You are here

Online Program Book

PLEASE NOTE: We are working on making updates and edits to finalize the program. If you are searching for something and cannot find it, please reach out to annualmeeting@aarweb.org.

The AAR's inaugural Online June Sessions of the Annual Meetings were held on June 25, 26, and 27, 2024. For program questions, please reach out to annualmeeting@aarweb.org.

This is the preliminary program for the 2024 in-person Annual Meeting, hosted with the Society for Biblical Literature in San Diego, CA - November 23-26. Pre-conference workshops and many committee meetings will be held November 22. If you have questions about the program, contact annualmeeting@aarweb.org. All times are listed in local/Pacific Time.

P24-301

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Omni-Gaslamp 1 (Fourth Floor)

.

  • Fractured Imperial Hagiography, John of Ephesus and Imperializing Miaphysitism

    Abstract

    This paper will look at how John of Ephesus dialectically looks at the Empress Theodora as the pinnacle of Christendom while also seeing her as a subversive force in relation to Chalcedonian Orthodoxy. Looking at how John understands her religiously and morally in conversation with Procopius’s Anecdota, we see how hagiographies can construct and deconstruct moral identities within religious spaces. I will play these sources off each other to elucidate the hagiographic method that John applies to earthly power and further understand how people can create hagiographic identities during a person’s life. This paper will look at how the fractured nature of John’s Theodora narrative offers a different lens through which to witness hagiographic identity.

  • “‘The Most Beloved of All’: Love, the Abbess Gertrude of Hackeborn, and the Monastery of Helfta”

    Abstract

    Virtually every study of the monastery of Helfta remarks on the significance of its thirteenth-century Abbess Gertrude of Hackeborn (1223-92) to the extraordinary literary flourishing that took place during her forty-year tenure [N6:6:1, 205] when the  Helfta nuns collaboratively composed the largest body of women’s religious writing of the thirteenth century. When scholars have turned to the Helfta writings, their attention has for the most part alighted on the visionaries at the literature’s center, Mechtild of Hackeborn (the Abbess’ biological sister) and Gertrude of Helfta, her younger contemporary. My paper focuses on the Abbess Gertrude to argue that the Helfta literature presents her as embodying the piety the cloister sought to promote, with its focus on loving well.

  • Laughing at Empire: The Transgressive, Saintly Humor of Hrosvit's "Dulcitius"

    Abstract

    The tenth century canoness, Hrotsvit of Gandersheim, drew from hagiographic legenda in search of extraordinary figures, particularly women, to serve as protagonists in her dramas, crafted in the style of the Roman playwright Terence. This is aptly demonstrated in her work, Dulcitius, adapted, with no substantial changes in the plot, from the story of three sisters found in The Passion of Saint Anastasia. While the play begins with these women sentenced to death, the multiple attempts by the agents of the Roman empire to humiliate or assault them are subverted in particularly humorous ways, rendering the men in power and the empire they represent ridiculous. This paper will analyze the levels of transgression found in Hrotsvit’s Dulcitius arguing that a transgressive message of laughter “from below,” as outlined by Jacqueline A. Bussie, can be reclaimed from the work as humor uniquely disrupts dominant ideologies of empire and patriarchy.

A24-340

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Aqua 309 (Third Level)

"Extraordinary individuals (saints, sages, heroes, etc.) are often transgressors. They cross boundaries (actual and imagined), they break rules (sacred and profane), and they challenge norms (about sex, gender, class, etc.). How does the extraordinary status (or sanctity) of these individuals endow them with the power to transgress, for better and/or worse? How do those who honor such personages make sense of their transgressive power? What can this power tell us about the role of the extraordinary individual for the community that gathers in their wake?
In keeping with the collaborative ethos of the Hagiology Seminar, this roundtable will involve participation in three virtual conversations leading up to an in-person session at the 2024 AAR Annual Meeting."

A24-314

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Cobalt 500 (Fifth Level)

The Mīmāṃsā author Kumārila was one of the most formidable and determined critics of the Yogācāra philosophy and of the tradition of Buddhist epistemology that emerged within it. This session explores several aspects of his biting and brilliant critique and discusses what we can learn from it, both for our understanding of South Asian intellectual history and for philosophy today. Key topics to be discussed include the Buddhist concept of conventional truth, idealism, the dream argument, the "self-awareness" (svasaṃvedana) doctrine of Yogācāra and the memory argument for it, and whether an anti-realist, non-referential view of language can be internally consistent.

  • Metaphysics and the Problem of Language: Ślokavārttika as a Guide for the Interpretation of Yogācāra

    Abstract

    In vv. 3 - 83 of the Nirālambanavāda chapter of the Commentary in Verses (Ślokavārttika), Kumārila mounts a powerful critique of Yogācāra in the form of a response to the dream argument. This critique engages at the level of both metaphysics and philosophy of language. Kumārila argues that a Yogācārin who denies that our concepts have external percepts, based on the analogy of a dream, can make sense neither of goal-oriented motivation nor of perceptual error. And he turns the dream argument against itself, deftly arguing that its rejection of referential views of language deprives the proponent of the argument of the ability to understand either the argument itself or any aspect of Sanskrit debate. Since participants in South Asian debates were held accountable for representing each other’s arguments accurately, Kumārila’s account of Yogācāra may shed light on scholarly conversations about how to interpret the meaning of key Yogācāra teachings.

  • Kumārila against Instrumental Falsehoods

    Abstract

    In a brief exchange with his Buddhist opponent in the Nirālambanavāda (vv. 154-59), Kumārila argues that (non-referring) expressions like “the horn of a hare” cannot bring about correct ideas. His commentator, Uṃveka, understands this as having implications for the Buddhist conception of upāya, skillful means, and of saṃvṛtisat, conventional reality. Keating's paper unpacks Kumārila’s reasoning and considers its implications for both Buddhist opponents and the Mīmāṃsā hermeneutic project, which relies on arthavāda, motivating speech, that some have characterized as convenient fictions.

