-humanism has recently emerged as a way to talk about contemporary experience that is seeking a way past/through the impasses of postmodern thought and culture. Do the Dharma traditions have resources to partner with critical post-humanism (as diverse schools of thought and praxis) to negotiate the limits and opportunities of AI and the digital, cyborg, scientific world in which we live? What are those resources? What might different dharma traditions offer, with the light they bring, to unveil or expose the possibilities and limits of AI? Issues of panpsychism, technology, rebirth, nuclear power and weaponry, climate change might also be addressed in this panel.

  • Abstract

    This paper addresses the nexus between mind, information and mental causality. How is it that the mind—what we think of as a mental entity, with a first-person perspective—how does the mind cause the brain to register particular neuronal states affecting the physical material of the brain and the body? As a way of probing the question of mental causality, we look here at the limit case of yogis using mantras, magical formulas, as a mental mechanism employed not only as a means for transforming a person’s state of mind, but also as a means to effect events outside of a person’s own physical body. This paper draws from a variety of sources, medieval Sanskrit texts, the work of the 20th century yogi scholar-adept Gopinath Kaviraj, contemporary neuroscientific work on the concept of information and mind to tease out the links between mind and the brain in relation

  • Abstract

    The second-season Star Trek: The Next Generation episode “The Measure of a Man” famously raises the question, “Does Commander Data have a soul?” Commander Data is an android and is one of the most beloved characters in Star Trek. This paper will examine the question, “Could an artificial intelligence, from the perspectives of various Dharma traditions, be possessed of jīva, the soul or essential life force of a living being?” The paper will examine various permutations of this question from the perspectives of different Dharma traditions. The Buddhist conception of ‘self’ as a process, for example, will be considered, along with Jain and Hindu concepts of jīva. The work of Marie Kondo, who recommends that we thank inanimate objects before we recycle them, will also be considered, along with the ethos of reverence for all entities, even those conventionally regarded as inanimate, which Kondo’s approach entails. 

  • Abstract

    This is a work of philosophical reflection based on my formation in Indian and European philosophy broadly.  My arguments are also based on my lay understanding and use of AI technology, as well as Erik J. Larson’s The Myth of AI:  Why Computers Can’t Think the Way We Do (Harvard University Press, 2021).  Larson argues that AI technology as it exists today and into the foreseeable future is not taking us one step closer to general intelligence, despite its dazzling ability to produce on command various images, prose, and poetry, and to organize data across an increasingly wide range of applications.  The inferences that are required to comprehend a newspaper or hold a conversation with an understanding of its meaning cannot be programmed, learned, or engineered with our current knowledge of AI.  

  • Abstract

    Critical posthumanism locates the human as a historical construct that is culturally and epistemically bounded. Modernity is a phase of the universalization or globalization of such a construct which has reached its limit. This paper will ask how one can understand dharma under these conditions and if yoga can provide us with new goals of becoming for our time.

A18-114

Theme: John Allegro's The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

San Antonio Convention Center-Room 304B (Ballroom Level)

This roundtable is dedicated to exploring the enigmatic career of John Allegro, and the reception history of his book, The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross (1970). A philologist with expertise in comparative Semitic dialects, Allegro made a name for himself as a translator and popularizer of the Dead Sea Scrolls; however, his academic reputation was destroyed with the publication of The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross: A Study of the Nature and Origins of Christianity within the Fertility Cults of the Ancient Near East. Bringing together scholars from the AAR and SBL, this roundtable will explore Allegro's argument that the original Christian community was a fertility cult based on the sacramental use of the psychedelic mushroom Amanita muscaria, the controversy and professional backlash generated by his thesis, and the continuing influence of his provocative thesis among academics, believers, and authors of popular fiction.

A18-115

Theme: The Ecclesial Work of Unacknowledged Hands

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Bowie C (Second Floor)

These papers discuss how many whose labor contributes to the life of the church often go unknown, unappreciated or underappreciated, and unacknowledged. They discuss the relations between centers and peripheries in the churches. The papers address blue-collar participation in the church, the history of HIV/AIDS in the work of an unacknowledged theologian, the work of church volunteers during Covid-19 lockdowns, and the work of mothers and "othermothers" in marginalized communities. They all address how the work of church building, so often assumed to be dependent upon the work of its leaders, is more often a creative bricolage that is the work of many hands, using many different means at hand. 

  • Abstract

    Church work is often assumed to rest with preachers, pastors, elders, and worship leaders. However, before the doors open on Sunday morning, the ecclesial space has already been established and maintained by the work of laborers often overlooked—plumbers, electricians, janitors, construction workers, landscapers, and others. This oversight is mirrored in the broader Faith and Work movement, which itself prioritizes white-collar vocations over blue-collar labor. At the root of this oversight lies a particular ecclesiological assumption of what it means for work to be “spiritual” or “ministerial”, an assumption tied to privileged ideas of enlightenment and self-actualization. This paper will interrogate this assumption for its lack of biblical and theological warrant and then offer a working ecclesiology for blue-collar participation based on a more grounded understanding of ecclesial and faithful labor, one in which the facilitation of communal space is at the heart of the work of the church.

  • Abstract

    Kevin Gordon was a lay gay Catholic theologian. After starting a PhD at Union in the late 1960s, he moved to the Castro, where he worked as an analyst while teaching, writing, and organizing a task force on homosexuality for the Archdiocese of San Francisco. In the 80s, Gordon returned to New York and assembled a group called the Consultation on Homosexuality, Social Justice, and Catholic Theology, which included John Boswell, Mary Hunt, Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza, Rosemary Radford Ruether, and others. He died of AIDS before completing his dissertation. This paper will examine two elements of Gordon’s work—his ecclesiological legacy found in his work on the World Council of Church’s document “The Church as Healing Community” and his influence on later AIDS ecclesiology, and his skepticism of premature meaning making—to press on a tension at the heart of the church and its metaphors: that between fragmentation and wholeness.

  • Abstract

    In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, considerable attention has been given to the changing role of clergy, as congregations often shifted exclusively to online worship. What has received less explicit analysis were the ways in which many lay people adapted and responded to help their communities navigate the challenging restrictions of the lockdown. This paper draws upon qualitative studies of eight congregations that focused on the impact of the lockdowns on the experience of church during the COVID-19 pandemic. The focus of the discussion will be on ways in which lay people, sometimes for the first time, took up leadership roles to respond to the needs of their community. The second concern of the paper will be to analyze the challenge that the re-opening of church buildings post-pandemic represents to such new initiatives, as many of the newly engaged lay people have sometimes experienced their ideas and interests being left behind or disregarded.