  • Computer Simulations and Conventional Truth: Responding to Kumārila's Double Critique

    Abstract

    This paper explores how defenders of Yogācāra might be able to respond to Kumārila’s critique by drawing on later developments in Buddhist philosophy and contemporary developments in technology. Examples of computer simulations, especially multiplayer games, show that environments in which everything that appears is an illusion can be characterized by both misperception and goal-oriented motivation, so long as they also exhibit intersubjectively robust causal regularities. Meanwhile, the spectacular self-destruction of the dream argument shows that a Yogācārin cannot afford to characterize conventional truth as false simpliciter. In this dialectical context, a key role could be played by the later distinction drawn by Buddhist epistemologists between a cognition’s being non-mistaken (abhrānta) and the distinct property of being non-deceptive (avisaṃvādaka).

  • Does Cognition Illumine Itself?

    Abstract

    It is a central claim of Yogācāra philosophy, defended by Dignāga and Dharmakīrti, that a cognition must apprehend itself in order to apprehend an object. Some believe this idea – known as the “self-awareness” (svasaṃvedana) doctrine – also to be central to certain European philosophical traditions (German idealism, Husserlian phenomenology). Building on previous work by Birgit Kellner and Alex Watson, this talk analyzes a key passage from Kumārila’s Ślokavārttika, Śūnyavāda chapter (vv. 179cd ff.), that critiques Dignāga’s so-called memory argument for this thesis – namely, that when one remembers something, one also remembers experiencing it. The passage reveals the complexity and sophistication of a Hindu-Buddhist controversy already at an early stage.

A24-315

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-33A (Upper Level East)

Presentations in this panel revolve around passages drawn from Śikṣānanda’s early eighth-century Chinese translation of the *Laṅkāvatārasūtra* (Taishō no.672), which is the focus of a new translation project. The *Laṅkāvatārasūtra* is well-known as an influential if also unorthodox source of Yogācāra-Vijñānavāda thought that was particularly impactful in East Asia. With reference also to other versions of the text, the panel will attend to key passages from Śikṣānanda’s version concerning aspects of earlier Buddhist thought inherited by the *Laṅkāvatārasūtra* and (re)formulated by it, including the substratum consciousness (*ālayavijñāna*), karmic ‘seeds’ that burden it (*bīja*), and some notion of ‘buddha-nature’ (*tathāgatagarbha*). In discussion, the panel will reflect on questions arising from translating Śikṣānanda’s Chinese into English: how best to render its philosophical and doctrinal profundity (and obscurity); what distinguishes it from our other versions of the text, and the perennial difficulties surrounding the translation of what are already translated Buddhist texts.

A24-316

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Sapphire 400A (Fourth Level)

The United States is undergoing paradigmatic demographic, religious, social, and political shifts. One of many resultant trends is the decline in certain historical institutions (religious, educational, etc.) and the rise and growth of others. Chaplaincy is not immune to these realities. Though historically linked to institutionally based health and clinical settings (hospitals, hospices, etc.), chaplaincy is quickly growing in new spaces: community, corporate, educational, athletic, etc. Bringing together insights from ACPE educators, administrators in theological education, and chaplaincy practitioners from different theological streams, along with empirical data, this roundtable will explore emerging spaces for spiritual care training and provision toward transformation and social justice. The panel will examine questions arising from these shifts and opportunities, such as how to define chaplaincy, models for forming and educating chaplains, and economically sustainable models of chaplaincy, with a particular focus on community chaplaincy.

A24-317

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-1B (Upper Level West)

Did poetical language and Buddhism co-create each other around the turn of the Common Era in South Asia? If so, how? And what are the implications for the beginnings of Indic literature and for the development of Buddhist, Vedic, Jain, and other literary and religious traditions of Asia? Our seminar hosts four research presentations on sources from early to early medieval South Asia, bringing them into conversation with each other through formal responses and general discussion. In this first session, Stephanie Jamison and Charles Hallisey examine the Rig Veda, Therīgāthā, Theragāthā, and other texts to revisit the historical problem of the beginnings of Indic literature and the role of Buddhist sources in contributing to forms of poiesis. Laurie Patton's and Thomas Mazanec's responses will broadly contextualize their presentations and raise questions in light of major scholarly paradigms concerning the history and development of Indic and Chinese literature.

  • “Kāvya in the Dark Ages: The Source and the Missing Link”

    Abstract

    In this paper, building on earlier work of my own, I will argue that the art poetry that dominated Classical Sanskrit literary culture, kāvya, has as its stylistic source the elaborate and self-conscious style of the earliest Sanskrit text, the Rig Veda. Despite the large chronological gap between the Rig Veda and Classical kāvya, and the apparent absence of this genre in Sanskrit in the intervening centuries, a missing link can be identified in the discourses of power in Middle Indic languages and in early Buddhist literary works. Both the similarities in poetic devices and the shaping of subject matter will be addressed, with ample examples.

     

  • Before Literature: Poeisis in the Poems of the First Buddhist Women and Men

    Abstract

    In his The Language of the Gods in the World of Men (2006), Sheldon Pollock argues that Buddhists played a key role in the “the astonishing expansion of the discursive realm of Sanskrit in the century or two around the beginning off the Common Era” (75). This is not only a historical issue. Pollock begins his exploration of this expansion self-consciously by saying, “To speak of beginnings, especially literary beginnings, is to raise a host of conceptual problems” (75). This paper explores how we see important literary beginnings in the Therīgāthā and the Theragāthā, collections of poems of the first Buddhist women and men, and how we can see in them traces of the protean emergence of Literature as a cultural form of poeisis in South Asia.  This conceptual exploration focusing on Pali texts suggests that the historical problem of the beginnings of Literature in India is ripe for reconsideration.

A24-318

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-24B (Upper Level East)

The two papers in this session consider issues in translation and retelling in the tradition of the _Mahābhārata_. Shankar Ramaswami’s paper compares the account in the _Mahābhārata_ of the snake sacrifice by Janamejaya with the retelling of it in Arun Kolatkar’s English poem “Sarpa Satra.” He argues that while Kolatkar’s poem suggests the contours of a non-anthropocentric vision of dharma (as that which sustains and promotes all life and the earth), this ideal is actually more fully developed in the critical edition of the _Mahābhārata_. Fred Smith’s paper approaches the ongoing project of translating the critical edition of the _Mahābhārata_ as an effort of retranslation, and describes the current publication plan. He compares examples from earlier efforts at translating segments of the text. Advances in translation methodology and cultural understanding can give greater focus to the meaning, intent, and comprehensibility of a received text.

  • Towards a Non-Anthropocentric Vision of Dharma: Violence, Nonviolence, and the Non-Human World in Arun Kolatkar’s Sarpa Satra (Snake Sacrifice)

    Abstract

    What is Arun Kolatkar’s reading of Janamejaya’s snake sacrifice and the burning of the Khandava forest, as depicted in the poem, Sarpa Satra (2004)?  If the poem describes the snake sacrifice as “cynical,” a “mockery”, and a “grotesque parody” of a yajna, what would constitute a true, proper yajna?  Why does Jaratkaru advise Astika to stop the sacrifice, not for the sake of the Nagas, but to save “the last vestige of humanity”?  In addressing these questions, I will argue that although Sarpa Satra seems to present an anthropocentric understanding of dharma (in which human beings should live and let other species live), there are materials in the poem that suggest the contours of a non-anthropocentric vision of dharma (as that which sustains and promotes all life and the earth), an ideal that is more fully developed in the critical edition of the Mahabharata.

  • Translation and retranslation: thoughts on methodology, with respect to the Mahābhārata

    Abstract

    Translation and retranslation: thoughts on methodology, with respect to the Mahābhārata

    This is a report on the present state of the Mahābhārata translation by Primus Books, Delhi, which is the completion of the translation of the Pune critical edition undertaken by the University of Chicago Press more than half a century ago, but now permanently suspended. At this point, more than half a century after van Buitenen commenced that translation and 140 years after Ganguli began the first translation of the complete Mahābhārata in Calcutta, we are best served by viewing the present project as a retranslation. This paper will examine some of the methodologies or retranslation, a subfield of translation studies, in order to appraise how advances in this field will help us to better understand the Indian national epic.

M24-301

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Marriott Marquis-Temacula 2 (North Tower - First Floor)

This session highlights the research of scholars associated with the Manchester Wesley Research Centre.
The first presentation will focus on Charles Wesley’s role in Methodist community formation in Bristol through his letters. The equalitarian marriage of eighteenth-century Methodists John and Mary (née Bosanquet) Fletcher is the subject of the second presentation. The final presentation will explore Thomas Coke’s attitudes and relationships with people of African descent.

  • Charles Wesley and the Formation of Community at Bristol (1749-1771)

    Abstract

    Charles Wesley moved to Bristol with his new bride, Sarah Gwynne, in 1749. They would live in Bristol until 1771, when they moved to London, although they continued to own their Bristol home. After the marriage, Charles initially resumed his itinerant ministry, but even after this ceased his presence in Bristol shaped the Methodist institutions nearby, including Kingswood School. This presentation will consider the years Charles spent at Bristol though an examination of his correspondence. It will concentrate on what can be learned about Charles Wesley’s formation of the community in and near Bristol through his letters.

  • “Twin-souls”: The Roots of Equalitarianism in the Marriage of John and Mary Fletcher

    Abstract

    This paper examines the marriage of eighteenth-century Methodists John and Mary (née Bosanquet) Fletcher, arguing that it had roots of equalitarianism. John and Mary’s relationship showed a mutual respect that Charles Wesley noticed. Wesley wrote to Mary Fletcher, “Yours I believe is one of the few marriages that are made in heaven . . . I sincerely rejoice that he [John Fletcher] has at last found out his Twin-soul, and trust you will be happier, by your meeting thro’ all eternity.” This research, supported by the Manchester Wesley Research Centre and the John Rylands Library draws on the Fletcher Tooth Collection in Methodist Archives of the John Rylands Library (University of Manchester). The paper argues that John and Mary Fletcher’s marriage provides an example for future equalitarian marriages.

  • The Apostle of Methodism: Thomas Coke’s Attitudes and Relationships with People of African Descent

    Abstract

    This paper explores Thomas Coke’s attitudes and relationships with people of African descent. During his lifetime Coke made eighteen voyages across the Atlantic Ocean, where he visited and preached in communities where Africans were enslaved in America and the West Indies. Utilizing primary sources, Coke’s letters and writings, and secondary sources, the paper will analyze the various experiences, relationships, and attitudes that Coke exhibited about Black people, including his advocacy on behalf of the rights of enslaved persons and the abolitionist cause. The paper makes the case that while Coke had a complex relationship with British colonialism, and worked within racist systems, his actions advanced the liberation of Black people.

A24-319

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-3 (Upper Level West)

The Lutheran tradition is not without its own history of colonialism and of working with governments to settle people on colonized lands around the world. Papers in this session engage historical, theological, and other perspectives that critically address the complexity of past or present relationships between Lutheran theology, land appropriation, indigenous rights and settler colonialism. This session also reflects towards future possibilities for action and scholarship.

  • Changing the settler colonial subject: Lutherans among the Bafokeng and Sioux

    Abstract

    In many contexts Lutheranism has been deeply entangled with settler colonial efforts to appropriate Indigenous lands for white settlers within an extractivist capitalist economy while seeking to eliminate the Indigenous population. However, there are notable exceptions to this dominant arrangement of Lutheranism and white settler colonialism that involves important Indigenous agency within a settler colonial order. This paper contrasts such different relationships between Lutheran churches, white settler colonialism, and Indigenous populations by describing the situation of the Southern African ELCSA church and the North American ELCA. Specifically, this paper compares the relationship of the ELCSA and the Bafokeng in the North West Province with that of the ELCA and Indigenous peoples in North Dakota, including these churches’ relationships to Indigenous lands and resource extraction.