  • Abstract

    The term “othermothers” was first coined by Patricia Hill Collins to refer to the Black cultural phenomenon where individuals “actively and positively assume responsibility as role model, mentor, protector, and provider to children who are not biologically their own.” In my research for the Missing Voices Project, which centered and empowered marginalized youth to start new ministries, we found that mothers and “othermothers” of all racial and ethnic identities were active advocates, allies, and accomplices for marginalized youth in and beyond their congregations. Mothers and othermothers acted as public theologians, living their theological beliefs on behalf of their (and other) children. Using a practical theological framework and an ethnographic approach to research, this paper will analyze the lived theology of these mothers and othermothers through the theology of motherhood presented by Stephanie Buckhanon Crowder in order to critique the gaps and failures of our political system.

A18-116

Theme: The Business of Evangelicalism: Christianity, Capitalism, and the Corporate World

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Crockett C (4th Floor)

Christianity is big business. This session explores the well-established partnership between American evangelical identity, capitalism, and the corporate institutional logic of growth, recruitment, leadership formation, and development. Each author offers a unique entry point into the business of evangelicalism. This session includes papers that address American evangelicalism’s staunch commitment to Western capitalism, the ways in which this position is driven by anti-communist sentiment, and the implications for evangelical attitudes toward racial justice and conservative politics. It also includes papers that approach the theme from the corporate side. They examine the evangelical logic governing the subject formation and organizational practices that are not only present within the church but also outside of ecclesial space, in this case, at the heart of one of the largest tech companies in the world.

  • Abstract

    The political identity and activism of American evangelical Christians in the twentieth century has been given great attention in recent years, but far less attention has been paid to the actual theology—especially the biblical theology—animating these political concerns. In the 1970s and 80s, evangelical theologians, pastors, and biblical scholars fiercely debated questions of political economy, producing a multitude of popular books on the subject. This paper will explore the evangelical defenses of “Reaganomics” through an analysis of the biblical theological literature of the period—primarily Ronald Nash’s *Poverty and Wealth* (1986) and John Jefferson Davis’s *Your Wealth in God’s World: Does the Bible Support the Free Market* (1984). These texts, in their defenses of a capitalist political economy, illuminate the convergence of evangelical political and economic theologies, biblical hermeneutics, and accounts of work and vocation.

  • Abstract

    Jerry Falwell, Senior helped build the Religious Right as a reaction against the gains of the Civil Rights Movement. Yet when he preached about segregation and black liberationism, he was not so much rejecting the idea of black bodies in historically white spaces (although for a time, he did not allow African Americans at his church or school) as much as he was rejecting Martin Luther King's iteration of the Social Gospel. Falwell was a severe capitalist who saw any form of government regulation, especially the form that King was advocating, as part of a slide towards Soviet-style communism. He saw the Social Gospel itself, including the contemperaneous Civil Rights Movement, as part of a communist plot to take over America's churches.

  • Abstract

    Willow Creek is a paradigmatic megachurch, the blueprint for the “seeker-sensitive” and corporate-friendly church that became popular in late twentieth and early twenty-first century American evangelicalism. It presides over a global network of churches and partner organizations, at the center of which is the Global Leadership Summit, which Bill Hybels created in 1995. Founded as a workshop for church leaders, the GLS quickly exceeded Hybels’ initial plans, evolving into a kind of Davos for evangelicals. The GLS is the focal point of Willow’s influence on Christianity around the world. I argue that the GLS facilitates a dual revival that combines the theology and affective strategies of evangelical revivalism with neoliberal corporate leadership discourse in order to pump new life into businesses and churches for the salvation of the world. The salvific religion of the GLS is neoliberal leadership formation encased in evangelical affect. This is Willow Creek’s global imprint.

  • Abstract

    A distinctive feature of evangelical action, both in worship and in its creation of cultural products, is its appropriation of secular forms. Jill Stevenson identifies this appropriation as a signature method of what she calls “evangelical dramaturgy,” or the performative tactics used by evangelical media to shape the emotional responses of attendees. This paper asks what happens when appropriation moves in the other direction and technology companies, like Salesforce.com, adopt evangelical dramaturgies to structure their annual user conference. Based on ethnographic observations and interviews, I argue that North American corporations, such as Salesforce, now borrow from evangelicalism’s performance repertoire, and especially from strategies associated with seeker sensitive megachurches. Furthermore, the secular marking of evangelical forms allows companies to deploy them without anyone taking notice or taking offense, even as the company explicitly associates itself with indigenous or Buddhist philosophies and practitioners.

A18-149

Theme: On the Nature of Poetic Language: A Philosophical Roundtable

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Lonestar Ballroom, Salon D (Second Floor)

The poetic theorist Ānandavardhana famously held that in addition to the literal and implicative functions of language, poetry expresses meaning through a third, distinctive function: suggestion (*dhvani*, *vyañjanā*). Mukula Bhaṭṭa, in his *Abhidhāvṛttamātṛkā*, holds that there is no need to posit a third semantic function; implication (*lakṣaṇā*) suffices to explain the communicative power of poetry. This roundtable brings together five scholars to assess Mukula’s arguments, both in their historical context and in light of contemporary poetics. The goal of the format is to create a space for lively and rigorous discussion, rather than traditional paper presentations. A handout with the original Sanskrit and an English translation of selections from Mukula’s text will be provided. 

A18-120

Theme: Islamic Mystical Platonisms

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Republic C (4th Floor)

This panel explores the importance of Platonic and Neoplatonic thought in the mystical thought of various Muslim thinkers. Towards this end, the papers that make up this panel address a number of questions with regard to the nature, scope, audience, and context of Platonic texts that were translated during the Arabic translation movement that occurred in ninth-century Baghdad, Iraq from Greek into Arabic. This panel seeks to show how the translations of the Dialogues of Plato, the ontology of Plotinus, and the theurgical practices of Iamblichus and Proclus became part-and-parcel of Islamic mystical thought after the ninth century. The ideas in these original Greek works were also often misattributed and even heavily redacted to conform to the monotheistic worldviews of their Muslim and Christian readers. The papers in the panel examine the use of these translations in the thought of various mystics and philosophers during the Medieval period.