  • Lutheranism in Brazil 1824-2024 - Settlers' Impact and the Struggle for Citizenship

    Abstract

    Lutheran churches in Brazil have emerged through migration from 1824. The paper argues that there were three struggles for its citizenship: a first one in the 19th century for the civil rights of immigrant settlers. At the same time, black and indigenous people were fought as enemies. With expanding pan-Germanic tendencies after 1871, not too few claimed the "Protestant church and Germanness must remain indissolubly linked". The second struggle for citizenship, after 1945, implied the clear positioning as a Brazilian church. This was severely tested under the military regime (1964-85). From 1970 onwards, the church took an increasingly critical stance on issues of democracy, civil rights, and issues of social justice in its third struggle for citizenship: standing up for others' rights. However, prejudice and land struggles against indigenous peoples continue. The Bolsonaro government (2019-22) brought to the fore a strong polarization between ministers and members around such issues.

  • Hegemonic Humans? The Norwegian Sami struggle for indigenous rights and a close-to-nature theology of creation.

    Abstract

    Historically, Norway is constituted by Sami tribes and Norse settlers. These historical groups are still referenced, and in 2013 a conflict evolved between Sami tribes and the Norwegian state. The state will erect 277 wind turbines on a specific site, not taking into account that the location is an important Sami winter pasture for reindeer. Huge wind turbines disturbing 2000 grazing reindeer may violate the Sami people's rights. Despite protests, the government decided (March 6, 2024) to build the turbines as planned. As a consolation, Sami reindeer herders are promised “compensation”. I will use this complex case to ask “Who are the ‘hegemonic humans’ in Norwegian thinking and theology?” I will discuss the case by comparing two influential traditions: inherited Sami Nature Spirituality and modern Scandinavian Creation Theology.

  • Custer Died For Our Sins: Vine Deloria, Jr., Theologia Crucis, and the Work of Settler Repair

    Abstract

    Fifty years ago, Dr. Vine Deloria’s challenged American white settler churches to begin an “honest inquiry by yourselves into the nature of your situation,” a situation where “you have taught [humanity] to find its identity in a re-writing of history.” Turning to Vitor Westhelle’s *After Hersey*, my “beginning of honest inquiry” interrogates the pseudo-theologies that funded European colonialism and settler claims to Indigenous lands in what became the United States. Deploying an anti-colonial *theologia crucis*, I follow Westhelle’s critique of the history of European colonialism allowing “naming the thing for what it is.” This theological approach then funds a critical look at my own family story of pioneer life in the Upper Midwest chronicled famously by my relative Laura Ingalls Wilder. I conclude with a case study of the Northeastern Synod of the ELCA engaging in truth telling and repair in relationship to the Minnesota Chippewa Tribe.

A24-320

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Sapphire 400B (Fourth Level)

The central question for this roundtable discussion is, How do we, as scholars of religion, teach about the Middle East? This question recalls the deep historical roots of Jewish, Christian, and Muslim traditions in the region and the contemporary diversity of those communities. This question is also pressing in light of the current events and the requests for information that many of us are receiving from other scholars, students, and members of our broader communities. What pedagogical approaches should we consider for courses focusing specifically on the Middle East, for courses that can only touch briefly on the region, or for other venues in which we may be asked to teach about the Middle East? What resources are available – including textbooks, audio/visual sources, and digital tools – for teaching and understanding the region and its religious communities?

A24-321

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-24A (Upper Level East)

This session will explore the relationship between trauma, moral injury and meaning-making through engagement with the work of psychiatrist Judith Herman.  The papers range from a theoretical examination of these relationships in a theological sense, an exploration of visions of commual repair in the aftermath of moral injury, and an exploration of the challenges to conceptualizations of harm, punishment and justice offered through Herman's work for those imprisoned and facing execution in the US criminal justice system.  

  • The Heart Keeps the Score: Judith Herman and the Moral Context of Trauma Theology

    Abstract

    While trauma studies are gaining popularity, increased public awareness trades on reductive summaries that elide the moral context of trauma in favor of stress-based models acceptable to modern medicine. This creates unique challenges for integrating trauma studies into morally saturated disciplines like theology, especially when those disciplines foreground existential insights from trauma as with the emerging sub-discipline of “trauma theology.” In this paper, I draw from moral injury research to resource what I call “morally expansive” approaches to trauma theology. Using Bessel van der Kolk’s work as a foil, I suggest that Judith Herman’s recent addition of a fourth stage to her famous threefold stages of trauma recovery signals the need for recovering moral contexts in interdisciplinary trauma research. In van der Kolk’s terms, I conclude that while the body may be the “scoreboard” of trauma, it is the moral center (the heart”) of a person that keeps that score.

  • Community-based Reparative Action as Moral Injury Recovery

    Abstract

    This paper will contend with Judith Herman’s recent publication, Truth and Repair (2023) bridging Herman’s emphasis on trauma and justice with best practices of recovery in the aftermath of moral injury. Because moral injury is social-relational in nature, recovery must integrate pro-social reparative action rooted in an engaged, trustworthy and compassionate community. This paper will highlight three community-based reparative action approaches – community service, activism, and Restorative Justice practices. These approaches are effective: (1) by functioning as an engaged, trustworthy, and compassionate community; and (2) by exercising moral responsibility as a collective matter not an individual pathology. The Western clinical-medical paradigm is not capable of fully addressing the needs of the moral injured because it is not designed to respond to the demands created by moral transgressions (i.e. injustices). Without community-based reparative action a person can develop a learned helplessness resulting in worsening social-relational isolation, destructive behaviors, depression, and suicidality.

  • Moral Injury on Death Row

    Abstract

    This paper addresses the issue of moral injury within the American penal system, by exploring its realities in the context of Death Row. Those imprisoned have profound experiences of moral injury, requiring exploration.  It describes the key elements of moral injury in terms of its symptomology and etiology, paying particular attention to the devastation of moral identity through the experience of catastrophic violence. It delineates the ways penal practice exacerbates rather than redresses moral injury, and considers the consequences of this.   It then turns its attention to the voices of the victims of moral injury within our penal system, and to the theorists and practitioners of repair, especially Judith Herman, in order to delineate healing modalities for both practice and policy.  Key informants include insiders on death row, attorneys, judges and other participants in the system, as well as military and Veterans Administration Chaplains, who work with morally wounded warriors.

A24-322

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Aqua 314 (Third Level)

This session centers the history and perspectives of Kumeyaay peoples, the Indigenous peoples of San Diego. In 1769, The Mission San Diego de Alcalá, became the first Spanish Colonial Mission that sought to colonize California Native peoples. The Kumeyaay fought to dismantle the Spanish mission, the Mexican government, and later, the American colonial system. They continue to steward their ancestral homelands. Contemporary Kumeyaay include tribal members and their descendants from multiple Kumeyaay Bands in San Diego County and northwestern Mexico. This session focuses on the intricacies of Kumeyaay Spirituality and Religious intersections in cities, reservation communities, and beyond. Highlighting historical moments within Kumeyaay history, we will explore how “Spirituality,” prior to the settler colonial encroachment, laid the foundational understanding of relationality and reciprocity of all things. Lastly, we will consider how Kumeyaay Spirituality and Religion has changed over time, influencing how tribal communities relate to “tradition” through a contemporary lens.

A24-323

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-7B (Upper Level West)

Embracing a geographically capacious definition of "North American religions," this panel features research papers that explore religious life in different locations across the Americas. The first paper focuses on the Nahua people of Mexico and considers the ontological foundations of their cultural perseverance and resistance to colonization. The second paper centers on Hawaii and investigates how Korean immigrants drew on notions of America as "white Christian nation" to advance nativist views of Japanese Americans. The final paper focuses on the U.S./Mexico borderland and considers the religious dynamics of tents and tented events in that region. All together, these papers invite a comparative and transnational approach to the study of American religion that reaches across and beyond national boundaries.

  • Nahua Ontological Contributions Towards Perseverance: A Telling through Modern Voices arising from Interviews

    Abstract

    Following the 16th Century invasion of the Anahuac by Hernán Cortés different forms of assimilation, acculturation, accommodation took place amongst the Nahua people throughout the centuries. Notwithstanding, the Nahua resisted and persevered to become an enduring people. A distinct Nahua ontology, in contrast to Western forms of ontology arising from Aristotle and a consequent arising therefrom - namely, an emphasis on imagination - has contributed to Nahua perseverance. A result of the Nahua worldview is an emphasis on work, discipline, and penance. This is expressed in collective community, obligations to the earth, and self-identity with respect for difference. An inclusion of variety of modern Nahua voices, arising from interviews across Mexico is included to support these claims. These voices also shed light on the past, particularly where the Nahua fell at diverse times on the three pillar modalities which facilitate change in subaltern-dominant group interactions: assimilation, acculturation, accommodation.

  • The Foreign Nativist: Tracing Korean Immigrants’ Racial Consciousness in a “Christian Land”

    Abstract

    This paper explores how religion played a central role in the understanding of US citizenship and racial categorizations during World War II, centering on Haan Kilsoo, a Korean immigrant who firmly supported a nativist viewpoint toward Japanese Americans. Drawing from public statements, correspondence between intelligence agencies, legal documents, news articles, and letters, this paper examines how Korean immigrants like Kilsoo claimed their loyalty to the States by drawing from the predominant idea of America as a “White Christian nation” in Korean immigrant communities. Korean immigrants’ understanding of race as intertwined with religious affiliation helped many to disassociate themselves from the broader racial category of “Asian,” particularly during a time in which Korean immigrants were negotiating between their racialization in the States and the colonization of their homeland by the Japanese empire.  

  • The Subjects that Tents Make: The Architecture of Early Pentecostal Missions, Mexican Circuses, and Detention Camps in the US/Mexico Borderlands

    Abstract

    This paper examines three kinds of tents and tented events that have been erected and coordinated in the US/Mexico borderlands, particularly Texas. The first two, early Pentecostal missionary meetings designed to convert Mexican people, and semi-local, small Mexican circuses, or *carpas,* coincided in the nineteen teens and early nineteen twenties. The third, tented migrant detention camps run by the US Immigrations and Customs Enforcement and the Border Patrol, especially those used to detain minors seperated from their caregivers, exploded across the borderlands and the national consciousness almost exactly one hundred years after the heyday of missionary tents and *carpas.* The paper details the similarities of the material infrastructure of the tent at all three sites, noting how the tent form offers a set of affordances and connotations that enable and constrain three distinct subject-making enterprises. 

A24-324

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-11B (Upper Level West)

Secularism’s (or the secular’s) role in the constitution of coloniality has been underattended in the fields of religious studies and decolonial theory. In The Coloniality of the Secular, An Yountae investigates the collusive ties between the modern concepts of the secular, religion, race, and coloniality in the Americas, as well as decoloniality’s conception of the sacred. In this roundtable, scholars at the intersection of philosophy of religion, postcolonial and decolonial theories, black religious thought, Christian theology, feminist study of religion, and theories of secularization and postsecularity come together to celebrate the publication of and respond to the arguments of The Coloniality of the Secular.

A24-325

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Indigo 202B (Second Level)

This roundtable session features a conversation about Karma and Grace: Religious Difference in Millennial Sri Lanka (Columbia University Press, 2023), by Neena Mahadev. The anthropological and ethno-historical study examines Theravada Buddhist and Christian political-theological entanglements over conversion. While Sri Lankan Pentecostals and other Born-again Christians publicize “the Good News” (Sinhala, Subha Aranchiya), the work interrogates what happens to this “news” when it is propagated among subsets of a population that sharply resists it. Karma and Grace elucidates why questions of religious belonging became a revived source of conflict in a country that had been so long afflicted by ethnic war. The book proposes a “multicameral” methodological and theoretical approach to the study of pluralism. The author and three commentators will discuss how the book contributes to the anthropology of Christianity, the anthropology of Buddhism, religion and media, and debates on pluralism, political theologies, and the politics of religious freedom.