  • Abstract

    The Brethren of Purity (Ikhwān al-Ṣafā’) were a ninth-tenth century Shi’ite philosophical movement from Basra. Most modern scholars have denied that Hermeticism as a distinct school of philosophy ever existed. Due to this, earlier studies have not shown what role Hermetic and Neopythagorean mysticism played in the Treatises of the Brethren of Purity. This paper rejects a theory posed by André-Jean Festugière and Kevin van Bladel that Hermeticism is merely a bricolage of concepts. Instead, as Christian H. Bull and J. Peter Södergård have argued, this paper supports the theory that a distinct form of Hermetic mysticism is present in the Brethren of Purity’s Treatises and that they used magic, theurgy, and numerology to achieve mystical union with the Universal Soul through invoking spirits (angels and jinn). These spirits taught the Brethren empirical sciences and also how to unite with the Universal Soul.

  • Abstract

    This talk engages in what I argue to be the continuation of the ancient philosophical tradition of the care of the self (epimeleia heautou) as formulated by Michel Foucault in the Islamic context.  While many elements found new life in the Islamic world through the engagement with Hellenistic philosophy following the Graeco-Arabic translation movement, I will focus here on the Platonic notion of recollection (anamnesis) and the echoes of Platonic epistemology in Islamic philosophy, theology, and mysticism. The talk briefly charts the reception of Plato’s theory of recollection in the Islamic context, and posits various afterlives of anamnesis in the Islamic world despite widespread rejection of reincarnation and the pre-existence of the soul.  Specifically, I highlight the mode of recollection in Fakhr al-Dīn al-Rāzī’s (d. 1210) developed philosophical theology, which I argue to be an ontological rather than epistemological principle.  

  • Abstract

    The Andalusian mystic ‘Abd al-Ḥaqq ibn Sab‘īn al-Ghāfiqī (d. 1271 CE) has long been considered a radical monist because of his theology of absolute oneness (al-waḥḍa al-maḥḍa).  In this paper, I will argue that the key to this theology comes from a monotheistic gloss on the metaphysics of Proclus (d. 485 CE), as expressed in his work The Elements of Theology.  Two Arabic translations of portions of Proclus’s Elements were made in the medieval period. The Arab translators of the Elements eliminated the pagan parts and transformed the One, which is beyond being for Proclus, into God as the First Cause and the First Being.  For Ibn Sab‘īn, since God as the First and True Being (al-Awwal al-Ḥaqq) must be present in all forms of multiplicity, He is also present in all things.  The outcome of this logic is his monistic theology of absolute oneness.

  • Abstract

    What must the world be like, to host natural laws as well as their violations? Must one choose between a scientific worldview and a world with a God with untrammeled power? I lay out an interesting strategy in Ibn Sina that attempts to preserve causal powers of nature as well as the possibility of the divine in overriding them to perform miracles. Ibn Sina introduces into the cosmos an extraordinarily powerful agent, a human nonetheless, who functions as a kind of “soul for the world”. Just as our souls influence our own bodies, the soul of a mystic and prophet is said to influence bodies other than their own. By working miracles into his system in this way, Ibn Sina’s theory of prophecy, I argue, brings together his scientific worldview as expressed in his thoroughgoing philosophical works with his more esoteric views expressed in his mystical works.

  • Abstract

    This paper proves the substantive role that Twelver Shiʿite sources played in the development of medieval Sufi piety, well beyond what is known to modern scholarship.  Specifically, I show how Sufis as early as the 8th/14th c. expressed devotion to the Twelfth Imam of the Shiʿa as awaited Mahdi and supreme spiritual authority or “Seal of the Saints,” through significant reliance on Shiʿite sources.  After considering this doctrine’s origins in Mongol Iran, I sketch its transmission through Persian Sufi orders until the Safavid period (10th/16th – 12th/18th c.).  Prompting a serious return to the old hypothesis of “Shiʿite influence” on Persian Sufism, these sources suggest that the readiness throughout much of Iranian society to accept Shiʿism under the Safavids may have rested partly on a Sufi, specifically emanationist reinterpretation of Shiʿism’s normative claims – but also that such conceptions were too widespread to guarantee confessional outcomes by themselves.

A18-121

Theme: New Light on Jain Yoga: Philological, Anthropological, and Philosophical Insights

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

San Antonio Convention Center-Room 207A (Meeting Room Level)

This panel brings together five scholars working on interdisciplinary philological, anthropological, and philosophical approaches to Jain yoga, showcasing original translations of Jain yoga texts, ethnographic field work, and cultural studies of Jainism and yoga. The presentations shed new light on Jain yoga’s textual “dark age” including from Yaśovijaya's Prakriyā commentary on the Pātañjalayogaśāstra, sections of Yaśovijaya's Dvātriṃśad-Dvtriṃśikā which also comment directly on the Pātañjalayogaśāstra, as well as the Yogapradīpa. Our presenters further consider contemporary cultural intersections of Jainism and yoga, sharing fieldwork from newly developing styles of Jain yoga in India, insights into Jainism and yoga’s entanglements with European culture, and a philosophical current of Jain pragmatism found in Jain yoga texts that urges us to revisit the popular emic notion of intellectual-ahiṃsā encountered in contemporary Jain culture today. Collectively, these five presentations shed new light on Jain yoga and also new research opportunities in Jain Studies and Yoga Studies.

  • Abstract

    There is limited scholarly awareness of the Jain impact on yoga, particularly during the period Sagarmal Jain has called the “dark age for Jain yoga” from the 11th century onward. To help shed new light on Jain yoga’s “dark age,” this paper presents elements of my research from two Jain yoga texts: the Yogapradīpa, and Yaśovijaya's Prakriyā commentary on the Pātañjalayogaśāstra (PYS). I discuss how the Yogapradīpa (second millennium AD) presents an eight-fold path to liberation that is similar to that found in the PYS, highlighting how the Yogapradīpa nevertheless assigns higher importance to dhyāna rather than samādhi. I also show how the Yogapradīpa conveys a Jain-inflected trans-sectarian approach to yoga. Similarly, Yaśovijaya, a prominent seventeenth century Jain philosopher from Gujarat, presents his own conciliatory approach towards other religions on the principle of neutrality in his Prakriyā commentary. I compare and contrast these unique Jain contributions toward Jain yoga’s development.

  • Abstract

    The relevance of the Pātañjalayogaśāstra (PYS) has varied throughout history. Scholarship on the text has mainly focused on Brahmanical and Buddhist traditions and has left out other voices that might complicate the narrative of the history of the text. This paper presents new translations from a text by the so-called last great philosopher of Jainism, the Tapā Gaccha monk Yaśovijaya (1624 –1688). He not only devotes an entire compendium, Dvātriṃśad-Dvtriṃśikā, to an investigation of various forms of spiritual practice he calls 'yoga', but also devotes an entire chapter with the PYS as his chief interlocutor, rendering his own summary version of the text in śloka form. Despite his influence in Jain thought, Yaśovijaya remains understudied and most of his work has not been translated. With original translations, this paper shows how he affirms a Jain position in the PYS through his hermeneutical choices in the Dvātriṃśad-Dvtriṃśikā.

  • Abstract

    Alongside the well documented work of Rakesh Jhaveri at Dharampur Meditation Centre in Gujarat, three meditation movements have taken up similar work, attempting to promote a spiritual practice in the Jain idiom for contemporary times: Preksha Dhyan established by Acharya Mahaprajna (1920-2010), Adhyatma Dhyan founded by Acharya Shiv Muni (1942-), and the Arham Meditation movement of Muni Pranamya Sagar (1975-). This presentation will highlight key principles of each of these yoga systems, including reports on field site visits and a consideration of how each system incorporates Jain yoga texts into their practices. It will demonstrate the diversity of contemporary Jain yoga systems even as it demonstrates each system’s commitment to similar foundational Jain principles, practices, and soteriological goals.

  • Abstract

    This paper contextualizes Dr. Narendra Kumar Jain’s (1937-) Eastside Gallery Painting, “The Seven Stages of Enlightenment,” a popular mural on the Berlin Wall featuring a meditating yogi-Buddha with seven cakras, Mahavira, and several other religious and spiritual figures and symbols. The mural’s peace-making bricolage pushes the boundaries of the study of Jainism and yoga to their disciplinary limits, requiring an interdisciplinary approach drawing from Jain Studies and Yoga Studies but also from Buddhist Studies, political science and art history to understand why these various influences converge in Dr. Jain’s popular mural. Even as Dr. Jain emphasizes a universalistic Jain and yogic identity and the apophatic nature of his artistic work, his engagement with all of the intersecting influences presented in this paper place his mural in a very particular socio-historical location, making his work both transcendent and contextualizable, from emic and etic perspectives, respectively.

  • Abstract

    Contemporary Jains often understand anekānta-vāda to have implications for interfaith goodwill and acceptance in the form of social- and intellectual-ahiṃsā. Following this contemporary approach, this paper considers one genre of Jain texts instrumentalizing anekānta-vāda not only as an epistemological dialectical logic, but also as a mandate for social-ahiṃsā between religions. I revisit several texts on yoga by Haribhadrasūri who is engaged in a type of interfaith dialogue in a way that affords significant positive valuation of other non-Jain yoga traditions. I argue that there is a current of philosophical pragmatism in these texts and within the thought of some other Jain thinkers which subordinates theory to practice and admits the fallibilism in mundane human knowledge in such a way that allows for significant positive valuation of other traditions, thereby fostering potential for interfaith goodwill. In this way, this paper is the first in-depth dialogue between Western Pragmatism and Jain tradition.

A18-122

Theme: Doctrine, Violence, and Care: Emerging Research on Japanese Religion

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Crockett B (4th Floor)

Emerging research on questions of doctrine, metaphor, violence, licensed evil, and care among Japanese religious actors across a range of historical periods.  Individual papers in this omnibus session explore the discourse of “licensed evil” in the writings of Hōnen’s (1133-1212) followers, with special attention to their concern with salvation through the practice of the nembutsu; the metaphors of violence and their relation to Buddhist doctrinal concerns in the writings of Takuan Sōhō (1573-1645); the Maruyamakō movement, which spread rapidly through eastern Japan beginning in 1870, and whose transformation from movement to sect is explained through the concept of "doctrinalization"; and the eldercare activities of Kōdō Kyōdan, a Tendai Buddhist group founded in 1936, with attention to how interactions between religious and secular institutions shape this Buddhist program's vision of faith as a medium between care and caring in a time of crisis. This papers session will be followed by a business meeting for the Japanese Religions Unit.

  • Abstract

    Medieval Japanese Buddhists debated the relationship between moral conduct and salvation, widely understood as birth after death in the Buddha Amida’s Pure Land. Some argued that faith rendered rules of proper behavior unnecessary to attain birth in the Pure Land. This paper examines medieval Japanese debates over whether Pure Land teachings license individuals to commit evil. It focuses on Hōnen (1133-1212) and his followers, with whom the discourse of “licensed evil” is closely associated. Hōnen taught that salvation is achieved only by chanting Amida’s name (nenbutsu) and relying totally on his compassion. As his doctrine spread, however, some devotees used it to legitimize the violation of conventions. In this paper, I situate antinomian readings of Hōnen’s doctrine within a broader undercurrent of anxieties over attainment of salvation and show that “licensed evil” became a focal point of debates over how to interpret Hōnen’s doctrine of the exclusive nenbutsu.

  • Abstract

    In the early twentieth century, militarists eager to dignify violence in service to the modern Japanese state promoted the writings of the Zen priest Takuan Sōhō (1573–1645). To reassess the relationship between Buddhism and violence, as well as Takuan’s role in theorizing that relationship, this paper develops a systematic analysis of the metaphors Takuan used to conceptualize violence. Focusing on Takuan’s works addressing a warrior audience, “The Mysterious Record of Immovable Wisdom” (Fudōchi shimyōroku) and “The Annals of [the Sword] Taia” (Taiaki), I will show that Takuan employed metaphor in three important ways: (1) to explain the ‘non-stopping mind’—his neologism for non-attaching immovable wisdom; (2) to analogize swordsmanship to Buddhist practice; and (3) to liken warriors to bodhisattvas. Based on theories of metaphorical conceptualization and master tropes, I will show that Takuan endorsed swordsmanship practiced with the non-stopping mind as a warrior’s entry into the path towards enlightenment.