A24-326

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-28D (Upper Level East)

The new boom in research and interest in non-human sentience and sapience (in particular, “critical plant studies” and the Rights of Nature movement) calls for a deeper theoretical engagement with ethics, ontology, religious studies, and metaphysics. This panel explores the biological and ethical promises of these new frameworks, while critically analyzing their incompleteness. While welcoming the agency and personhood of our non-human kin is one way to enter into deeper, and perhaps decolonial, relationships with the more-than-human world, this panel explores the complexities involved, asking questions like: When do our frameworks of analysis perpetuate the very violence and colonial assumptions we seek to do away with? When do our imaginaries and cosmologies promote ecological hope? And what philosophical and religious frameworks can create mutually beneficial relationships nonhumans? Muslim environmentalism, Black Studies, Hindu perspectives on animals, Buddhist perspectives on trees, Dark Green Religion, and Korean mythology on big cats are considered.

  • Celestial Bodies, Terrestrial Troubles: Non-Human Agency and Ecological Violence in W.E.B. Du Bois’s ‘The Comet’ and Black Panther: Wakanda Forever

    Abstract

    This paper explores the role of non-human agency in addressing ecological violence through the lens of W.E.B. Du Bois's "The Comet" and Black Panther: Wakanda Forever. Employing the concept of "melancholic hope," the paper argues that by centering celestial bodies and non-human entities, these works of speculative fiction challenge anthropocentric narratives and expose the slow violence of systemic racism, imperialism, and extraction. Drawing on religious frameworks that consider non-human sentience and sapience, this paper examines how marginalizing these perspectives perpetuates ecological imbalance and undermines the sacred equilibrium necessary for the survival of all species. Engaging with literature and art that re-centers the non-human nurtures our moral imagination and makes possible alternative paradigms for a more inclusive and sustainable Anthropocene. This paper invites scholars of religion to consider the transformative potential of melancholic hope in fostering a responsible and empathic relationship with our planetary cousins.

  • The Knowing Nonviolence of Trees

    Abstract

    One of the little examined margins of ecological thought is the kinship between human and arboreal beings. The recent emergence of “critical plant studies” tries to remedy this, and we find ourselves in the midst of a boom of popular books on trees. Both graft enchantment at trees’ newly (re)discovered sentience and sociality onto inherited ideas of sacred groves, world trees and the apparently unstinting generosity of trees. Entwining easily with what Bron Taylor calls “dark green religion,” these discussions also often recapitulate dubious ideas of planty passivity and selflessness which are both biologically and ethically incomplete. In this talk I weave together representative contemporary discussions with the more complicated and profound sentience and sociality of the enlightenment-hosting ficus religiosa and the San Diego native Torrey Pine, precious to the Kumeyaay, to ask: what can trees teach us about the spirituality of non-violence?

  • The Gaze: The Companionship among the Colonized Animals

    Abstract

    This paper explores the entangled reality of coloniality in the relationship between human and non-human animals, drawing on the insights of Jacques Derrida and Donna Haraway as well as the gaze of Beom in the Korean tradition. Derrida generates a profound rupture in the discussion of human and non-human animals where the problems of ability and passivity resurface through the symbolic actions of gazing and naming. Haraway expands on Derrida’s insights, advocating for an interdisciplinary approach that incorporates a more comprehensive understanding of animals. In furthering this discussion, I invite beom, Korean-origin big cats, to serve as a lens through which to explore animals and animality from a non-Western tradition and reveal the intersection among colonialism, Western imperial power, and the naming of species. Through the gaze of the beom, the notion of passivity in animality will be challenged by a deeper appreciation for the shared experience of living together.

  • When conferrals of “humanity” and “personhood” beget violence: an ethical examination of animal-human relations

    Abstract

    When does the recognition of “humanity” or “personhood” to nature’s bodies enable, rather than restrict, certain kinds of violences? I focus on a few key examples: bestiality practices in medieval England, the violent taming of wild elephants in 19th century Malaya, and the sacrifices of goats to deities in rural India. In understanding the relationship between ontology and violence, does it matter what kind of “violence” we are discussing, whether it is operating within an intimately interpersonal home or at the large-scale of mass factories? How can thinking with Black scholars, such as Saidiya Hartman and Zakiyyah Jackson, give us resources to understand when recognition of humanity licenses, rather than restricts, violence? For those who are invested in both more-than-human cosmologies and environmentalism, we need a more precise ontological and ethical framework than a generic respect of agency or personhood of nature’s bodies to conceptualize nature-human relations.

A24-327

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Cobalt 502A (Fifth Level)

Global Perspectives on Religion and Food

  • Pyramidal Prejudices: Fatphobia, Faith, and Femininity in Multi-Level Marketing Companies

    Abstract

    In multi-level marketing companies (MLMs), agents sell products and assemble sales teams, ‘downlines’, from whose sales they receive a commission. MLMs are popular but controversial due to pyramid distribution models that favour few agents who join early and their reliance on sales to friends/families. MLMs appeal to women by emphasizing flexibility, family, domesticity, positivity, and empowerment; however, this may not account for the unpaid, invisible, and emotional labour endured by MLM agents. MLMs recruit members of religious groups that may endorse certain gender roles and body expectations. Many MLMs sell weight-loss products, which draw from harmful body, gendered faith, and corporatized empowerment messages. This paper will report on the preliminary development of a ‘pyramidal prejudices’ framework based on a literature review and multi-modal critical discourse analysis of MLMs’ social media posts that considers the fatphobic, faith, and post-feminist aspirational labour discourses of MLMs, which help shape their influence.