  • Abstract

    From 1870 through 1895, the Maruyamakō movement spread rapidly through eastern Japan. It was characterized by outsiders as a millenarian movement with secret, subversive teachings. It is often described as peaking at 1.38 million members in 1889. Maruyamakō’s charismatic founder Itō Rokurōbei has been interpreted in the past as reviving an early modern popular morality. My research instead emphasizes the prominence of faith healing in the group’s spread, and explains its history using the concept of "doctrinalization" which emerges in the history of Sect Shinto. I look at several documents published between March and September 1885 which attempted to control the Maruyamakō movement by imposing doctrine on them. These attempts proved futile, but greater administrative oversight allowed Maruyama Kyōkai to establish strict control over the production and copying of Itō Rokurōbei’s messages from 1887 until his death in 1894.

  • Abstract

    This study examines the evolving roles of a faith-based social welfare program, the Maitri Help Service, in providing care services in contemporary Japan. Launched in 1998 by the lay Buddhist group Kōdō Kyōdan in Yokohama, the Maitri Help Service offers a wide range of eldercare services to the public. In light of Japan's aging population and the COVID-19 crisis, this ethnographic study investigates the development of the Maitri Help Service and its interactions with external institutions. It seeks to understand the intricate dynamics that this program navigates with multiple interested parties in the non-profit sector. This study argues that the interrelationships between the Maitri Help Service, its parent religious organization, and external institutions are crucial in shaping the program’s actions and visions of how faith can bridge care and caring in times of crisis and enable opportunities for future development.

A18-123

Theme: La Labor de Nuestras Manos: Understanding Faith and Labor in the Fields

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Marriott Rivercenter-Conference Room 12

.

A18-124

Theme: Should We Abolish the Family? On the Relationship Between Care and the State

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Republic B (4th Floor)

In recent years, activist calls for the abolition of a number of institutions have become more visible in popular discourse. This includes a demand to abolish the family itself. This roundtable features four panelists, from a range of disciplinary approaches, whose interests coalesce around gender, care, and home. The roundtable will focus on the following four questions: Should we abolish the family? What does family abolition entail? How do religious concepts and theological systems construct the body, the relationship between self and body, and the relationship between the body and the state? And what religious resources might fund new visions of care? Panelists discuss Black geographies and the built environment; sexual autonomy and the politics of consent; pregnancy and motherhood; and parental rights and public education.

A18-146

Theme: Transpacific Political Theology: Perspectives and Methods

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

San Antonio Convention Center-Room 212B (Meeting Room Level)

This roundtable is based on a forthcoming book Transpacific Political Theology: Perspectives and Methods, which brings together Asian theologians, Asians in the diaspora, and Asian American scholars. Since US political and military strategies pivoted to Asia, tensions between the US and Asian and Pacific countries have escalated. It is urgent to reflect on the theological and the political from a transpacific perspective. A transpacific political theology problematizes essentialized accounts of continents and regions and reflects on the transpacific circulation of peoples, cultures, commodities, and ideas. Its goal is to interrogate the relationship between the state and the political, nationalisms, old and new orientalisms, and U.S. colonial and military presence in Asia and the Pacific. It challenges and queers the construction of nation, empire, race, caste, gender, and sexuality by presenting grounded historical analyses. The roundtable offers examples of how faith communities have been involved in people’s struggles and movements across the Pacific.

A18-126

Theme: Who Counts as a “Mystic”?

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Crockett D (4th Floor)

Since the inception of what can be considered “comparative mysticism,” the field has largely privileged mystics and mystical traditions whose examples have been culled primarily from the “major world religions” – Judaism, Christianity, and Islam as representing “theistic” mystics, and Hinduism and Buddhism as either “monistic” or “non-theistic” mystics. While this early-mid 20th century typology has been contested, definitions of “who counts” as a mystic have mostly been the purvey of 21st century scholars who have begun to question the boundaries of the field including the very definitions applied to its subjects. This panel questions the qualifications one must possess in order to be considered a mystic, and presses how far beyond the categories of traditional “world religions” might the term apply. In doing so, this panel “troubles” the category of the mystic, particularly who counts as one, and where one might locate – or re-imagine – a comparative study of mysticism today.

  • Abstract

    Contemporary scholars of religion have frequently linked mysticism with the desire for and pursuit of experiential knowledge of the divine. The term mystic, derived from the Greek μυω, meaning hidden, secret, or allegorical, is often used to describe a set of texts and devotional techniques oriented around a specific subset of contemplative thought and practice.  However, scholars also recognize that mysticism is a capacious category. Niklaus Largier’s recent text, Figures of Possibility: Aesthetic Experience, Mysticism, and the Play of the Senses, begins with the premise that mystical practices have been continuously reinvented across the centuries. Drawing on a wide range of aesthetic production he explores how mystical and devotional practices have long been invested in the modulating and reconfiguring of sensation, affects, and thoughts. This paper places his concept of the ek-static threshold in conversation with contemporary writing on trans spirituality to explore how differential and unrepresentable presences and forms of life might facilitate alternative ways of being. 

  • Abstract

    This paper explores modern, kabbalistic sacred sexuality as a means of seeking from the body, which is both the vehicle and the destination. By analyzing a series of interviews with its modern teachers, I show how practitioners cultivate physical and emotional limit experiences to achieve powerful, altered modes of embodiment. In their own words, they often describe rituals that combine elements of psychology, bodywork, religious ritual, and kink - theorized as a mode of participation which rearranges and alters self, personal relationships, society, and the cosmos as a form of trans-embodied, transpersonal, empowered psychology. In my analysis, I use modern theories of transpersonal psychology to argue that the limit experiences of kabbalistic sacred sexuality become a mode of participation in psychological and cosmological structures that move and transform in multiple domains at once, while centered in the body. In this way we approach the question of not only who is mystic, but what and where it is.

  • Abstract

    This paper contextualizes Jung’s early occult investigations through the wider historical landscape of the emerging trans-Atlantic intersection of “psychology and religion” in the early 20th c. After locating Jung’s personal experience and subsequent theoretical model of the unconscious as contingent upon his own “occult origins,” I will then turn toward Jung’s mysticism of “the Dead,” by way of his own “channeled” text, “The Seven Sermons to the Dead.” Comprising the final segment of The Red Book, Jung’s “Seven Sermons” challenge historical notions of “who counts” as a mystic, what mystical praxis entails, and the pivotal role of the imagination (or, “imaginal”) in what can be considered a unique melding of cataphatic and apophatic approaches to mystical consciousness.

  • Abstract

    Scholars such as Alton Pollard, Rachel Harding and Kofi Opoku have long written about Africana mysticism and mystical culture as a core aspect of Africana religiosity. Within Africana traditions, communion with divinity solidifies practicing communities. This communion is a means of communication, affirmation, healing and wellness, integration, vital union and transformation on individual and collective levels. The body is the primary site for divine visitation or communion between the visible (living human) world and the invisible (spirit) world, but aesthetical practices and material items also support these processes. In this paper, I will explore how structures of Africana mystical culture that are critical to comparative discourses on mysticism permeate Black popular culture and performance in ways that demonstrate the multivocality of divinity, the central role of the body, and the generation/solidification of Black vitality. 

A18-148

Theme: Networks of Extremism: Shared Scripts, Strategies, and Frameworks of Hindu Nationalism and White Christian Nationalism in India and the US

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Bonham C (3rd Floor)

Religious nationalisms develop in conversation with one another: despite their sometimes public confrontations and apparently divergent ideologies, many of today's religious nationalisms share discursive strategies, institutional structures, funding models, and media ecosystems, learning from one another through both competition and collaboration. The proposed roundtable will explore the connections between two growing and intertwined religious nationalisms: White Christian nationalism and Hindu nationalism in the US and in India. These movements exhibit marked similarities in their ideological foundations, rhetorical strategies, institutional initiatives, and use of media (especially social media). These similarities have developed as White Christian nationalism and Hindu nationalism have observed and competed with one another but also through active collaboration between their respective agents, producing surprising solidarities. The discussion will highlight the shared Islamophobia and grievance politics that often unite these nationalisms against perceived common enemies and the transnational political and financial networks that make these ‘nationalist’ movements possible.

A18-127

Theme: Retelling U.S. Religious History: A Roundtable Discussion

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

San Antonio Convention Center-Room 225D (Meeting Room Level)

_Retelling U.S. Religious History_, a collection of essays published in 1997, aimed to rethink "the grand narratives of U.S. religion" and create "more inclusive stories of America's complex religious past." Once an effort to revise the canon, the book shaped the next generation of scholars and is now a canonical text in the field of American religious history. This roundtable will bring together scholars trained in the 25 years after the publication of _Retelling U.S. Religious History_ to reflect on its impact. Each participant will focus on one essay and discuss how its core theme influenced their individual scholarship and the field of American religious history overall. They will also discuss the limitations and possibilities for future scholarship on that theme. This roundtable session will foster intergenerational conversation about telling and retelling American religious history--how this work has changed and how we envision doing this work together moving forward.

A18-128

Theme: God in Motion: A Critical Exploration of the Open Theism Debate by Manuel Schmid (Book Panel)

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Marriott Rivercenter-Conference Room 11

Open theism paints the picture of a flexible God who engages in dynamic history with free creatures, a history in which the future is not definitely known to God but rather unfolds as a range of possibilities. As one might expect, this position has proven fractious. God in Motion is the first in-depth analysis of the biblical-hermeneutical questions driving the heated open theism debate. Schmid proposes an alternate path to understanding this debate, bringing open theism into conversation with representatives of German-language theology such as Karl Barth, Emil Brunner, Wolfhart Pannenberg, and Jürgen Moltmann. God in Motion shows ways out of the theological dead ends that have characterized the debate, especially regarding the biblical grounding of open theism, by considering lessons learned from the controversies of current theological discourse. This roundtable session will discuss the open theism, classical theology, and Schmid’s proposal.

A18-129

Theme: Interpreting and Translating the Qur’an

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

San Antonio Convention Center-Room 007D (River Level)

This panel includes papers from a range of perspectives on translating and interpreting the Qur'an.

  • Abstract

    Why did a Catholic priest translate segments of the Qur'an into his self-made language Volapük? What use is a Qur’an translation into a variant of Tamazight so purified of Arabic expressions that few Tamazight speaker are able to understand it? Most studies of Qur'an translations do not offer answers to these questions because of their focus on the communicative function of translations. Conversely, this paper argues that the production of Qur’an translations has a performative function that makes them no less important than the much better-researched Biblical translations. The paper will center marginalized languages and show how the Qur’an is positioned in attempts to define their status, and how these languages in turn define the status of the Qur’an. While the production of Qur’an translations in such cases has a largely symbolic quality, their mere existence contributes to centering the marginal and making the obscure visible.

  • Abstract

    This article explores the role of the Muslim World League (MWL) in authorizing translations of the Qur’an. Established in 1962 by Saudi Crown Prince Fayṣal b. ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz Āl Saʿūd, the MWL aimed to assert moral and political authority over the entire Muslim world. The article argues that Qur’an translation was an important part of the MWL’s strategy for promoting Islam globally. Despite the Qur’an being considered an “untranslatable text,” the MWL successfully completed six translation projects in languages such as Japanese, Yoruba, and Turkish. Through analyzing the history and stories behind these translations, the article shows how the MWL’s experience contributed to the Muslim community worldwide by providing “authorized” translations. This idea of institutional authority in translation, where the role of publisher, reviser, and approving body played a decisive role, went beyond the individual experience of the translator. The article concludes that the MWL’s success in authorizing Qur’an translations played a pivotal role in establishing the King Fahd Glorious Qur'an Printing Complex, which remains the largest Qur’an printing and translation factory today.

  • Abstract

    Ibn Taymiyya’s "Introduction to the Principles of Qur’anic Hermeneutics," (Muqaddima fi usul al-tafsir) has arguably become one of the most important classical manuals to understand the medieval Qur’anic commentary tradition and its hermeneutic viewed as normative way to understand the Qur’an.  However, in the most recent edition of the Muqaddima, the editor Sami b. Muhammad b. Jad Allah contends that the last two chapters are wrongly attributed to Ibn Taymiyya and are in fact the writings of Ibn Kathir.  Jad Allah makes his argument based on the chapter’s writing style, pre-modern citations and various manuscripts.  I am inclined to Jad Allah’s reasoning but believe more pre-modern and manuscript work needs to be done to conclusively establish the argument.  This discussion is significant because it speaks to the construction of modern exegetical orthodoxy and how the medieval tradition has been transmitted to us.     

  • Abstract

    This paper examines how, within the ontological framework of the Qur’an, the concept of israf or waste can be understood in not only material terms but also epistemic ones. This paper argues that within this Qur’anic framework, epistemic waste occurs when the meaning-content of an existent entity is unacknowledged or insufficiently apprehended by its recipient. Utilizing Said Nursi’s (d.1960) hermeneutics of approaching the cosmos as scripture or ayat in which divine names are constantly being manifested, this paper examines how israf as conceptualized throughout the Qur’an, looks to the epistemological nature of the world in which all entities are carriers of divine names not to be wasted, materially and epistemically. Understanding israf within the broader theological epistemology of the Qur’an can be a critical step in constructing an Islamic eco-ethic that is not divorced from the broader telos of its scripture.