     

  • Reimagining Foodscapes: On sociality and memory-work in Cape Malay Cooking

    Abstract

    The paper explores the intersections between food as a repository and archive of memory and connection to the past, the lingering presence of apartheid and the colonial history of slavery in the Cape, and the contemporary sociality of food-making in the context of a Muslim community in Cape Town. Drawing on a genealogy of Cape Malay food history, the paper discusses the ways in which the contemporary making of Cape Malay/Capetonian Muslim foods evoke, ascertain and imagine embodied foodscapes of the past and of the present. The paper is particularly attentive to narratives connecting the present to the presence of the past and the subversive potential of food-making. That is, food as memory-work and edible acts of re-membering, food as offering a site for contestation of the dominant legacies of the past, and food as a powerful aromatic response to histories of erasure, displacement and marginalisation.

  • Unfurling Ashram Life: Who Takes the Center Stage?

    Abstract

    Ashram communities, today, are largely defined by their guru and mostly always, His, bloated reputation. In this, we miss people’s practices, engagement with rituals, which rarely, if ever, inform ashram life. Visiting an ashram in Vrindavan, Unfurling Ashram Life pays close attention to mango for its ability to unfurl ashram life. So often things that seem inherently religious—Gods, guru, or sacred texts—inform our understandings of religion. A piece of fruit like mango is consumed and thrown away, without much thought about its entanglements constituting ashram-specific rituals, as well as conceptions about guru, bhakti, seva, gender, caste and class dynamics, Islamophobia, climate change, colonialism, and South Asia. This paper is an ethnography about mango, including the mango-inspired paisley design inside a Vrindavan ashram.

A24-328

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-26A (Upper Level East)

This panel session is a collaborative effort between the Religion Migration Unit and the International Women's Caucus. The category of gender is a central factor to any discussion of migration including the causes, characteristics, and consequences of migration. This session explores how gendered cross-border relationships, including different and diverse types of marriage, are shaped by and shape the dynamics of religion and migration. Engaging Jordanian, Korean, and American contexts, the papers draw on a variety of methodological approaches to analyze and assess the significance of gender as an analytical category as well as an activist category in the current geopolitical context.

  • Decision to Leave: A Theological Reflection on Orpah and the Cross-border Female Marriage Immigrants in South Korea

    Abstract

    This article is a theological exploration into the marginalization of Cross-border female marriage immigrants within Korean churches. The author employs a feminist interpretation of Orpah from the book of Ruth—the Moabite widow who chose to return to her mother’s house—to challenge the conventional expectations held by the Korean government, families, and churches that marginalize cross-border marriage immigrants: the unquestioning assimilation into the cultural norms and the performance of the traditional female roles. By revisiting Orpah’s courageous decision not to renounce her mother’s house, the author explores how her story can empower immigrant women not only to retain and pass down their cultures but firmly believe that their decision will be met with blessings (1:8b). Furthermore, by highlighting Naomi’s role in encouraging and blessing Orpah, the author underscores the church’s responsibility to foster a safe environment for women to express themselves rather than legitimizing marginalization.

  • La Fuerza de Voluntad Among Hispanic/Latine Catholic Married Couples: A Hopeful and Imaginative Discernment Towards a Spirituality of Migration

    Abstract

    The U.S. reality is permeated with migration waves that have led to a Hispanic/Latine population of over 62 million. In the present essay, I assess how a sample of Latine married couples within a Catholic parish discern a home outside their birthplace. I interrogate how such a community seeks, creates, and implements a spirituality of migration born out of the struggles before, during, and after the process of forced mobility. I enter this journey by sharing some of the most valuable lessons on the migration journey these couples have had via interviews. I clarify the terms of in-between, lo cotidiano, la lucha, accompaniment, vocation, and Christian Spirituality through the import of relevant theologians and spiritual writers who offer vital wisdom to this complex reality. Finally, attention is given to the implications of an emerging spirituality of migration as this group discerns how to build a home away from home.  

  • The Ambiguity of Justice: Imam Marriages, Gender Security and Human Rights among Syrian Refugees in Jordan

    Abstract

    This paper focuses on a particular type of Islamic marriage, so-called imam marriages, which are not recognised by the Jordanian state but widely practised among and with Syrian refugees since their influx to Jordan in 2011. State institutions and European faith-based organisations advocate the registration of religious marriages on the basis of fulfilling UN conventions on gender and human rights.

    Through a case study of Syrian refugees in Jordan, this paper offers new insights into the ambiguity inherent in the enforcement of marriage registration and the impact of humanitarian interventions on gender rights and the safety of displaced individuals in the Middle East. It further highlights the need for a nuanced understanding of gender justice and security and underscores the importance of considering the broader implications of such interventions, particularly on the lives and well-being of displaced people in the global south.

A24-329

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Hilton Bayfront-Aqua Salon AB (Third Level)

In a time of cultural divide and stark polarization, this panel highlights case study of religiously motivated solidarity with the marginalized and the implications of such solidarity for paradigms of citizenship and democratic beloning. The first urges us to look again at the Azusa Revial through the lens of queer theology to illuminate the anti-normative perspective on democratic citizenship preached within.  The second examins Jewish opinion magazines and how one in particular moved beyond its typical Jewish focus to embrace intersectional feminist activism. The third explores case studies of Christian solidarity with Palestine and the embodiment and risks of such action.

  • Normativity, Citizenship, and Political Imagination: Keri Day’s Azusa Reimagined in Conversation with Queer Thought

    Abstract

    Violence and marginalization are woven through U.S. political life. One critical conversation in recent years centers on normativity in U.S. citizenship, a thread that theologian Keri Day picks up in her 2022 publication, Azusa Reimagined: A Radical Vision of Religious and Democratic Belonging. In Azusa Reimagined, Day explores the Azusa Revival in the context of U.S. racial capitalism and uses queer scholarship to examine Azusa’s anti-normative vision and practice of citizenship. While queer theory and queer theology serve as important resources for the book, I argue that Day’s constructive proposal for political moodiness and a project of radical inclusion, belonging, and intimacy risks shoring up rather than effectively resisting the normativity paradigm it seeks to contest. Ultimately, the project would benefit from deeper engagement with negative theology of queer theologian, Marcella Althaus-Reid, to reframe its conclusions and enrich ongoing discussions around normativity, violence, and U.S. citizenship. 