  • Abstract

    This paper elucidates a Quranic framework of *shura* as a relational theology of care. Drawing on four references from the Quran this paper highlights what may be considered an implicit norm as encouraging a theology of relationality in interpretation of Revelation and Divine communication between caregiver and careseeker. Engaging with Toshiko Izutsu’s *Revelation as a Linguistic Concept in Islam*, Grau and Wyman’s *What is Constructive Theology?* this paper posits *shura* as a practice of care in Muslim practical theology.  

A18-130

Theme: Reformed Confessions and the Nature of Church

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

San Antonio Convention Center-Room 008B (River Level)

Reformed Christianity have written, debated, confessed, and even divided over confessions and creeds for hundreds of years. In this session, the Reformed Theology and History Unit considers the complex and contested nature of confessions in the ecclesiology, theology, and history of Reformed Christianity. The first paper examines Karl Barth's lectures on the Reformed confessions during his formational tenure at Göttingen, considering how his own views on confessions was shaped by his study of both Lutheran and Reformed history within his German speaking academic context. The second paper turns to the American context and offers a ciritcal analysis of the Presbyterian concept of the church's spiritual nature. The final paper offers a constructive reading of Reformed Confessions within a global and plural context through a theology of confessional hospitality. 

  • Abstract

    Karl Barth’s Theology of the Reformed Confessions characterized the Reformed confessional texts as more ethical in orientation and more horizontal in focus than the symbols of their Lutheran counterparts. He goes so far as to say that “this understanding of Christianity as the connection, grounded in God and effected in humans, of the invisible divine truth of life and the visible renewal of human life …” simply is “the positive Reformed doctrine of Christianity” (147-148). He builds there on earlier claims made in lecture cycles on Calvin and Zwingli about the ethical and horizontal distinctiveness of the Reformed tradition. This paper examines his source material to explore ways in which he does render early Reformed confessional concerns from 1523 onward but also in what ways his analysis was inflected by his engagement of Luther studies in 1923. 

  • Abstract

    Common interpretations of the American Presbyterian doctrine of the “spirituality of the church” have been criticized by historians as a theological rationale for the church to avoid addressing racial injustice from slavery to desegregation. In this paper, I supply theological argument to complement these historical criticisms. Common interpretations of the “spirituality of the church” intend to offer a distinction between what political concerns the church can and cannot officially address. I argue that the common interpretations typified in the seminal figures of Stuart Robinson, James Thornwell, and Charles Hodge offer distinctions that are unable to offer guidance in the application of scriptural moral teachings that have social dimensions. As an alternative, I draw upon John Calvin’s and the Westminster Confession of Faith’s recognition that the moral law applies to church and state alike to undergird an understanding of the church that can address political concerns, without sponsoring a state church.

  • Abstract

    The double bind that Reformed catholicity presents is that churches confess catholicity but their "confusing provincialism" leads to an idealized catholicity that, Karl Barth warns in The Theology of the Reformed Confessions, becomes unity deferred. The symptom of this problem comes in the proliferation of multiple locally-grounded confessional statements. This presentation suggests that there needs to be a way to bring churches from different contexts to the table in a way that is hospitable to many, even if it does not mean uniformity or comfort. This presentation calls this way, “confessional hospitality.” Drawing on Jacques Derrida's dialectic between conditional and unconditional hospitality, confessional hospitality considers the possibilities for local churches to confront universal evils by learning how to talk with each other through Reformed confessions. Thus, confessional hospitality paves the way for a connectional unity without connecting it with a specific institution or structure.

A18-131

Theme: Spirituality and Morality: Struggle, Agency, and Imagination from Disability Contexts

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

San Antonio Convention Center-Room 210B (Meeting Room Level)

Papers in this session will explore spirituality and morality as it emerges from specific disability locations and contexts: 1) Humanistic Deaf spirituality emerges in fiction and role playing games, and Deaf players create meaning in the midst of the struggle for self-determination and autonomy in the face of continued encroachment on Deaf communities, languages, identities, and bodies. 2) Black disabled men bring wisdom to the struggle towards thriving, esp. in the spirituality arising in the lives of Black disabled men, spirituality that is a profound source of strength and inspiration marked by softness and an ethics of care. 3) Nineteenth-century epileptic colonies highlight how epileptics were positioned on the borderline between madness and sanity, and how religious ideals and practices linked with medical authority, valorizing eugenic biopolitics and positioning religion as a moral good and disciplinary strategy.

  • Abstract

    Through examination of the fictional world of Sara Nović’s novel Tru Biz, the Inspiriles role playing game developed by Hatchling Games, Sign: A game about being understood from Thorny Games, and the online role playing game, Deafverse, this paper will track the expression of a humanistic Deaf spirituality rooted in finding hope and creating meaning in the struggle for self-determination and autonomy in the face of continued colonialist encroachment on our communities, languages, identities, and bodies.

  • Abstract

    This paper takes a multidisciplinary and multilevel look at Black disabled men in society as they struggle towards thriving. As we look at constructs of masculinity, ableism, and a theology that promotes wellness, what wisdom do Black disabled men bring to the table? 

  • Abstract

    Nineteenth-century experts produced medical theories in which the physical integrity of the brain dictated one’s ability to recognize morality or perform it. Psychobiological health thus determined the extent to which one could be moral. In the later nineteenth century, some states began building new institutions to segregate certain types of disability, including epilepsy. Medical experts argued that epileptics straddled the line dividing sanity from madness. Even sane epileptics, however, were typically considered morally suspicious and a dangerous threat to others.

    Modeled after Germany’s Bethel epileptic colony, New York’s Craig Colony for Epileptics absorbed an old, remote Shaker site in order to segregate epileptics from everyone else. Once institutionalized, epileptics’ lives were managed for them. Like most US epileptic colonies, Craig saw religion as a moral good and helpful disciplinary strategy. Chaplains’ religious ideals and practices conversed with medical expertise, valorized eugenic biopolitics, and anchored religious services in medical authority.  