  • Jewish opinion magazines, intersectionality, and the Obama era culture wars

    Abstract

    Intersectional feminism entered mainstream American social discourse at the end of Obama’s presidency. How did two Jewish opinion magazines from different ends of the ideological spectrum, namely the neoconservative Commentary and Tikkun on the liberal left, address this phenomenon? The presentation focuses on the discourse concerning the emergence of intersectionality, which was one of the key elements of the culture wars that took place – mostly online – during the mid-2010s. The presentation shows how the political outlooks of the magazines affected the ways in which intersectionality was embraced, rejected or questioned in their writings. Additionally it offers analysis on how the Jewish background and profile of both publications affected their approaches to the topic.

  • Costly Solidarity: Case Studies in Global Christian Solidarity with Palestine

    Abstract

    This paper explores global movements of Christian solidarity with Palestine. Within the theoretical frames of decolonial theory and liberation theology, we delve into the practical application of these approaches within Christian movements supporting Gaza and broader Palestine since October 7th, 2023. Furthermore, we also argue  that confronting Christian Zionism and its roots in empire can act as community-centered decolonial practice in these spaces. Using two case studies, we examine the transformative power of these movements on theology, liturgy, and ritual. Our first case study examines a South African-led delegation of Christian leaders who traveled to Bethlehem to witness Rev. Munther Isaac's sermon "Christ in the Rubble" as a powerful act of solidarity. Our second case study focuses on global Gaza Ceasefire Pilgrimage during Lent. Together with our theoretical foundations, these examples reveal how Christian communities worldwide are engaging in embodied protest and ritualized solidarity across diverse geographic and cultural landscapes.

A24-330

Sunday, 3:00 PM - 4:30 PM

Convention Center-30E (Upper Level East)

In a continuation of last year's two sessions comprising our "shadow conference," this session of lightning talks too will offer a series of critical questions and reflections on academic experience under its contemporary structural conditions of exhaustion, minoritizing and differential violence, labor exploitation, precarity, and breakdown. Presenters will consider how these structural conditions feel -- how we respond affectively to these conditions -- as well as how affective responses can interrupt or potentially reconstitute or alter these conditions. Each presenter will speak integratively both from their subjective experience, and from their area of expertise. In the foreground: if contemporary academia works its exploitation and violence through entrapment, containment, and perpetual stuckness, how might we leverage feeling and sensation to mobilize ourselves?

  • Academoniacs Roaming the Tombs of Higher Ed

    Abstract

    This paper considers the academy, i.e., the proverbial ivory tower, as a sort of empire that occupies and overwhelms those in its shadow. Like the Geresene demoniac in the Gospel of Luke, there are many living among the tombs of lost careers and relationships in higher education. The graves are filled with those who could not publish, or publish enough, and have perished. I find myself among the tombs. How does it feel to grieve such a loss? How does one exhume the bodies for an autopsy? Engaging theories of affect in conversation with the Lukan story of the Geresene demoniac, I argue for affective eulogizing that attends to the mourning and open grief of what has been lost. 

  • Affective Challenges of the German Academic Precariat Through Gender, Race, and Class

    Abstract

    Hanna was the name of a character through which The Federal Ministry of Education and Research in Germany illustrated the shortening of the time the contracts in order to assure innovation, creativity and circulation in a short animation. Hanna was portrayed as a young white, childless, middle-class person. In reaction to this, #IchbinHanna (I am Hanna) was the hashtag created in 2021 and widely used on social media to counter this image and protest increasingly scarce permanent positions and precarisation in the German academy. The precarity is intensified when one has children, performs care work or when competitive and dependent relationships arise between professors and others. One feature of German science is also its claim to ‘neutrality’, which puts any kind of so-called political engagement that restricts the contours of knowledge production. In this talk I give a public/personal account of catching up with ‘Hanna’ from an intersectional perspective.

  • Between Interest, Guilt, and Pleasure: Reading in and out of Academic Time

    Abstract

    Centered on the experience of losing oneself while reading, this personal essay explores the relationship between academic time lost when reading for pleasure and academic pleasure lost when reading to maximize time. Emerging out of engagement with the work of Kathleen Stewart (2007), Donovan Schaefer (2022), Sara Ahmed (2010), Margaret Price (2011), and others, it asks: if we’re choosing this academic life out of interest, curiosity, and passion, why do we so often stifle our pleasure? Why do we try so hard to reel in the “ordinary affects” that draw us into unexpected places, encounters, and experiences of time (Stewart, 2007)? While answers like capitalism, neoliberalism, and university-as-business offer insight, none of these click—none satisfy the emotional longing behind this “why” (Schaefer, Wild Experiment, 2022). This essay aims to sit with the dissatisfaction.

  • Finding Ways to Move in Joy

    Abstract

    Academia often seems overwhelming and potentially created to destroy us. Yet, it can also be a place to explore the possibilities of joy. In this paper, I draw on Gilles Deleuze’s interpretation of Baruch Spinoza’s concepts of joy as the ability to move. If we think about joy as the ability to move, what possibilities open to us? My experience in the lighting presentation last year crafted a shared recognition of the construction of academia today as a machine that attempts to inhibit our movement. But also, the presentations recognized points of hope, of the ability to make change and movement happen within our oftentimes oppressive systems. This paper will encourage audience members to think through where places of movement exist in their own lives as ways to cultivate and encourage joy.

  • Rules of War: The Wartime Organization of Feeling in James Cone’s Black Theology and Black Power.

    Abstract

    In this paper, I reframe Cone’s 1969 work as a work of revolutionary theology that reorganizes affect and emotion. Through his theology, James Cone declares war, turning Christian conceptions of love and reconciliation on their heads, putting forth a theological discourse that finds a way to be Christian and Black, and to do so with feeling. By renarrating Christian discourses with suffering Black bodies at the center, Cone creates a Black theological affective economy, placing emotion front and center in the Black theological project.