A18-132

Theme: Dwelling with Pedagogy: Religion, Ecology, and the Craft of Teaching

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

San Antonio Convention Center-Room 301A (Ballroom Level)

This roundtable on the pedagogy of Religion and Ecology reflects on how and why—not just what—we teach in this area. Teaching in Religion and Ecology (and related courses) requires meaningful reflection and continual revision as both the natural world and our students’ relationships with it continue to change. Panelists will share methodological opportunities and challenges in this area as well as resources for teaching (community based, alternative media, online) that they have had success with or are developing. They will each conclude with remarks on their curiosities or hopes for ongoing pedagogical development within Religion and Ecology. A respondent with pedagogical experience will offer a response as well as discussion questions, opening the conversation with session attendees and facilitating the further exchange of perspectives and information between all participants.

A18-133

Theme: Systems, Circulation, and Management of Devotion and Dissent

Saturday, 9:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Grand Hyatt-Bonham D (3rd Floor)

Six panelists consider the systems, circulations, and managerial practices of devotion and dissent in a hybrid panel of short paper presentations and roundtable-inspired conversation. Case studies vary across geography, tradition, race, gender, and other markers of human distinction and social difference-making. Panelists consider the impacts of highway construction on black spiritual landscapes and remembrance practices, mail-order fundraising networks and shadow economies among the Pallotine Fathers, the entrepreneural practices at a Shinto shrine and among evangelical homemakers, and the un/waged labor embedded in Hindu standardized testing systems and as central to the genre of "speaking bitterness" among Catholic nuns in China. A formal response and Q&A to follow short presentations with a business meeting held immediately after.

  • Abstract

    When the construction of Interstate 94 in St. Paul, MN, ripped through the African American community of Rondo during the 1950s and 1960s, it spawned resistance campaigns, cultural preservation efforts, and, more recently, restorative agendas funded by local foundations and city governments. Associated with famous residents such as Roy Wilkins and August Wilson, the Rondo community has risen to national notoriety. Animated by thriving professional, athletic, and social clubs, hair salons, newspapers, banks, restaurants, and labor unions, before the implementation of eminent domain under the Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956, Rondo was the Twin Cities' Black Wall Street. In this paper, I employ interviews conducted in the summer of 2022 with members of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church in St. Paul, MN – to describe how recollections of the displacement and destruction of Black sacred centers inspire new memory landscapes where religious and business life intertwine as integrated and orienting belief systems.

  • Abstract

    This paper elucidates what a Shinto shrine is in relation to business enterprise. When I worked in a Shinto shrine for the first time, I was told that a religious organization is different from shoubai (business). Through the language, the shrine was trying to emphasize the difference between a shrine and a commercial enterprise. However, I was bewildered when a kannushi (Shinto priest) called himself a salaryman (corporate employee) and shrine a company. This contradiction led me to reflect on what is the difference between a religious corporation and a business corporation. In this paper, I will explore the interpenetration and tension between religious and economic interest in a Shinto shrine, from the perspective of the insiders. Although seeking economic (secular) gain is not appropriate for a religious (sacred) organization, a shrine cannot operate without economic interest. How does the administration manage the shrine, maintaining the appropriate relationship between them?

  • Abstract

    In 1995, evangelical financial counselor Larry Burkett published Women Leaving the Workplace, a book dedicated to helping American evangelical women quit their jobs and become homemakers. Placing Women Leaving the Workplace in historical context, this paper examines three moral problems in Burkett’s text: the problem of wage work, which took women from their children and left the home vulnerable; the problem of consumer culture, which depleted wages, distracted the family from spiritual pursuits, and resulted in debt; and the problem of dependency, particularly dependence upon welfare, which threatened the moral fiber of both the family and the nation. Burkett solved these problems by encouraging women to bring the workplace home—to import business practices into homemaking and to start home-based businesses. In contrast to the midcentury ideal of the housewife who depended on her husband’s wages, Burkett praised the female entrepreneur as a moral exemplar for an emerging postindustrial economy.

  • Abstract

    This presentation analyzes one of the world’s largest Hindu standardized testing systems by comparing the waged and unwaged intellectual labors of its test administrators and test-takers. In the early 1970s, the Swaminarayan Hindu sub-group called BAPS (the Bocasanwasi Akshar-Purushottam Sanstha) inaugurated a standardized testing system, which currently tests around 50,000 devotees annually, from young children to senior citizens. This presentation draws on 13 months of ethnographic fieldwork and interviews from 2018 in Ahmedabad, Gujarat and Chicago, Illinois, with the salaried devotees who administer the testing system and the transnational, unpaid devotees who study and complete the exams every year. Ultimately, I argue that both waged and unwaged devotees engage in knowledge production labor that is invaluable for BAPS as an institution. The small number of waged administrators produce the officially sanctioned theological and historical knowledge standards of BAPS, while the large numbers of unwaged test-takers generate quantifiable yet intimate data on the organization’s transnational community, which organizes and ranks their massive devotee following.

  • Abstract

    Who does the “work” of the Catholic Church in China? This paper documents Catholic nuns’ religious labor in the context of Chinese post-socialism. Drawing from Chinese nuns’ stories of trial and struggle, this article argues that the nuns engage in a labor of complaint. First, they perform various tasks on behalf of the Church. Second, they engage in communicative labor, via a Chinese linguistic genre known as “speaking bitterness,” to call attention to their under-compensation. Drawing from recent scholarly attention to complaint, this article highlights the thankless work that Chinese Catholic nuns perform to make their religious labor for the Church recognizable and the gendered social forces that inhibit their complaints from being heard. This multilayered process situates complaint not merely as communicative labor, but also as a phenomenon dependent upon everyday work—where the labor of complaint bridges multiple domains of work to stake claims for redress.    

  • Abstract

    This paper will use the Pallottine Fathers, an order of Catholic priests, to examine how new forms of fundraising challenged notions of religious “authenticity” in the twentieth-century United States. The Pallottine Fathers were pioneers of direct-mail fundraising in the early 1970s. The order sent out millions of pieces of mail every day, each one containing urgent pleas for money and heart-rending pictures of starving children. Pallottine letters also touted the “Pallottine sweepstakes,” with prizes ranging from dinner sets to new cars. This strategy was fabulously successful; the order raised millions. However, investigations revealed the Pallottines were using this money to build a real estate empire rather than to feed starving children. This paper will show how the “shadow economies” of religious fundraising cast a shadow on the American ideal of religious authenticity.